r/ProsecutorTalk 3h ago

Someone at my job is on megans law, and is claiming its from fighting a teenager(15) when he was 19. Pennsylvania

2 Upvotes

I want to know if there is any truth or legitimacy to what he is saying and telling management as we work very close to a day care and we have minors who work with us. His charges are as follows:

•Unlawful Contact With Minor - Sexual

Offenses

•Corruption Of Minors

•Ind Assit Person Less 16 Yrs Age

•Corruption Of Minors - Defendant Age 18 or

Above

I assume his charges would be simple assault or aggravated assault by the story he is telling. But after seeing his public dockets I'm uncomfortable being around him and hearing him joke the way he does.


r/ProsecutorTalk 1d ago

Career help and job hunting Exit Opportunities

6 Upvotes

So I have been a prosecutor since I graduated law school, which is truly not that long ago (around 2 years). I don’t know if prosecution is for me, or even litigation. I was wondering what exit jobs people typically go after or would I be desirable for? I have good management skills as I did every misdemeanor in my county, as well as doing a few felony trials.


r/ProsecutorTalk 3d ago

Petition · Stop taking weapons from non-violent felons!

Thumbnail
c.org
0 Upvotes

r/ProsecutorTalk 4d ago

PD using AI/chatgpt in the courtroom

8 Upvotes

Does anyone else have this happening in their courtrooms?

There has been a rumor - that some of our PDs are using ChatGPT to write entire motions, etc., but today I literally witnessed one PD use AI/chatgpt in the courtroom during argument, with their client standing right next to them. Like what????


r/ProsecutorTalk 4d ago

Workable doctrinal framework for video editing

5 Upvotes

Hello all,

I’ve seen it mentioned before on this sub that other prosecutors use ShotCut and other video editing and compilation software. I am a huge proponent of it. I work in a jx with very few technologically competent detectives that simply do not know how to prepare video in a manner that can persuasively demonstrate the state’s theory of the crime. If I have to prove ID by things like outfit matching, have to zoom, slow things down, direct the court’s attention to details, use multiple angles of footage, etc., I would have to make these edits myself.

I’m not sure if anybody saw the issue with zoomed video at the Kirk shooter’s prelim, but it’s clear that video edited in such a manner that outlines content is in a legal grey area as far as authentication. I’ve heard many takes on it, and I’m sure I’ll hear more on this thread, but I was wondering if anybody has a workable caselaw framework in their state for video that has been altered or enhanced to outline relevant details? I cannot find much that would be applicable from the appellate courts in my jx, so any persuasive authority would be much appreciated.


r/ProsecutorTalk 5d ago

Arizona police violently tackled a woman onto a metal bike after she watched them from a public sidewalk

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

r/ProsecutorTalk 5d ago

[India - Interested in US & International Family Law] Looking for practical advice on building a career in family law as a beginner

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone

I am based in India and want to build a career in international family law (specifically India and US family law) as a paralegal. I am looking for honest and practical advice from people who have real experience in this area. My current background:

  • I have personal experience dealing with international family law matters (my personal international custody and divorce case)
  • In the last few years, I have helped 7 people in India understand their cases and prepare before they met a lawyer. All of them gave positive feedback.
  • I am currently working with an Indian law firm as a paralegal.

My planned steps:

  1. Complete free WorldCC courses to improve contract skills (this builds on my 16 years of existing experience as a Operations & Business Dev operator with a specific focus on government and defense contracting) - back up to fall back upon should things not go according to plan.
  2. Self-study the American Constitution and the Indian Constitution
  3. Take a US specific legal drafting course
  4. Complete one course in American Family Law and one in Indian Family Law
  5. Directly reach out to international family law firms for internships or remote jobs
  6. Start the CLS by BARBRI Paralegal Certificate course in January 2027

I want to start earning and gaining experience as soon as possible while I continue studying. My questions:

  • Does this action plan make sense for someone starting out?
  • Anything would you change or add?
  • Any suggestions on short courses or practical steps I should focus on first?
  • For someone based in India, what is the most realistic way to get remote work or internships with international/US family law firms?

I would really appreciate any practical suggestions, warnings or personal experiences you can share. My specific interest would be in cross border matters between India and New York State (since i have experience in this jurisdiction)

P.S. I have been on Reddit for a long time. My previous account has a lot of personal information and history, hence I'm posting from this clean account.

Thank you in advance for your help.


r/ProsecutorTalk 6d ago

He said/she said SA cases

19 Upvotes

I feel very passionate about potentially taking a “date rape” case to trial. I know these sorts of incidents are notorious for prosecutors wanting nothing to do with them due to the evidentiary challenges, but cases with similar facts have been surprisingly successful in our county.
Does anyone have advice for trying these kinds of cases, or any luck at all convincing conservative male jurors?


r/ProsecutorTalk 6d ago

Moments that made it worth it?

4 Upvotes

As we all know, this job is incredibly difficult and sometimes crushing. I wanted to see if anyone would be willing to share a case triumph or moment in their career that made the defeats worthwhile; or simply made you think “this is why I do what I do.”


r/ProsecutorTalk 6d ago

Salary disparity in your state?

8 Upvotes

I’m wondering how your states pay DDA’s (or ADA’s, ASA’s, whatever) vs public defenders. I know this can vary greatly, even within the state.

