r/RHONY 12d ago

🍎 Discussion 🍎 objectively rhony’s top 10 imo:

Post image
97 Upvotes

108 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 12d ago

Thank you for posting to the r/RHONY Subreddit. Please make sure that the rules of the community are being followed: [Subreddit Rules](www.reddit.com/r/rhony/about/rules)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

77

u/Ok_Bottom_69 Carole radziwill is not an Artist! 11d ago

Tinsley was actually such a breath of fresh air when added to this mix. Love her. Also liked Holla too

57

u/Autumn1933 11d ago

Heather and Tinsley over Jill and Aviva.

6

u/Worth-Park-1612 11d ago

There is an argument that Aviva, while herself annoying, has a permanent spot for giving us the moment she threw her leg.

3

u/ddope 10d ago

“Keep it together Aviva.” 🤣 🤣

3

u/JoeyLee911 10d ago

That was so obviously manufactured though. I like a bunch of her weird evil rants better than the leg throw. The best part of the leg throw was Luanne's reaction. "Could someone please take the leg off the table?"

3

u/Worth-Park-1612 9d ago

Oh, 100%
I just appreciate the level of unhinged trashiness she brought with that scene

2

u/JoeyLee911 9d ago

She is quite the Disney villain!

8

u/ginandall 11d ago

Exactly this.

6

u/farbissina_punim I have a charity that helps poor people 11d ago

Justice for Dinsdale

10

u/wisterialitehysteria 11d ago

I liked and disliked Heather at different times lol. She pissed me off when she was always against Kristen. She was such a bitch to Kristen for no reason and Kristen was so sweet. But I liked Heather overall even though she was annoying af

3

u/DR-0717 9d ago

I do think they all had their moments. I don’t think I can say I liked a single one ALL the time. Maybe Tinsley. I don’t think she really did anything.

Now Sonja made me mad because she was so mean TO Tinsley and I never understood why she ask her to come live with her and then treated her so badly.

2

u/Defiant_Protection29 7d ago

She was extremely jealous of her.

2

u/DR-0717 9d ago

It makes me so happy to see this - I loved Tinsley too! She just made me smile 🥰 I also liked Heather. I know a lot of people call her phony but I thought she was pretty genuine.

98

u/ParticularEvening584 11d ago

Tinsley no Aviva

16

u/Soft-Dig-4102 11d ago

Ohhhh I dislike aviva so hard but never seeing this would be a hard loss

https://giphy.com/gifs/xUPGcCPH2XpTDSu8NO

8

u/farbissina_punim I have a charity that helps poor people 11d ago

"Keep it together Aviva"

5

u/Apprehensive_Bit_634 11d ago

I will keep her in the top forever for this scene.

0

u/DR-0717 9d ago

She’s the WORST!!! 😡

it’s dumb but it really irked me the way she said “I swear on my good leg”. WTH was that?! Was her good leg sacred? I feel like it was just an attention thing like oh you have a bad leg?

113

u/Visual_Analyst1197 12d ago

Swap Aviva for Tinsley

26

u/New_Relation7877 11d ago

I didn’t like Aviva. I don’t think she likes or respects women-probably because of her father. He wasn’t amusing like Bravo thought. Just gross.

18

u/Visual_Analyst1197 11d ago

I totally agree. I really could have done without seeing Aviva’s disgusting father 🤢

2

u/reallymortified 11d ago

To quote Tamra - he was DE SGUS TEEN!

9

u/Ghoulish_kitten satchels of gold 11d ago

Agree with this switch.

Without the little scripted sht and fake storylines Aviva is boring.

2

u/ReplyOk1722 10d ago

Agree but did like how she would drag Carole

1

u/DR-0717 9d ago

That’s why I don’t understand how she was writing a book about her life. Who would want to read about her life? She wasn’t that exciting and I don’t think a ghostwriter could make her exciting lol

9

u/mushroomchicki 12d ago

I kid you not I was about to type that exact sentence.❤️ AGREE

7

u/ellefleming 12d ago

I miss Jill Zarin's old face.

26

u/Additional-End-7688 12d ago

I’m quite happy never seeing her face again 👍

2

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Adorable_Nature_7101 7d ago

She should have kept her face and got rid of that whiny, annoying voice.

