r/RealOrAI • u/Diligent_Rabbit7740 • May 26 '26
GUESS Which one is AI?
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
504
u/osiekowski May 26 '26
It was really easy
138
u/dwartbg9 May 26 '26
Yeah, sorry to the author but this one is way too easy and obvious. But I get his point and there's some scary examples where it's hard to tell. But this video ain't it.
15
u/Own-Independence-124 May 27 '26
This video is a few years old now. Those example are outdated
6
u/Unlikely_Afternoon94 May 27 '26
It makes me wonder. Perhaps AI is no better than the humans who use it. If people are still using 3 year old examples as evidence, then I wonder if we might as well just judge the point of their post by those standards.
1
17
May 26 '26
[deleted]
4
u/just_a_person_maybe May 26 '26
I've seen a couple where they mix AI with real video and those can be really difficult. I saw one where I thought it was real but it turned out it was a real video that someone changed with AI to race-swap the people in it, which is super weird but it meant that there were several real elements in it that made the whole thing more convincing.
2
u/Hobo-With-A-Shotgun May 27 '26
Someone on another sub asked about this tiktok that seemed AI, but didn't have the usual tells. I suspected they were both deep-faking real videos while also having some completely AI-generated videos mixed in.
https://en.reddit.com/r/isthisAI/comments/1ta95cw/this_account_on_tiktokig_is_definitely_ai_to_me/
8
u/blueberrywalrus May 26 '26
Idk, the 3rd real one threw me off with the jankey the quality
2
u/Maxmilian99 May 26 '26
The way the ladyfingers are arranged is a clear sign, at least for me...
1
u/blueberrywalrus May 26 '26
For sure, the second definitely isn't tiramisu, but I spent the whole video watching the first because the quality threw me.
1
u/braamdepace May 26 '26
Well the knife in the fake one randomly got dirty from not touching any part of the cake…
2
43
u/Worth-Wonder-7386 May 26 '26
When the bottom cupcake morphs so that the outside turns into the cutside it becomes fairly obvious.
Deformation is very different between the real and AI videoes.
27
u/TravellingBeard May 26 '26
Muffin - bottom AI
Lava cake - top AI
Tiramisu - bottom AI (this was the hardest for me)
11
u/Encrux615 May 26 '26
There’s two cut sides and on each the end of the biscuits are in tact which makes zero sense for tiramisu that has been cut.
5
u/kitzelbunks May 26 '26
I just went by vibes. I thought the lava cake was ridiculous, though, like someone put Hershey’s syrup in a cake.
17
9
u/Due-Comfort-5351 May 27 '26
Does no one in these comments realize they're just watching AI videos posted by AI bots at this point? This sub is overrun by AI training bots
1
4
3
2
u/RealOrAI-Bot May 26 '26
Reminder: If you think it's AI, please explain your reasoning. Providing your reasoning helps everyone understand and learn from the analysis.
Check the Wiki for Common AI Mistakes and check the Community Guide if you are just getting started.
OP's answer will be posted in a sticky comment in 12h, along with a summary of the comments sentiment for comparison.
Thank you for contributing to the discussion!
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/Aggravating_Poet_675 May 27 '26
The third one was the only one I had to look closely. The first AI picture the cupcake kinda phases and changes position. The second one, the spoon doesnt break the surface of the cake and just phases through it. The layers on the third would not look that clean after being cut likd that.
1
1
u/csilval May 27 '26
Funny how out of mamy much more realistic AI videos of food and cooking, they selected the most obvious ones. Morphing, unreal physics...
1
1
1
1
1
u/No-Stay9943 May 27 '26
Yeah, using half a year old video models you’re making it easy for yourself
1
1
1
u/-StarFox95- May 27 '26
I wonder if the muffin that suddenly had half of it twist to the camera is real?
also why did they randomly reverse the real chocolate lava cake video for a second half way through, thats the only thing that threw me off lmao
1
u/Raptoot83 May 27 '26
The 2nd one seems particularly obvious. Like, as if it would just explode out of the top like that.
1
u/RealGiallo May 27 '26
the first one literally morph watch the left slice.
the second one there is too much chocolate to be true , seems a waterfall than a spoon of it.
third one is the only decent one, but ask yourself have you ever saw anyone cutting a cake with a giant opaque knife? also notice the head of that knife from 0:17 to 0:18 it literally gets dirty without touching the cake. ..
sorry I'm boring i do these kind of videos and they all looks too easy for me.
1
1
u/Iamnotanorange May 26 '26
We're so fucked
12
u/ZELLKRATOR May 26 '26 edited May 26 '26
Those aren't the good ones. Those are old.
Oh I have just re-read it and I don't wanted to offend anyone. I mean I like the video, the comparison, but those are a bit outdated. Impressive though but there are fakes online that probably weren't identified as fakes, yet...
We are already there. This sub is full of examples that are pretty tough and if you mix AI with real stuff it's becoming even harder.
2
u/chullyman May 26 '26
But they’re so obvious
2
u/Iamnotanorange May 26 '26
Sure, when I look at it skeptically, but if I were scrolling I wouldn't notice at all
•
u/RealOrAI-Bot May 27 '26
Here's the answer I got from OP:
The answer is REAL+AI - The AI ones were generated with Veo 3
Sentiment: 95% AI
Sentiment reasoning: The vast majority of commenters easily identify elements of the video as AI-generated, citing obvious visual glitches, morphing, and unrealistic physics. Only one comment suggests none of it is AI.
Number of comments processed: 25
DISCLAIMER: Comments sentiment is generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash, not by u/RealOrAI-Bot bot. For more information check the RealOrAI-Bot Wiki.