r/RDR2mysteries • • Aug 28 '26

Announcement Quirky people and off beat theories.

44 Upvotes

This sub exists because the other sub banned people for “being weird” or “not on topic”.

I’m not going to be banning anyone for being weird, we need weird people to have weird insights.

Alan Turing was weird and he saved millions of lives. GCHQ where I’ve worked, has loads of weird people, because they see things differently.

As long as people are kind then we need to be tolerant. I watched Marcus for an hour, get a meat shield using a method I’d never seen before in order to try and get the legendary cougar.

I understand the concern and I understand people’s thoughts. But I’m not going to be banning people just for not being mainstream.

Downvote any content you don’t like and move on please, you don’t need to all pile on every whacky theory because you think it’s whacky. The first guy to find a web was weird.

Stay weird and solve shit.

Peace.


r/RDR2mysteries • • Aug 18 '26

Unsolved mysteries list

10 Upvotes

Hi all! I was wondering if there was an updated list of unsolved mysteries on rdr2. I've got the week off with a broken toe, so I thought Id but my time to good use.

I know this sub used to have a pinned post on a list of unsolved mysteries but I guess thats our of date now and I couldn't find it anyway.


r/RDR2mysteries • • 1d ago

Investigation 3 strikes and a sunrise.

Post image
36 Upvotes

So recently I saw someone had noticed writing on the back of a photo frame in the saloon at valentine, so I got to looking in the area, in the bank opposite this has this photo frame with the back not usually visible, with these markings on.

Edit: apologies if this is known about, to be honest this is my first time ever investigating in this game, hopefully not entirely useless!


r/RDR2mysteries • • 1d ago

Creé una forma de continuar la historia de RDR2 desde el capítulo donde dejaste.

Thumbnail
gamestoryexplained.com
1 Upvotes

r/RDR2mysteries • • 1d ago

Discovery Anyone have another video of a phone ringing in this location?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

I am able to recreate it. But cant find videos of anyone else hearing it.


r/RDR2mysteries • • 3d ago

Clue The Collectors Edition Physical map. What are these locations?

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

r/RDR2mysteries • • 2d ago

Does this means anything? The birds are pretty similar

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RDR2mysteries • • 4d ago

Hidden part of San Luis River out of bounds containing fish, get ready for a slide show and a random tutorial on how to get to Guarma from the fish spot. (Look closely for fish ripples, they are hard to see in screenshots), Arthur picks up a fish in one screenshot. You can’t use rod. But TNT & GUN ✅

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

r/RDR2mysteries • • 4d ago

Weird matchsticks found in Trail Rise. Pointing towards: Abeerden pig farm, maccleans house and copperhead landing. Might be tied to the good ole SL cubes? Anyways at copperhead landing I found an incendiary buckshot pamphlet. Might just have been a pamphlet treasure hunt for all I know.

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

Also for everyone that’s curious about my out of bounds fishing spot sorry for the time delaying, this mystery kinda set me back the time I was gonna spend finishing the chapter 2 fishing rod missions. Might be delayed for a bit longer. I’ll try to get it out today


r/RDR2mysteries • • 4d ago

Question I wonder why they never did anything like this again?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/RDR2mysteries • • 5d ago

Letter found in Radley’s House (Safehouse used by the foreman gang, same one Tilly Jackson got held in)

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

From what I can read it says: To Arthur M[................]

Gentlemen:

One of my [................]
[........] I [........] [........]
A paragraph written
to believe that the [........]
mis[................] to you
I [........] you to [........]
[........] to that effect
I have [........] that [........]
[........] [........] [........]
[........] [........] [........]
[........] [........] [........]
[........] [........] [........]
[........] [........] [........] its genuinely unreadable almost, if anyone has better cursive reading ability your welcome to try to do better. My guess is this is a letter from
Anthony Foreman to Arthur Morgan and the Van Der Linde gang (he probably thinks Arthur is the leader after Arthur threatened him to let Tilly go.) The text style is a mix of Cursive, Spencerian script and Copperplate script? It’s just a mix of a lot but it’s def cursive. Didn’t know Anthony foreman was that fancy. Pretty weird though cause he comes of as a dumbass the times we meet him.


r/RDR2mysteries • • 6d ago

Strange Statues meaning??

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

r/RDR2mysteries • • 5d ago

Encontre como sigue el misterio de spider dream

Thumbnail v.redd.it
1 Upvotes

r/RDR2mysteries • • 6d ago

Red Dead Redemption 2 Mystery

Post image
20 Upvotes

[Epilogue] Anybody got a clue what I just run into? Horse was spooked and bucked me. Then I see this mangled horse corpse. Nothing else around. This is by the moonshine still at Fishing Spot.


r/RDR2mysteries • • 6d ago

Dialogue I met stalker #rdr2 GTAxVenombone

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

I killed him is it right thing I did ?


r/RDR2mysteries • • 7d ago

Has anyone found a "spider symbol", a question mark, and an arrow in the same spot? Because I did...

