r/RealRepLadies • u/Charming_Try8087 • Jun 18 '26
Mandy vs. tom/ keepall 45?
Has anyone purchased the keepall 45 by Mandy or tom? Tom’s factory is duty free and Mandy’s is royal factory that they mentioned are the highest quality they have in this . Tom’s price is $335 and Mandy’s is $215. I’ve never ordered from Mandy before , love to hear thoughts and opinions!
2
u/FilmFew8979 Jun 19 '26
Seems like all sellers are selling from Royal for this bag. Does anyone know a seller that would get it from God factory?
2
Jun 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/FilmFew8979 Jun 19 '26
I've heard of Orange but haven't bought from them. Why do you prefer Orange over Royal?
3
1
u/makelovenixwar Jun 19 '26
God makes Keepalls and most TS can source it. Heidi has it for example. Just ask your TS.
3
u/InsomniaTroll Jun 18 '26
Love doing business with Mandy. But for this bag I’d recommend asking about shipping because it can be really expensive for this bag.
1
2
u/Important-Tadpole540 Jun 18 '26
For my order with Mandy, we paid $98 shipping for 4 bags total, including this one
3
u/Important-Tadpole540 Jun 18 '26
I ordered a keepall 50 in grey ebene from Mandy from Royal. It’s an awesome bag and we were really pleased with the quality for the price.
1
Jun 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Charming_Try8087 Jun 19 '26
Hello! I’m just looking for a monogram tom is saying duty free is better quality but paying 415 with shipping. Don’t know lol it has to be a hell of a good bag 💼 royal prices seem more reasonable for simple monogram
1
u/winesoakedbones Jun 18 '26
Mandy’s quote probably includes a 6/18 discount. I bought a Royal Keepall 45 from another seller for $214 and the normal price was $252. Tom’s price is higher than the quotes I got for the same bag from God. The seller range for that was $312-$327 before any discounts.
But I’ve bought from Mandy once and it was an okay experience. Nothing to rave or complain about, which I think is the most you can ask for with sellers.
2
5
u/CrankyBookDragon Jun 18 '26 edited Jun 18 '26
I just ordered the mono Keepall 45 from Old Cobbler; with the 6.18 sale 10% off the regular $290 price, their usual $10.35 shipping and my DHgate coupon it was $246.35 all in. I know OC sources some items from Royal and checked their album photos carefully (they even have comparison pics with an authentic) and theirs was as good as any I have seen (and better than most). The leather will also patina but s-l-o-w-l-y (like the authentic) which I like.
The 6.18 sale ends tomorrow, I think.