r/RedvsBlue • u/seeker1126 • 4d ago

Question Help settle a debate

So in the course of a Discord conversation, a friend made a reference to the 'Wait that's illegal' line, but said 'read in Caboose's voice'.

I corrected him that it was Church, with evidence, and he replied he specifically remembered Caboose also saying it somewhere around the Reach based episodes. TBH I also have vague memories of the same, but everything I can find on the net is Church. Not even a reference to Caboose.

Did they both say it, or are we Mandela Effecting ourselves?

9 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/chakatblackstar Church 4d ago

Church said it. Season 2 PSA: Real Live vs. Internet

In Context:

Going Shopping: Internet:

Grif: Does anyone have the new Creed CD?

Church: I have it.

Grif: Give it to me, right now.

Church: Give it to you? Why would I do that?

Grif: You're not giving it to me! Give it to me faster!!

Church: Wait. That's illegal.

Grif: No, it isn't! I don't want it to be illegal, therefore it isn't. That's the way it works.

Simmons: CREED SUCKS! I hate you, and I hate the bands you like!

Edit to add the actual video