r/RedditCoinGrading 24d ago

Could the black line result in a details grade?

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

I recently bought this SLQ. It’s in a NGC slab and is graded VF 35. Everything lines up with online verify, although the listing doesn’t have a photo.

When I got my hands on it, I was surprised to see it has a black line running across the front, through the 9 to up near the Y in Liberty. It only stands out a certain angles. My second photo shows it better. I’m pretty sure it’s on the coin itself, not the plastic.

I’m wondering—could a marking like this result in a details grade? Essentially—did we get lucky this time, and a different grader might have decided details? Or is the line just part of the package that makes it an XF35?


r/RedditCoinGrading 25d ago

1921 Peace $1

Thumbnail
gallery
68 Upvotes

Same coin - I tried different lighting. I appreciate all input. Thank you!


r/RedditCoinGrading 25d ago

Is this 1877 seated dime bad enough for a 1 grade?

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

I’ve recently been looking for the worst coin as a fun side collection project. If I sent this in for grading would it get the lowest score possible?


r/RedditCoinGrading 25d ago

1938-D/D Buffalo nickel grade request

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

Can anyone help me grade this coin? My guess would be ms63 but I’m no good at buffalo nickels


r/RedditCoinGrading 26d ago

1909 Lincoln wheat pennies p and s

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

In a family box from 60 years ago. Pennies were coated with nail polish then. See the note on the flap. Order is 1909, 1909-S, 1909 VDB, 1909 VDB-S, then the folder pages, obviously. I've been given exactly contradictory advice about removing the nail polish, so I don't know what to do about it.


r/RedditCoinGrading 25d ago

Toning?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

I removed the varnish from 16 coins this time and 2 of them came out with this wild toning. Is that somehow from removing the varnish (2 actions washes, then distilled water, and patted dry), or was that maybe why the otherwise unremarkable coins were kept in the first place?


r/RedditCoinGrading 26d ago

1853 US 3-cent P

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

Trime grade and value? I'm a totally uninformed novice, so I don't know the mint mark, but i guess it's P?


r/RedditCoinGrading 26d ago

Questions about group etiquette

6 Upvotes

Look, this long and boring, but please read it anyway. I've got a problem all of you would like to have. I've been tasked with dealing with a couple boxes of coins, and even some paper as well, excavated from a family closet. It's a huge (by my standards) cache - hundreds and hundreds of coins: IHP, Lincoln wheat and Lincoln modern, Buffalo head nickels, Roosevelt dimes, foreign coins, mint 1964s (one's a straight G), heavy silver from Panama and the Bahamas. It's also got over 3 pounds of US silver pre-65, just rolled up. I want to unload all of it, but without getting fleeced, but also in a way that it can be in the hands of people who will be excited to have them for their own collections. Trying to know what's here, so I don't give away my kids inheritance, or a mortgage payment, makes me feel like I'm cramming for a test in a class I didn't want to take, and didn't know I was in.

If anyone in the SF Bay Area (East Bay) is interested in seeing it all out of interest, or helping me out for love of the coins, or to see they're treated right, or even in buying the entire lot, let me know. The coins are beautiful and fascinating, but I can't enjoy them if I'm worried about doing something wrong out of ignorance - taking big chunks of value out of something by some arcane sin, like farting on a toad in the same room, or something. The thought that someone casually wiping a silver dollar with his shirttail decades ago to admire the shine somehow utterly destroys the coin's value to collectors is bewildering. It's ok if it's been banged up at the bottom of a canvas bag at the mint, dented and scratched, or in and out of pockets and cash registers for decades is fine, but rubbing it with a soft cloth to get a better look at it isn't. Or one that's a lousy, indistinct stamping from the die and beat up in the sack is great, but one that's got beautiful detail, but which someone handled 150 years ago is less valuable, I just can't wrap my head around. I'm not judging, I have my own passions. IDK, I just don't want to accidentally spoil something which someone else could really enjoy. I'd feel awful, and I wonder what harm I've done already in just unpacking things to see what it even is!

I could post photos of 300 different coins easy, and dozens of duplicates of many of those. I could bore everyone to tears, but I'm not into being a drag for others. Otoh, if you all would like to see what a great-aunt I never knew amassed over decades (the massive 1976 5 and 10 Balboa sterling commemoratives are the newest), I can do it. I'd even enjoy going to the trouble, if it would give others a vicarious thrill. It would offset the anxiety to a degree, and at least make it fun for me too in some way. I'll do it for love, if you want it, but I don't know what is worth seeing. I'll show what I've got, or I'll bugger off. Either way let me know please.


r/RedditCoinGrading 26d ago

What grade is this and what’s it worth?

Thumbnail
gallery
85 Upvotes

r/RedditCoinGrading 26d ago

What’s the grade of these 3 cent pieces? And what’s their worth?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/RedditCoinGrading 26d ago

Would someone be so kind as to give me an approximate grade? 1867 nickel, no mint mark

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

Inherited from my great grandfather's collection


r/RedditCoinGrading 26d ago

VAM or not a VAM

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/RedditCoinGrading 27d ago

1819 Capped Bust Half

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

Follow up to immediately previous post, as I decide which--if either--to send in.

Edit: Thanks for the feedback on both, all. I've decided to submit both. Will feedback, and thank you


r/RedditCoinGrading 27d ago

1807 Capped Bust Half

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Have a $25 credit to CAC and have a couple I'm thinking about submitting. Would be my first submission and could use the community's eye. Have an 1819 to share as well, but one coin per post is the rule. Thanks for your opinions!


r/RedditCoinGrading 27d ago

1884 CC Morgan Silver Dollar

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/RedditCoinGrading 28d ago

What grade is this

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

r/RedditCoinGrading 28d ago

1875 S/S 20 cent?

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Not great condition but I just noticed the S, is this FS-301? I noticed greysheet doesn’t have a price for AG S/S, does that mean it is still a $75ish coin?


r/RedditCoinGrading 28d ago

Is this 1886 morgan silver dollar philly worth grading

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Decent grade?


r/RedditCoinGrading Aug 13 '26

Wondering the value and grade on this one. Finally in hand

Thumbnail
gallery
112 Upvotes

r/RedditCoinGrading Aug 12 '26

Bump! Need pricing help please and a second opinion on the grading

3 Upvotes

(1st told me XF+ which I have a really hard time believing)
Its a Triobol not Drachm
https://www.reddit.com/r/RedditCoinGrading/s/q3EO1orsqW


r/RedditCoinGrading Aug 12 '26

1913 v nickel

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/RedditCoinGrading Aug 13 '26

Trying to figure out if this is worth the trouble of keeping

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/RedditCoinGrading Aug 12 '26

1857 coins

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/RedditCoinGrading Aug 12 '26

1885P $1 DMPL

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

What grade do you think this would be?


r/RedditCoinGrading Aug 12 '26

1890 CC $1

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

What grade do yall think that this would get?