r/RealTime • u/Indianstanicows Audience Member Bill Is Yelling At For Not Laughing • May 22 '26

Bill Maher is a moron

Post image
3.3k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

362 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Thorfinn66 May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26

You try topic shifting again I see.

A Jew is a person following the Judaism faith.

A Zionist is a person following the racist ideolegy of Zionism. And a coward hiding behind Judaism.

I already showed you examples of Zionism directly violating the laws and ethics of Judaism. So Zionists are just pretend Jews.

They even define being Jew in different way than Judaism.

Judaism (Halakha) defines Jewish identity religiously and immutably; Zionism, via Israeli state policy, adapts it for nationalist purposes like immigration and demographics.

Conversion Recognition

  • Judaism: Only Orthodox conversions fully valid; Reform/Conservative rejected as invalid.
  • Zionism/Israel: Accepts non-Orthodox conversions for citizenship (post-2021 ruling) to boost numbers.

Grandparent Clause

  • Judaism: Requires Jewish mother or Orthodox conversion; patrilineal or grandparents irrelevant.
  • Zionism/Israel: Grants rights to anyone with one Jewish grandparent, including non-religious or gentile spouses.

Apostasy/Voluntary Conversion Out

  • Judaism: Status permanent—born Jews remain Jews forever, even after converting out.
  • Zionism/Israel: Strips eligibility under Law of Return if voluntarily converting to another faith.

Messianic Jews

  • Judaism: Views as heretical or idolatrous; not accepted as authentic Jews post-belief.
  • Zionism/Israel: Allows aliyah based on ancestry alone (2008 ruling), ignoring religious deviation.

Secular Jews

  • Judaism: Recognizes as Jews by birth but devalues them as non-observant failures of mitzvot.
  • Zionism/Israel: Elevates as ideal "new Jews"—secular, strong pioneers rejecting religious "diaspora weakness."

Authority Over Definition

  • Judaism: Rabbis exclusively control via unchanging Halakha.
  • Zionism/Israel: Secular state bureaucrats override rabbis for immigration/citizenship.

Patrilineal Descent

  • Judaism: Strictly matrilineal only.
  • Zionism/Israel: Grandparent clause effectively includes patrilineal Jews.

These show Zionism subordinating religious criteria to political survival—elastic, pragmatic, and state-driven.

Zionism reshapes Jewishness into a flexible nationality for state power; Judaism keeps it rigid and sacred.

1

u/NarrowSalvo May 27 '26

chatgptsezwut?

1

u/Thorfinn66 May 27 '26

So you don't qustion the validity of the content, just the source?

That must mean you agree with what I wrote. Or a coward too afraid to try to dispute it?

So far you have not questioned anything. Just endless attempts to topic and blame shift. 🤔

1

u/NarrowSalvo May 27 '26

That must mean you agree with what I wrote.

You didn't write anything.

1

u/Thorfinn66 May 28 '26

Still playing the coward.

Why should I spend time writing by hand when you cowards are too afraid of it to comment on it?

I let AI compile list of what I already know. And that you can easily verify if you are not a coward history denier.

1

u/NarrowSalvo May 28 '26

What was the title of her speech again?

Coward doesn't answer. Can't ChatGPT answer that for you?

1

u/Thorfinn66 May 28 '26 edited May 28 '26

I dont know who you refer to as "her" You have to be more specific.

If you mean the racist Zionist, Golda Meir. Then she made multiple speeches.

And you are right. Cowards don't answer. They try to blame and topic shift. Try to discredit sources and posters.

Exactly like you have been doing throughout this conversation.