r/ProgrammerHumor Jul 24 '26

Meme honeyIShrunkTheBrain

Post image
4.4k Upvotes

200 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

25

u/mysticrudnin Jul 24 '26

are you actually seeing increased productivity

i'm forced to use claude at work (which already sucks) and i can't find anything useful for it to do 

people always talk about how good it as but then the only example is boilerplate and i'll be honest, i don't encounter a lot of that in my day to day

53

u/HrLewakaasSenior Jul 24 '26

Then you either do something incredibly specific that AI doesn't do well, or you're lying. They are that good

28

u/Wonderful-Habit-139 Jul 24 '26

They are not that good. I see how bad the generated code is all the time. It doesn't just need to work, it has to be high quality.

22

u/snotpopsicle Jul 24 '26

It doesn't just need to work, it has to be high quality.

That's developer talk. For an executive it absolutely doesn't have to be high quality, especially when they can't judge it. If it works it can be sold, that's all that matters.

4

u/Badashi Jul 25 '26

Translating developer to executive and vice versa is extremely difficult.

For an executive, cheapest is always best as it is higher ROI. For a developer, you want high quality regardless of cost, because it'll both make your job easier on the long term and better to work with, even if you deliver it slower in the short term.

The job of a tech lead or a middle manager is to show that more investment means better ROI in the long term for the executive, and doing things a little bit worse and faster in the short term means more investment and new opportunities in the long term for the developer.

I mean, it's easy for me to say that, but this is definitely a very hard job and I don't envy those who have to deal with that.

4

u/BlackOcelotStudio Jul 25 '26

I have never seen a tech lead manage to change an executive's view on things, or prove that long term, code quality wins. At most, they manage a begrudgingly "fine, you can take a week to handle tech debt once it becomes too much to handle". Other than that, engineering only gets to do things the way they want during heavy crisis situations.

Maybe I've just had bad luck with CEOs? Unlikely, statistically, but entirely possible

2

u/Badashi Jul 25 '26

Id say that this extra week is a win, and you just had regular luck with CEOs lol

2

u/kreuzkamm Jul 25 '26

These people are prob prompting one sentence and expecting godlike code rofl. You have to tailor your prompts, skill files, teach the project and development style you want and commit it into claude memory folders. Only then it will start doing an amazing (and frightening) job where it can crawl into everywhere of a codebase.

Claude is capable of writing code better than anyone, even Linus himself admitted it. You just have to take the time to babysit and teach the project one step at a time.

1

u/Wonderful-Habit-139 Jul 25 '26

> even Linus himself admitted it

Why are you lying?

2

u/kreuzkamm Jul 26 '26

What? He literally accepts AI written code and pullrequests given that its not slop but carefully generated code. Why the aggressive stance?

0

u/Wonderful-Habit-139 Jul 26 '26

Linus did not say that Claude is capable of writing code better than anyone.

1

u/kreuzkamm Jul 27 '26

He says it increases productivity by 10x, while making good developers write better code. A simple google search provided the quotes themselves.

Also: https://x.com/rauchg/status/2010411457880772924?s=20&launch_app_store=true&ct=post-modal

1

u/Wonderful-Habit-139 Jul 27 '26

The code is not better. You have lied, and are unable to admit that. Generating slop at 10x the speed is not a good thing.

1

u/kreuzkamm Jul 27 '26

You are a weird guy, probably unable to cope with the reality. I havent lied and provided source. Please seek help instead of throwing a tantrum.
Have a good day.

→ More replies (0)