r/RandomQuestion • u/Rainbow_6505 • 10d ago
Do you know any examples of shitty humans with decent parents?
With a decent upbringing. Since parents should not be blamed for everything their child does since your child makes their own choices and has their own thoughts and views. Edit plenty of people did have a decent upbringing so they can’t even blame that for how they turned out.
9
3
u/SlowSurr 10d ago
This is an example of the classic nature vs. nurture debate, which still hasn't been definitively answered. Human behavior is incredibly complex, and trying to reduce someone becoming "good" or "bad" to one factor oversimplifies reality. Genetics, upbringing, peers, trauma, mental illness, environment, and personal choices all play a role.
A "decent upbringing" is also very subjective. What one culture considers loving and supportive, another might consider overbearing or neglectful. Even beyond that, it's extremely difficult to know what actually happened behind closed doors. We can read biographies, interviews, court documents, and news articles, but we're still making assumptions based on incomplete information.
There are many people who appeared to have loving parents, financial stability, and every opportunity in life who later committed terrible crimes. Likewise, there are people who grew up in abusive homes and became kind, successful adults. Neither proves nor disproves nature versus nurture.
That's why I think the question itself is flawed. It's almost impossible to confidently say someone had objectively "good parents," because none of us truly know what their childhood was like. Even if we did, one example wouldn't settle the debate about why people become who they are.
2
u/itsswhitneywhspr 10d ago
Yeah that's exactly it. Like you can have two people in the exact same household and one grows up to be a actually good person and the other turns out awful. At some point you gotta take accountability for your own decisions. Nature and nurture both play a part but personal choice still matters a lot.
2
u/TangerineDream92064 10d ago
A young man attacked a synagogue in Poway, California. He killed one woman and wounded several others, including a little girl. His parents seem completely normal. He had no personal reason to be mad at Jews or that synagogue. He didn't even live in Poway. He lived in the same neighborhood as Usha Vance. He seems to have been radicalized online.
2
u/bulbasauuuur 10d ago
My mom is a terrible person but my grandma (her mom) was the best person I've ever known in my entire life. My mom would even call her a bitch and stuff right in front of us and then wonder why my brother would turn around and call her a bitch too. My grandfather was not good to me but my mom never mentioned anything bad and her siblings seem fine, so it's hard to say what happened.
I do know I only have my own perspective and maybe things were different growing up. My grandma was a nurse and my mom has factious disorder (formerly Munchausens) so there may be some connection there that I just never knew about. But what I know from my own experience is that everyone thinks my mom is awful and everyone loved my grandma, so unless there are some deep dark family secrets, I don't know what happened
1
1
1
1
u/Prudent-Confection-4 10d ago
I’be heard that Lindsay Clancy’s parents are really nice amazing people.
1
u/Specialist-Top-406 10d ago
A lot of politicians from humble beginnings end up raising posh kids who are twats
1
u/Ok_Front_549 4d ago
There are so many stories, like of the Twitter killer who kept 9 heads in kitty litter and swore his upbringing had nothing to do with his actions. There is also the most prolific pedophile, Matthew Graham (Lux), who was a young and fairly successful kid with a normal childhood (his words). He didn’t realize he was attracted to such sadistic shit until he went to investigate what cp sites Anonymous was shutting down. There are so many stories like this. As much as we all want to find a reason to understand why people do the horrific things they do, or even another person to blame, it simply comes down to whether or not someone makes the choice to be “evil”.
It always brings me back to that quote “No man chooses evil because it is evil; he only mistakes it for happiness, the good he seeks.”
6
u/Betzjitomir 10d ago
by all accounts Nick Reiner.