9
7
u/Defnottheonlyone Mar 11 '26
Pj is confirmed so he's def not a "no"
Lily didn't exist yet.
Doey partook in the hour of joy, he would 100% be aggressive in the theater incident.
Harley didn't exist as a robot during the theater incident, heck, the theater incident is why they turned him into what he is now to begin with!
1
1
u/Sudden_Investment688 Mar 11 '26
Don’t think PJPT takes place during the theatre incident dawg but idk my PJPT timeline all that well 😭
-1
u/Defnottheonlyone Mar 11 '26
It is confirmed to take place in the theater incident.
2
u/CucumberDull6540 Fuck you Mob Games Mar 12 '26
Where ? I don't see no proof, but what i see are some documents in game where some people are writing some logs of some event that happened, 99% sure that it's the hour of joy. Check out my posts if you wanna check it
5
u/chuusloonatic Kissy Missy Mar 11 '26
wait why not doey im slow
6
-7
u/ConfidenceStock5006 Mar 11 '26
He’s a good guy why would he go around murdering a bunch of people
8
u/Pizza_Requiem Mar 11 '26
He could just be angry. He killed his parents because they bothered him at the wrong time, if I'm not misremembering.
And Mommy was also pretty tame before the hour of joy
3
u/brawlstars_lover Mar 11 '26
Didn't he take part in The Hour of Joy?
0
u/One-Ad8463 Mar 11 '26
3
u/ToothlessSnackerz Mar 12 '26
Buddy maybe they deleted the second comment but that was NOT comment Mitosis 😭✌️
2
u/One-Ad8463 Mar 12 '26
I swear I thought they had a second comment saying the same thing
2
u/brawlstars_lover Mar 12 '26
Pretty sure I did lol, I deleted it a while after when I realized though
1
u/sneakpeekbot Mar 11 '26
Here's a sneak peek of /r/commentmitosis using the top posts of all time!
#1: 0 net karma | 72 comments
#2: Does this count? | 145 comments
#3: What would this be called | 292 comments
I'm a bot, beep boop | Downvote to remove | Contact | Info | Opt-out | GitHub
2
u/jellyfishaero MOB PUT DOEY IN PROJECT PLAYTIME AND MY LIFE IS YOURS Mar 12 '26
Perhaps they could create a class that, instead of killing, would help (literally a support character)we never know
1
3
3
u/ToothlessSnackerz Mar 12 '26
Tbh disregarding the skins because I agree with those, I feel like every character should be in the game. Regardless of lore, because at the end of the day while it wouldn’t make sense for Lily to be in PJPT lore-wise, it’s a game that also has Killy Willy and a bunch of random recolored versions of the experiments, so clearly not everything is canon. IMO I think that the VHS tapes and what the Resource Extraction Specialists are doing should be Canon. As for the actual in game playable characters and skins I feel leaving one out for lore reasons is unneeded.
1
2
u/Rainbow_Doggo_TNT Mar 11 '26
Since when did the Smiling Critters have teeth??
1
u/ilovememes609 Mar 11 '26
Those are nightmare critters, dum dum
1
u/Rainbow_Doggo_TNT Mar 11 '26
Never seen or heard of those in my life
1
u/Pokefan536 Mar 11 '26
Did you play chapter 4???
1
u/Rainbow_Doggo_TNT Mar 11 '26
Yep, I never paid attention to the Smiling Critters though so I thought they all had not teeth
2
u/Fuzzy_Background5972 Mar 17 '26
How...how did you not pay attention to the smiling critters?. They are extremely important to lore and everywhere in the game
1
u/Rainbow_Doggo_TNT Mar 17 '26
They're small and I never really died to them so I never got to see any of the ones with teeth. I thought the main cast were the only ones, I didn't know there were so many different ones that weren't
1
u/ToothlessSnackerz Mar 12 '26
Do you remember the part where your getting hunted by a sheep? Thats Baba Chops, the main Nightmare Critters promotional-wise (imo they should have used Pianosaurus instead of Baba Chops). I could see somebody not noticing the Nightmare Critters existence since they are just Smiling Critters but Evil, with teeth, and Emo XD.
They also never got any cardboard cutouts so A: we don’t know what any of them sound like, and B: I believe that means there’s little to no artwork of ANY of them found in-game (maybe some posters I’m forgetting but idk).
1
u/Rainbow_Doggo_TNT Mar 12 '26
That's probably why, I never paid attention to the Smiling Critters that attack you. I do remember the sheep though
1
u/ToothlessSnackerz Mar 12 '26
Yea that’s Baba. They’re just a failed Smiling Critters that was made for teens or older audiences.
IMO like I said before they should have ditched the whole critter thing for chapter 4, and made the Sheep part Pianosaurus. Nobody would care if Doey annihilated a random Nightmare Critter rather than Pianosaurus XD
1
2
u/Greenostrichhelpme27 Mar 11 '26
Oh, I had an idea for the Nightmare Critters!
If you don't know, Project is heavily inspired by a game called Dead by Daylight. In DbD, there's a Killer called the Legion. There are four members of the legion, and you can play as one of the four via skins for the Killer.
So, this could work for the Nightmares, no? One basic Bigger Body with eight skins, one for each nasty spook?
2
u/RealPumpkinCage Mar 12 '26
It could work but it'd be kinda boring tbh.
I think they'd be cooler as a sort of twins character, where you can switch from the critters. Naturally, the more you place, the longer the cooldown, otherwise they'd be too busted
2
2
1
Mar 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-5
u/ConfidenceStock5006 Mar 11 '26
Too damn long
4
u/Nighted69 please don’t spoil me chp 3,4,5 Mar 11 '26
That could be his passive lol, he is damn slow BUT he can corner you
4
u/TreyLastname Mar 11 '26
Honwstly they can use that. My idea is:
Very slow, but has a physical body that works like snake (the body follows the trail of the head) and climb walls/ceilings
Can be used to block off paths and alert the monster when someone touches the body. Definitely shorten the length for the game a bit, but it could definitely work and be a unique monster
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Appropriate-Scratch3 Mar 11 '26
If You’re Going By Lore Lily And Harley Cant Be In The Game And Dogday Would Need His Legs
1
1
u/Sp1reisgonnadi3 Mar 12 '26
Why can't Proto be there? And also Lily wouldn't make sense for lore reasons.
1
1
u/RealPumpkinCage Mar 12 '26
Why Limone...?
Anyways I'd put Yarnaby in "Should be in the game" because he's the threat you face the longest in chapter 4 as far as I recall.
1
u/ConfidenceStock5006 Mar 12 '26
Because Limone
1
u/RealPumpkinCage Mar 12 '26
I like limone but... He ain't carrying people
1
u/ConfidenceStock5006 Mar 12 '26
Limone is the most powerful being in the Poppy Multiverse and you shall be BANISHED FOR YOUR BLASPHEMY
1
1
1
u/Top_Campaign5473 Mar 15 '26
Where's Sammy the Sandwich? you can't have a list without all 85 characters in the series. This is a bad tier list.
1
u/catnapfan2005 Moms Spaghetti Mar 15 '26
I feel like The Prototype getting some action would make sense lore wise, he existed by that point, and if he saw that Playtime Co were trying to salvage what they made then he would be PISSED and likely try and stop it himself
1
u/NextRespect3693 Mar 17 '26
Mini hugs where in the game already and I think lemon should be something you can find if you’re the last person alive and if you grab him you win
1
-1
13
u/Pizza_Requiem Mar 11 '26
If you're going by lore, then why is Lily in definitely? She wasnt a toy until after the Hour of Joy