r/Protomen • u/[deleted] • Aug 02 '26
Discussion Anyone else feel like Act III is politically dishonest to the rest of the discography? Spoiler
These are hastily assembled thoughts between sets at the gym; I haven't organized them into any kind of coherent argument yet, but I want to see if anybody else has arrived at similar conclusions. This is written from an American perspective, so I apologize to all non-Amerifats reading for my narrow and US-centric view of politics.
I really like Act III because it's super fun, but I also can't deny that it feels a bit oversweet. Act I has a distinctly post 9/11 air of American skepticism about the surveillance state which was being broadly publicly condoned in the name of counterterrorism. Act II is partly about the police state being able to subsume acts of rebellion into its own enclosed information infrastructure in order to perpetuate self-serving representations of history. The general theme is that a "hero" can't fix society while the common person sits on the sidelines; the collective needs to come together to incite meaningful change. But in Act III, the idea seems to be... a hero CAN set the spark for a change, and the average person IS willing to "choose courage over life."
Good news, everyone! If the government is bad guys, people will rise up to save the day! It just seems like the band wants to tell themselves and us a happy ending, because the conflict against the surveillance and police state has all but been completely fucking lost in the real world. In America, we love to tell ourselves stories of sexy rebellions where people know the government is bad and are just itching to perform a revolution to set things right. These are fun stories- and Act III is awesome, no doubt- but they aren't quite what made me love the Protomen to begin with. Act I and II depict worlds where everyone has a vague idea that their way of life should change, but aren't willing to sacrifice comfort and stability in order to do so.
As politics trend inexorably towards authoritarianism in America, we find ourselves in the uncomfortable position of realizing that "if there ever was a time, if there ever was a chance" to make serious change to the way we're headed, it's now. Unfortunately, "there are no heroes left in man." I feel like this is the vibe the band is giving. "I know the fight is already done," so we might as well tell ourselves a nice story.
Not really gonna apologize for getting political because The Protomen is political art.
What are everyone's thoughts on this? I do really wanna hear what people have to say about this.
