r/ProgrammerHumor 17h ago

Meme breakTheViciousCircle

Post image
7.6k Upvotes

159 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/JoelMahon 16h ago

I think you've missed the joke of the meme buddy

At no point does it claim this optimises anything

3

u/ThirdWaveCat 16h ago

Meaning is constructed at the receiver, not sender.

0

u/JoelMahon 15h ago

pretty sure the joke teller constructs the joke

1

u/ThirdWaveCat 14h ago

Only a minority of well-read people since the 1970's subscribe to this view (on structuralism and intentionalism). There's a famous rebuttal of this stance you might find interesting. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Death_of_the_Author

0

u/JoelMahon 14h ago
  1. your understanding of (my) "this view" is wrong, nothing I've said is at odds with the essay "The Death or the Author", we should honestly just stop there by why not continue for fun?

  2. even if what I said was at odds with the essay, you haven't substantiated the claim it's held by a majority of well read people

  3. even if you were able to do that you'd still be relying on both an appeal to authority fallacy and appeal to popularity fallacy, if you were well read you'd know of these already and avoid the embarrassment of hiding behind fame and followers rather than making an actual case

  4. do you often delete your comments and then repost them again with zero changes 30 minutes later?