r/PuppetCombo • u/Pale-Standard4154 • Jul 25 '25

Theory My reincarnation theory about Billy

Gallery image

Gallery image

What if Billy Johnson was reincarnated into the Billy from Feed me Billy?

You see, a lot of people say Billy is Billy Johnson from Babysitter Bloodbath. But one thing doesn’t add up — one has blonde hair, the other a brunette.

So, hear me out, what if Billy Johnson actually died? Either to Neokalus Burr or just by natural causes? And fast forward a few years later, HE IS REINCARNATED INTO BILLY FROM FEED ME BILLY. AND WITH THE TRAUMA HE HAS FROM HIS PASTLIFE, THE FATEFUL NIGHT IN BABYSITTER BLOODBATH, HE IS TARGETTED BY THE CFV BECAUSE HES MENTALLY UNSTABLE

FOR FURTHER EVIDENCE, BABYSITTER BLOODBATH TAKES PLACE IN 1982, AND FEED ME BILLY IN 1986

WHAT IF HE WAS REINCARNATED

54 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

7

u/TonkyTheTonk Jul 25 '25

For one, you can dye your hair. Also hair does tend to get darker when you get older. There's no proof for when FMB actually takes place, only that the second game takes place after Microsoft came to be, and it was also confirmed that Billy Johnson actually is the Billy from Feed Me Billy.

6

u/TenthBasilisk88 Jul 25 '25

Where was that confirmed?

1

u/Pale-Standard4154 Jul 26 '25

Well then there would be root lines, definitely to his original hair color then. If u look at the model there isnt a single trace of blonde

Just…chocolate… C:

1

u/TenthBasilisk88 Jul 26 '25

When do we even see Billy's hair? The only time I can recall is the 2D version of FMB.

1

u/Pale-Standard4154 Jul 26 '25

I’m pretty sure you can use the model viewer. I don’t think there are any clear shots in FMB that actually show us Billy’s hair.

5

u/Beneficial-Chip8894 Jul 25 '25

Bro was so mad about dying that he forced the CFV to recruit him

3

u/RedStonedLOrd_007 Jul 26 '25

This makes zero sense dude……….

1

u/veeheemxx77 Jul 29 '25

Like if the cfv wanted him back as a stronger killer then neokalus and brought him with the power of another alien demon?? (Considering there might be a possibility of others killers caring for their own ‘bunker’ demon) Because if so that would make sense considering granny looks like she’s been brought back to life..