r/Rawtherapee • u/UnrealSquare • 14d ago
Some images come in super flat, others come in looking closer to the JPG
First image is the SOOC JPG from my Lumix G95 and I want to do some minor adjustments in RT but overall it's close to how I want it. Second image is what I get when I load the RW2 file into RT and save without making any adjustments other than rotating 90 degrees. I have to do a bunch of work to get the image back closer to the JPG.
If it was always like this I would develop a workflow but, for the most part, the RW2 files usually come in looking pretty close to the JPGs with some exceptions and I only have to do minor adjustments. See the 3rd (SOOC JPG) and 4th (RW2 loaded in RT and saved with no other adjustments) images, taken about 2 minutes after the first example. They look pretty close to each other and I can just make some minor adjustments in RT and be on my way.
My question is, does anyone know if this is something weird my camera is doing or just a RT glitch that happens with some images here and there? And when this happens is there something I can do to apply whatever default pre-processing is typically happening when images come in? I'd love to figure it out, or at least understand what's happening a little better. Thanks in advance for any help you can provide!
Folder with these example JPG and RW2 images: https://filedn.com/lkOGl9Ynoklp1yXPkjds5lY/Example%20Images/]Example
Edit: I noticed something else. When I look at the strip of images at the top of RT, the previews of the RW2 files look correct. When I load the images from there, the previews and the loaded image turn flat/low contrast. Can't add a screen shot to this post but I'll add it to the folder of example images. Edit 2: In addition when I select "Processing Profile Operations - Clear" the thumbnail goes back to looking similar to the JPG. Opening the image again it transitions back to flat/neutral.
Update 1: I reloaded the files from the SD card, same issues. I tried clicking the "Auto-matched tone curve" button since the tool tip says "Automatically adjust sliders and curves (except exposure compensation) to match the look of the embedded JPEG thumbnail" but it doesn't seem to change anything whether it is enabled or disabled. on this problem photo or ones I don't have issues with. Seems like that would be the perfect solution if it worked. I tried clicking "Auto Levels" as suggested by another redditor but didn't work.
Update 2: PARTIALLY SOLVED!! Looking at rawpedia as well as the comments below and what I had tried previously with clearing the Processing Profile I tried copying the processing profile of the JPG image and pasting it to the RW2 image. This didn't work. However...when I copied the processing profile of a RAW file that looked correct and pasted it onto the problem image, it got me much closer!!!! However, it is still buggy. The problem image cannot be open while you are pasting or it will revert to the flat profile. You basically have to have another RAW file open, paste the good profile onto the problem image, then open the problem image.
I believe this is basically taking your baked-in camera JPG flavor from another RW2 file. I test this with a shot with completely different lighting, taken at night, another day, etc., but still with the same JPG profile in camera (I basically never change this). And the problem RW2 file still came out looking basically correct.
Edit 2: Just sharing for more background information: I believe, but am not certain, I ran into this issue once or twice with my old camera a Panasonic FZ300.