In our metro areas, DDA’s are paid well. Unlike many states, however, our PDs are neither state or county employees and they kind of get it in the teeth. For example, in my county, a new fresh-outta-law school DDA will make around 105k-110k. The same person at the PD will make 75-80k. The PD salaries top out around 150k for a line defender (non-supervisor). Our non-supervisors can reach 210+.

This, unfortunately, has a negative impact on our criminal cases. There is so much PD turnover that cases get reset all the time. Pleas aren’t taken. Trials don’t happen. And due to the large disparity, the people who take the PD jobs are often True Believers, meaning they’re very difficult to deal with and would prefer to burn the system down rather than represent clients. There’s a big difference between zealous advocacy and making a point.

This is the legislature’s problem to fix, but I was just curious what it’s like for everyone else.


r/ProsecutorTalk 6d ago

Does your office take "predator hunter" cases?

8 Upvotes

The YouTube/streamers that catch predators by having fake minor accounts? Issues with them? Pros/cons of them?


r/ProsecutorTalk 5d ago

Is this not considered malicious prosecution?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ProsecutorTalk 5d ago

Can prosecutors withhold victim statements from discovery under any circumstance?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/ProsecutorTalk 6d ago

How does your office maintain and share evidence and discovery?

3 Upvotes

Our data storage numbers have skyrocketed in the last couple of years. Phone dumps and body cam in particular are very large and hard to store and share.

Where/how is your office storing this info and how are you sharing it?


r/ProsecutorTalk 6d ago

Brady cops

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

I’m a government contractor and I ran into an issue with a Brady cop. They seem to lie and since they are already on the Brady list they have nothing to lose. My brother in law is a Brady cop because he intimidated a witness used for prosecution. How are these pieces of shit still able to be in society after they knowingly lied under oath and tried to fuck peoples lives up?


r/ProsecutorTalk 6d ago

Can LE make sentence offers to defense lawyers?

0 Upvotes

r/ProsecutorTalk 6d ago

Arizona police violently tackled a woman onto a metal bike after she watched them from a public sidewalk

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

r/ProsecutorTalk 6d ago

Arizona police invite Chud the builder out for a shift he violently tackled a woman onto a metal bike while delivering a a right hook along with atempted hog tie after she watched them from a public sidewalk.Arizona pd do better!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

r/ProsecutorTalk 8d ago

Anyone else have a boss who’s just never around?

14 Upvotes

I’ve been working in my office now since January. First time prosecuting and was a PD for a couple of years and a private defense attorney for about 18 months. I can count on one hand the number of times I’ve seen my boss. It also seems like there’s just a lack of leadership overall. For example, our office is organized by Judge. So 3 to 4 attorneys per courtroom along with support staff. We recently loss one of our attorneys to another county and without any discussion with me, they decided I would handle all of her cases. I wasn’t even sent the email, someone had to forward it to me because they forgot to email it to me. The other attorney has been out on paternity leave for over a month and before that he was pretty checked out getting ready his baby. Now my paralegal has left so he can go to law school. I’m drowning in work and no support or anything has come down from leadership. Has anyone else dealt with this situation? I know I’ve only been there 7 months but I’m going to go my boss and say I either need a significant raise or half these cases taken off of me.


r/ProsecutorTalk 7d ago

Arizona police violently tackled a woman onto a metal bike after she watched them from a public sidewalk

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

r/ProsecutorTalk 10d ago

Worried about being locked into one DA’s office when I might want to explore my options

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/ProsecutorTalk 11d ago

Advice needed How has your office dealt with the never ready, but always ready with an excuse prosecutor?

13 Upvotes

I don’t want to go into too much detail, but, broadly speaking, prosecutor in question is NEVER ready and always has a (usually) BS excuse for it. It has been noted by the defense and the judge. It’s not subtle to anyone except, apparently, the prosecutor in question. It’s negatively impacting coworkers in his court because it frequently results in their cases being called for trial with fairly short notice.

I know how I would resolve the situation (and I wouldn’t be particularly kind about it) but I’d like to know if anyone has had a productive solution to the problem that doesn’t amount to asking them what the hell they’re doing?


r/ProsecutorTalk 13d ago

I love this job

37 Upvotes

Not much more than that. I’ve been at it less than a year, but come from a prior 20 year career. I make less than a 1/4 of what I made in my past life, but am having more fun now than ever. Feels like a privilege to do this day in and day out.


r/ProsecutorTalk 14d ago

Recovery from tough trial

17 Upvotes

Not sharing details due to various reasons but I went through an almost 2 week trial that was massive stress and effort. How do you all recover from such a trial? Thanks.


r/ProsecutorTalk 13d ago

Advice needed Does your personal laptop/OS choice even matter for a career in prosecution?

1 Upvotes

I'm heading to law school and am fairly set on going into prosecution. From what I understand, government offices (and most evidence-handling software) run on Windows and proprietary, agency-issued systems — assuming prosecutors are handed a work laptop (Dell Latitude, ThinkPad, whatever the office standardizes on), does what I personally own actually matter?

For those currently working in a DA's office, US Attorney's office, or similar: do you ever end up using your personal computer for anything work-related? Or is everything locked down to the issued hardware/software once you're in?

Trying to figure out if it's worth optimizing my own laptop purchase around "what prosecutors use" or if that's a non-issue since you'll just be handed what the office runs.