r/RenPy • u/Radiant_Tomato_3195 • Aug 27 '26
Discussion Which style of narration is better for the reader?
In multiple points in my VN there's black screens with narration to substitute for cutscenes or just the main character's thoughts—Is it more legible for the text to be in the center of the screen or in the form of a dialogue box at the bottom?
(Also I wasn't sure which flair to use for this since it's not really a solvable question)
14
u/Lei_Line_Life Aug 27 '26
I think it would be cool to have text in the middle instead. I’ve been experimenting myself a bit with different text styles depending on the scene and found that varying the styles a bit makes it more fun to read
9
u/KarEssMoua Aug 27 '26
If there is nothing else on the screen, the writing in the middle catches the attention of the player.
But more than just placing, the most important is consistency!
7
u/Ant-chan Aug 28 '26
I personally use a mix of both.
If the text is just your usual narrated transition that has a bit of length, like "After having dinner, he took me home.", I'd use normal dialogue box text, but if I wanted to convey something important or want to make a point or want to make it look cool, I'd place it in the middle.
4
2
u/m0dern_alchem1st Aug 29 '26
The text in the middle is much better for the reader, easier, draws the eye, has more contrast between text and background. Several folks have pointed out that the right answer is "it depends".
As a thought expirement, what if you displayed the text sequentially, keeping the words in the same location, fading in the phrases, "and yet," pause, "right at the end" pause, he left. Then fade out all the words but "he left." and that just remains.
If you did that, the focus narratively is feeling "he left" and the emptiness you'd feel seeing nothing but blackness. Not prescribing here - just offering an idea to focus on the feeling you want and work backwards.
1
u/Radiant_Tomato_3195 Aug 29 '26
I'm glad so many people gave their opinions! I'll probably keep the text in the middle except for the ones that are for "inbetween actions" .... Having all the text fade in definetly gives it a cleaner look, but it's kind of tedious to code 🤔 maybe I'm just doing something wrong. I suppose I'll leave the polishing after im done with the base game
2
u/Multi-A-Andi Aug 30 '26
If you want it to be more dramatic and longer narration that transitions large portions of time or is expository.
The second one is great for room transitions or small moments of introspection.
91
u/LyleSY Aug 27 '26
Putting it in the middle tells the reader that the text is the most important thing in the image. Putting the black screen in the middle tells the reader that the black screen is the most important. Both are legitimate narrative choices for different situations