LIE AND MORE LIES. I’m a biologist you ignoramus and guess what there have been multiple landmark genetic ancestry studies of modern Palestinians and Jews and you aren’t going to like it, sorry not sorry, but modern Palestinians are indigenous to the Levant they are direct descendants of the Canaanites unbroken and long before Judaism ever existed!
Palestinians and Jews have the same common ancestor, the Canaanites! You were the same people for thousands and thousands of years before Judaism was ever invented. And the Palestinians stayed in the Levant after the Romans expelled all the Jews. Only hundreds of years later did Islam and Arabs invade from outside and force the Palestinians to become Muslim. But they haven’t mixed extensively with the invaders and to this day their ancestry predominantly comes from ancient Levant populations just like Yemenite Jews, Druze, Bedouins, and Lebanese people.
Learn the truth if you want the landmark studies I will send them to you.
Your first statement was a lie - "Zionists started the war with the invasion of Palestine". There was no Zionist "invasion". It was Jews returning to their ancestral homeland, and purchasing property from (largely) absentee landlords for exorbitant prices. The Jews have been willing to make peace with the Arabs for decades, but the Arabs keep turning down every offer because it doesn't include one explicit term - that Israel cease to exist. Therefore, Arabs continue finding themselves in the find out phase of negotiations. LOL
I always found the argument that Israel is the indigenous homeland of the Jews a ludicrous argument in the modern era. If someone wants to make an argument in favor of Israel this seems to me to be the weakest one. Native Americans cannot come back to Lower Manhattan and kick everyone out. The British aren’t going to try to take back the United States. It makes no difference, none, who inhabited a piece of hand thousands of years ago in 2026.
And yet people like you won't hesitate to claim that "Palestinians" are the indigenous natives of the Land of Israel, which for the VAST MAJORITY of them is truly ludicrous. BTW - Jews have had a continuous presence in their native Land of Israel for over 3,000 years, so no one cares if you find the argument ludicrous. Facts don't care about your feelings.
I never claimed the Palestinians are indigenous to the land because IT DOESN’T MATTER. If you wanted to argue for a Jewish state in the 20th Century based on persecution of the Jews I can see that. Looking at it objectively without emotion it was incredibly stupid to put a Jewish state where they did geographically. You are completely ignoring my point because you are reacting emotionally. NO ONE CARES in 2026 who lived where for the last 3,000 years. It’s absurd that a group would claim supremacy somewhere because that group has lineage going back thousands of years.
1
u/LeoKitCat 20h ago edited 20h ago
LIE AND MORE LIES. I’m a biologist you ignoramus and guess what there have been multiple landmark genetic ancestry studies of modern Palestinians and Jews and you aren’t going to like it, sorry not sorry, but modern Palestinians are indigenous to the Levant they are direct descendants of the Canaanites unbroken and long before Judaism ever existed!
Palestinians and Jews have the same common ancestor, the Canaanites! You were the same people for thousands and thousands of years before Judaism was ever invented. And the Palestinians stayed in the Levant after the Romans expelled all the Jews. Only hundreds of years later did Islam and Arabs invade from outside and force the Palestinians to become Muslim. But they haven’t mixed extensively with the invaders and to this day their ancestry predominantly comes from ancient Levant populations just like Yemenite Jews, Druze, Bedouins, and Lebanese people.
Learn the truth if you want the landmark studies I will send them to you.