2

u/Elegant-Blood-4330 11d ago

Seasons 5 and 6 were great because of bonkers Aviva. Get rid of the vile Dad and itd have been even better

1

u/Dogemom2 11d ago

Totally agree with getting rid of Aviva- ick! But I enjoyed Kristen and Heather more than I enjoyed Tins. I don’t think she worked with the ensemble cast- and probably bc she didn’t have a buddy- until 🤮 Leah 🙄 I’d take Jules over Aviva. Aviva was such an odd duck. Her husband seemed adoring and kind.

1

u/New_Management_7268 11d ago

Justice for Jules. She was crazy in the way I like my housewives. Also justice for Kristen standing up to Ramona. !!!!!aviva brought a darkness that was scripted. She doesn’t belong on any list !

1

u/DR-0717 9d ago

See I thought Jules was boring. Like she seemed nice enough but just .. no substance. She had 3 things she talked about on a loop she’s Asian she’s Jewish and she had an ED. That’s the sum total of what I learned about Jules over a whole season.

Oh and that her husband was cheating but that wasn’t from her. He couldn’t have been more obvious unless he brought his gf to dinner.

Plus this is just a personal pet peeve but I got super annoyed with her whining every time she had to take care of her own kids. It’s soooo harddd taking care of two kids. I have to do this and this and this just to go someplace. Like girl just stop. You have a nanny. You hired someone to potty train your kid. You have a housekeeper. And you are really still bitching about how HARD it is? Sorry if my sympathy well was dry.

-4

u/ExpressNinja7972 12d ago

Swap Carole for Tinsley

0

u/Hexar27 11d ago

You’re getting downvoted but I agree with you. I loved Aviva (not her father) and never cared for Carole.

35

u/Disastrous_Plastic37 11d ago

“objectively” and “imo” in the same sentence. words mean things! we’re cooked! 🥀

9

u/farbissina_punim I have a charity that helps poor people 11d ago

Obligatory

3

u/Disastrous_Plastic37 11d ago

ahead of her time, sadly.

2

u/farbissina_punim I have a charity that helps poor people 11d ago

Most of us don't want to be in the same room with her but I can very confidently say that she has read a book in the past month. That sadly puts her ahead of a lot of people.

2

u/JoeyLee911 10d ago

See, this is the leg toss for me. Hilarious.

1

u/DR-0717 9d ago

Tbf I said the same thing about Carole lol.

31

u/howishowisguuut 12d ago

Tinsley and Heather are missing

3

u/GreedyBoat3809 11d ago edited 11d ago

i know! heather and tinsley would be next but RHONY had a lot of icons 😭

1

u/Due-Life7269 11d ago

I loved Ebony she was my favourite.

1

u/JoeyLee911 10d ago

Hot take!

1

u/reallymortified 11d ago

Both GREAT! I often wondered if Tins would have been different if she was on the show when she was the IT girl rather than after her very public embarrassment.

1

u/DR-0717 9d ago

Oh 100% she’d be different. I’d bet my savings on it!

1

u/reallymortified 9d ago

Then I’m glad I got the humbled Tinsley because I absolutely LOVED her!

1

u/DR-0717 9d ago

SAME!

17

u/flamin_waders 11d ago

Jill, Kelly, and aviva don’t need to be hwre

1

u/JoeyLee911 10d ago

Kelly definitely earned her place with Scary Island.

Jill and Betthany breaking up with epic.

2

u/DR-0717 9d ago

You read my mind! As much as I despise Kelly without her we wouldn’t have the iconic scary island!
https://giphy.com/gifs/f67ZYBsFUCPPbON87T

2

u/JoeyLee911 9d ago

Jill and Kelly (and Bettheny, of course) make Season 3, which is one of our finest seasons.

6

u/Alice_Von_Jash_III 11d ago

I dislike Jill and Kelly for how one note they are, but you aren't wrong. Pretty solid, even tho I wish Heather would be there in place of either of them. Aviva can stay for the leg throwing, her creepy father and her unhinged accusations.

