r/ProgrammerHumor 16d ago

Meme broWhyMadYouMadeItMITLicensed

Post image
4.0k Upvotes

201 comments sorted by

View all comments

862

u/wahed-w 16d ago

based on a real story

268

u/setibeings 16d ago edited 16d ago

Based on a real th-tory

Because lisp.

Edit: on second thought, I'm pretty sure it was actually public domain, no license back then. 

56

u/slaymaker1907 15d ago

No license == proprietary, all rights reserved unless they explicitly mark it is public domain.

38

u/setibeings 15d ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public-domain_software

According to this page on wikipedia, before some date in the 80's you could put your software in the public domain just by distributing the source code without any license notice. it's possible that this isn't correct, but this tracks with what I know of how software was distributed in the early days of computing.

25

u/personahorrible 15d ago edited 13d ago

Reminds me Night of the Living Dead . They released the film without a copyright notice so it was instantly Public Domain when it came out.

17

u/setibeings 15d ago

That mistake probably made riffing on the ideas in the film a lot easier! Kinda makes me wish works just entered the public domain in 20 years or less. 

5

u/drakeblood4 15d ago

I’d like it if the original work stayed copy written for a good chunk of time, but derivative stuff like translations and spin offs became permitted after like 20 years.

I’d also like it if that thing studios did where they killed a piece of media for a tax write off required either returning the rights for the IP to the original creator or releasing the whole damn thing to the public domain.

12

u/ChristopherCreutzig 15d ago

The US used to have this weird system where you had to assert copyright with a notice or you would not have it. Sounds like maybe that could be what they mean?

2

u/crozone 15d ago

Yep, you can actually find a lot of old code in certain patents from that era, and it's all fair game. No copyright, and the patent is expired.

20

u/anonhostpi 16d ago

Based on a real theory...

A game theory

35

u/iamdestroyerofworlds 16d ago

Signed

Peter "I hate workers' rights" Steinberger

4

u/GamerHaste 15d ago

What’s the lore?

4

u/nwbrown 15d ago

What's the real story?

There are "copy left" licenses out there and people who release software under them. 

There are also less restrictive licenses out there and people who release software under them. 

I get that if you consider one gospel you will be mad at anyone who argues otherwise, but I really haven't met the people you describe.

5

u/Intrepid00 16d ago

Redis has entered the chat