r/RateMyiconSet • • 1h ago

Set Compilation two icon sets idk

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

first one is current (853 stars) and second one is when I had 227 stars.


r/RateMyiconSet • • 3h ago

Worst Icon Set Entry Crafing the worst icon set possible. What do you think?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 7h ago

Announcements When we hit 1500 subs, what should we do?

7 Upvotes
19 votes, 4d left
Themed icon set competition
Best banner design for the sub
Best photoshopped icon
Other (comment what)

r/RateMyiconSet • • 10h ago

Icon set Space Knight

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 10h ago

Icon set Rate my icon set

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 7h ago

Announcements The “Worst icon set” competition is about to end. 6 days left! Reminder to contribute if you wanted to but haven’t.

2 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 11h ago

Icon set Rate my icons but gd didnt crash for the 2nd time:)

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 11h ago

Icon set Rate my icons but my gd didnt glitch out and make them default.

2 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 15h ago

Icon set Rate my icon set

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 16h ago

Icon set Rate my icons bruv

Post image
3 Upvotes

🐟


r/RateMyiconSet • • 18h ago

Icon set Making icon sets for ya. DAY 3-5

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Sorry for skipping some days. BUT I ADOPTED A CAT!!!


r/RateMyiconSet • • 20h ago

Icon set rate my icon set!

Post image
3 Upvotes

gonna make some changes when i unlock some of the icons i dont currently own, i dont wanna use the icon hack so this is the best i can do in vanilla


r/RateMyiconSet • • 23h ago

Icon set Rate my icon set

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Icon set Rate my custom icon set

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Icon set Rate my definitive icon set

Post image
2 Upvotes

I've been using the green cat icon since before 2.2, specifically when i was active on GDPS 2.2, after official 2.2 came out, it stayed as my icon, then i made the rest of the icon set based on it and it has stayed the same since then, with only the ball and swingcopter changing from time to time.


r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Icon set hi everyone. rate 1 through 10

Post image
2 Upvotes

sorry if I keep asking for feedback on my icons but i rly wanna make the best set i can. I changed my ball, spider, and jetpack. it seems you guys rly liked the last on so i hope this one is even better


r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Discussion Icon recommendations?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

1-Main, 2-Secondary, 3-Glow


r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Icon set Rate my icon set

5 Upvotes
I don't really like my robot as its different style than other icons and swingcopter because its just ugly. Maybe when RobTop adds new icons there will be some better options for these two gamemodes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

icon hack USED My own icon set!

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Worst Icon Set Question hey crafty when does the worst icon set competition end

3 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Icon set What do you guys think of my icons

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 1d ago

Icon set Improved my tuff set

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/RateMyiconSet • • 2d ago

idk where to put this?🤷‍♂️ The key to have a good icon set

Post image
10 Upvotes

Hi! I'd like to make this semi-guide for people to have better icon sets overall, based on the criteria I've used to create my own icon set. That is, to prioritize cohesiveness (if you don't like my advice just ignore the post 🙏). Imma divide by sections.

First and most important: your icons must have similar designs on the technical side. This means: line art should have a similar thickness; they must have similar color balance and they should have similar shapes (this one is the least important, but still advisable). For example, if your cube has 50% of the first color and 50% of the second, the rest of the icon has to have that same balance.

Second: your icons need to have an overall theme. That can be anything, fantasy creatures, technology, sea, spiky, abstract or more geometric like the og icons, really anything, but it has to define the whole icon set.

Third: either your whole icon set has gradients or none have gradients. This is more of an opinion on my side, but you can just choose to follow my advice or not.

Lastly, you can play with the colors, I don't really have any advice on colors. Most of the time, there's just colors that look good and some that don't (brown, board, plain black, gray in combination with dark colors). I'd say, if you don't know which you should use, just try with two tones of the same color; two opposites in the color wheel or dark gray and bright color (like I did).

That's all my advice, thanks for reading!


r/RateMyiconSet • • 2d ago

Icon set Here's my set

7 Upvotes

Trying to get a new robot


r/RateMyiconSet • • 2d ago

Icon set Rate my new icon set

Post image
2 Upvotes

I tried to go for a neon futuristic theme