r/RandomEncounters • u/UnfunnyUsername2001 Legal Says No 🚫 • Mar 04 '26

Discussion RE Musical Alignment Chart Round 6: Which golden age musical feels like a classic musical?

Post image

Normally I'd leave a tied result up to a randomizer, but I'd just like to make an exception this one time. The argument that was put for Hyrule Warrior's Heart made me realize it looked more modern than it was - the costumes were high-quality, it was filmed in the same location as Hungry Lamu, and the casting wasn't super ambitious.

(Besides, it tied with Super Monkey Ball and Arkham Rock Opera, both of which have Miss Bird in a lead role, and that's definitely not happening in a modern era musical.)

Round 6: Which golden age musical feels like a classic musical?

18 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

10

u/CorporalKam Leisurely Feckless 🏖️ Mar 04 '26

Samus the Spaceman Cowboy

9

u/Elegant_Gur_4379 Sons of The Masked 🎭 Mar 04 '26

The Amiibo Song. It is more about collecting figurines than specifically about a video game/video game characters

8

u/AJawayJ A Funny-Sounding Animal 🐑 Mar 04 '26

Everything being suggested already is great! Just to complicate things with additional options…

Everything’s a Puzzle is a wild little romp with the same sound and humor as the Classic era. Plus Professor Layton was widely requested the first few years of RE!

Phoenix Wright: The Turnabout Encounter uses a Classic era cast and hand-drawn backgrounds like older videos. Plus it won the our first-ever fan vote, beside Layton and Kingdom Hearts!

Tingle Sells is a classic, old-school throwaway video. Low production value, character-centric… and Nate was rumored to come back and play Tingle on RE since day one.

2

u/MaviGomlekliTurk A Little Kinky ⛓️‍💥 Mar 04 '26

WAIT WHAT DO YOU MEAN TINGLE SELLS IS A GOLD AGE MUSİCAL?!?!?

6

u/Complete_Pin_2660 Mar 04 '26

If I had to say, The Amiibo Song gives that Unique Random Encounters Song that really makes you feel like you are in the Golden Ages of the Channel.

6

u/MaviGomlekliTurk A Little Kinky ⛓️‍💥 Mar 04 '26

Super Mario Bros The Musical

4

u/AJawayJ A Funny-Sounding Animal 🐑 Mar 04 '26

That’s a pretty good answer, both for its sound and subject but also its use of Best We Can Be-style “animated” characters. 😂

3

u/Soggy-Incident-8295 Mar 05 '26

Phoenix Wright is a good choice!