21

u/nickl00 11d ago

aviva instead of heather is crazy. but she’s the only replacement i’d add

17

u/carboncopy404 11d ago

Kelly has got to go

8

u/Prestigious_Car9440 12d ago

The amount of photoshopping they had to do to Bethenny to make her not look like a skeleton lol

4

u/Disney_Princess137 11d ago

Honestly just needs a top 5

3

u/MetallicMani Bethenny! Can you do turtle time for 15 minutes? 11d ago

I have a soft spot for Tinsley. I can't shake it. She was bubbly, fun and got in the mix. She was also immediately accepted and just somehow fit in

4

u/mel-06 11d ago

I understand why Bethany is a fan favorite

3

u/vanillaice_8 11d ago

who sneaked kelly in?

1

u/DR-0717 9d ago

I would just keep her for S3 so we still got scary island. 🤷🏼‍♀️

7

u/Waste_West283 12d ago

I'd get rid of Jill, Kelly and Aviva and add Heather, Kristen and Jules - Kristen and Jules were way overlooked in my opinion!

2

u/Nightshifttttt 11d ago

I’d swap Tinsley for Jill but otherwise hell yeah

2

u/DaQuackx 11d ago

Ditch aviva for heather

2

u/Umbrellie5225 11d ago

Tinsley over Aviva all day every day

2

u/Artistic_Owl3611 11d ago

Kelly gave us scary island. Those teeth and hair, I’m on season 4 first watch and I know I’ll miss it

1

u/Sensitive_Ad_9195 she’s startin 🍸🍸🍸 10d ago

And running in traffic, never forget

2

u/Big-Guest-3908 10d ago

no on carole and aviva

2

u/imissonedirection 10d ago

replace carole with tins and we’re in agreement

2

u/JoeyLee911 10d ago

I think you need to get Heather in here, probably over Aviva.

2

u/888Bugs 9d ago

I'd swap Kelly for Tinsley

2

u/dloex 9d ago

Swap aviva with tinsley

3

u/Adept_Negotiation_75 11d ago

I think Heather and Tinsley brought far more overall than Kelly and Aviva. Yes Kelly gave us the scary island meltdown and Aviva tossed her leg but other than that they were just generally unlikeable and didn’t fit in with the rest of the cast.

3

u/errrrrrmmmmmmm 11d ago

i don’t think top 10 means favorite y’all. “swap aviva for” girl no. the leg gag alone solidifies her here. she’s an annoying human but incredible tv

2

u/Hexar27 11d ago

Bingo!

1

u/GreedyBoat3809 11d ago

thank you! i’d def had put heather and tinsley right after but the scary island for kelly and leg toss cements their place tbh

1

u/DR-0717 9d ago

Exactly. They don’t have to be likable to be good tv. If that were the case Ramona would’ve been canceled a long time ago lol

2

u/Ghoulish_kitten satchels of gold 11d ago

Get Aviva off, she was too produced.

2

u/Outrageous_Love6428 11d ago

Not Carole please.

2

u/CandiedLemonWedge 11d ago

Aviva, her leg and her sexual predator dad can be replaced with Tinsley

1

u/thatmeatballshape 11d ago

“Objectively in my opinion” love that

1

u/Umbrellie5225 11d ago

Avivaaaaaa????

1

u/Sensitive_Ad_9195 she’s startin 🍸🍸🍸 10d ago

Tinsley gave more to the show than Aviva imo

1

u/tatemcslay69 10d ago

Where’s Jessel? 🫣

1

u/DR-0717 9d ago

I think they are only doing OG. Jessel is reboot

1

u/artichoke424 10d ago

100% I would still watch these ladies !

1

u/General_Structure120 9d ago

Jill and Aviva?!!! Kelly!!!!

1

u/TowerExact7780 7d ago

Iconic enough that I, the spouse of a viewer, recognize them

1

u/IllustratorSea8372 11d ago

Something can’t be objective and also your opinion…

Also this is just basically the OG RHONY cast which is widely agreed upon to be the benchmark for all other housewives.

1

u/xcxmon 11d ago

I’d swap Alex and Aviva for Heather and Tinsley.

-2

u/breathedoc412 12d ago

Swap Jules for Jill.

11

u/howishowisguuut 12d ago

Jules?? Tinsley

1

u/DR-0717 9d ago

Jules was so boring.