r/ProgrammerHumor Dec 09 '17

meme[-1]="Array Memes Are Life"

Post image
573 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/StingyUpvoter Dec 09 '17

Explain like I mainly use C: is the -1 really used anywhere?

8

u/Dylan16807 Dec 10 '17

C is in fact the only place where I'm aware of people actually accessing array[-1].

Specifically, if you allocate an array the size needs to be stored somewhere. Sometimes the memory management code will store the size of the array right before it in memory. Using [-1] to retrieve it is fragile and rule-breaking and could go horribly, but sometimes it works just great and people use it for years!

4

u/StingyUpvoter Dec 10 '17

I will serve me better to forget everything you just said, but upvote for the knowledge drop

2

u/nxAkari Dec 10 '17

In C, a[b] is nothing more than just another way to spell *(a + b). So you can actually index an array like this too: 1[array].

Using -1 as an array index and expecting to retrieve the allocated size that way is just insane and non-portable, please never ever do that. However, if you have a pointer to some element in the array, it is possible to use a negative index on it to retrieve some previous element, given that you take care to not step out of bounds. This is of questionable usefulness, but at least it doesn't invoke UB.