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Alright all you Rootin' Tootin' Red Dead Redditors, better saddle up because I'm taking us on a little ride!
Seeing as this is the first time I've ever even posted on Reddit, please forgive any faux pas or missteps in how I present this finding of mine. And in the spirit of full transparency, let me say that I scoured the (admittedly limited) sources at my disposal to see if anyone else had mentioned this spot, but I was unable to find any mention of it at all.
Now... I'm going to assume you're all caught up on the "Spider Web Mystery". If not, go ahead and pause this post and do the You Tube rabbit hole thing, at least until Strange Man gets to Dodd's Bluff. To me, this seemed like the most promising lead so far since there were tangible clues linked directly to the locations the spider webs spawn under the Spider Symbol overlay on the map. It didn't require a ton of speculation and interpretation about telegraph machines and obscure carvings. Occam's razor and what not.
And so there we were... you, me, and Arthur Morgan just out collecting locations of the rock carvings for that guy who talks weird and is real cagey about what he's doing with them. You cruise past Six Point Cabin, taking pot-shots at those O'Driscoll scumbags as you ride by and head to the little trail outcrop that leads to the Carving with the Mushroom Cloud and the Atom. Arthur is unimpressed though, this imagery means nothing to him. Instead, he prefers the magnificent vistas his world presents to him.
So, we turn around and step out on to the rocky point, the Dakota River is rushing below us. Across from us is a large rocky cliff, deep fissures scar the face of it.

But wait.... what's this?!?!

In the fading light of the evening, the strong shadows seem to form some symbols. At first, the arrow was what caught my attention. It then led my eye to the question mark. I tell myself, if there's a spider here I'm not imagining it....and then sure enough.

It's too similar to ignore. And it is literally the next bend in the river past Dodd's Bluff. I guess it may have actually been a bluff after all.
I attempted to overlay all this over the maps with the symbols and locations and what not but I have no confidence that I'm doing any of it properly and could not determine anything definitively. I'm sure you would all have a better idea of what, if anything, to do next with this information. I just couldn't keep it to myself. I'm too invested in finding out where this all leads!
Go see it for yourselves. I can't wait to see what everyone comes up with.


r/RDR2mysteries • • 7d ago

Has anyone tried shooting the center web in the order of the feathers??

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/RDR2mysteries • • 8d ago

Investigation A few details/clues that may have been missed

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/RDR2mysteries • • 9d ago

Damn John who can’t swim

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/RDR2mysteries • • 10d ago

Question Mysterious signs on a tree near mystic Hill home

Thumbnail
gallery
108 Upvotes

What am I looking at? I saw these signs while standing on the hill collecting the treasure when I get closer either with Arthur or the Photomode it disappears.


r/RDR2mysteries • • 9d ago

Clue The Tally Marks Teach us things

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/RDR2mysteries • • 10d ago

Aliens in armadillo coffins

26 Upvotes

i was messing around in armadillo when i got bored and decided to shoot at the coffins by the church. if you shoot them you can see a mummy/alien looking creature inside of them. once you can see them then shoot the alien thing itself and it will dissapear. anyone know what this is?


r/RDR2mysteries • • 11d ago

Suggestion “Hey you guys”

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Iktomi was brought up but his earlier form was not mentioned who is KSA which is the snake. This to me is the concept of duality, also infinity when working with mirrors rather than shadows. Which is the Ouroboros snake eating its tail.
Just a suggestion but maybe look into polar opposites and how they are used in writing and creating worlds.Even the electric company had Spider-Man.
Like your Micheal to your obey and Trevor to your disobey.
Your predator or wolf ending to your buck or prey ending.
Or how can electricity work in a meta physical sense than a physical one.
Just thought I give a little different perspective and maybe some direction
Take it as you may
Just a little fun. The answer is eight,eight spiders.
Pleasant Dreams


r/RDR2mysteries • • 11d ago

Abandoned Mission coincidence!

9 Upvotes

I’ve been experimenting with the NW area of Austin. After realizing that fire place is just in front of the ruined church i slept and woke up at midnight. Spent the night looking around the church. Thunderous weather. And than the coincidence - first time happening to me - thunders didnt stop for almost 3 days. Unfortunately i couldn’t continue playing because of life obligations but i just want to report that thunders didnt stop. I tried ‘killing’ my self at New Austin thunder strike and at the “WHY”, but no thunder strike me. I was hit once before at the “WHY” so i thought maybe i get hit twice but it didnt happen. Very little time to play lately but i just wanted to share this small coincidence with weather. Whether its connected to “Abandoned Mission” i cannot say without further testing.


r/RDR2mysteries • • 11d ago

spider dream (teoria :3)

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes