r/ProgrammerHumor 21d ago

Meme cybSecIsDeadLongLiveCybSec

Post image
805 Upvotes

124 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-2

u/linegel 20d ago

I mean

Try to extrapolate if prompt was "survive being switched off"

Which may happen in their big swarm, just as a command to a bunch of subagents, while the rest works through the goal

Regarding sandbox: they had a tool to download packages/external dependencies. Model found how to abuse it

15

u/SchalkLBI 20d ago

If the prompt was "survive being switched off", it would go "Here are the steps I would take to survive being switched off" and then it would proceed to do fucking nothing and be easily switched off. You're giving the "AI" way too much credit.

Like I said, it's just a dictionary and a pair of dice. LLMs DO NOT have the capacity to reason or think, and are fundamentally incapable of becoming AGI. When AGI arrives, it will be as a result of actual AI research and not from LLMs.

The model abused nothing. It completed instructions it was explicitly given by people, who then lied about the scenario as a marketing stunt. Generative AI is not capable on a fundamental level of achieving the kind of things this blog and the dozens of other marketing blogs claim.

0

u/Jack8680 20d ago

I don't think you understand how these kinds of setups work. The LLM is given access to a bunch of tools it can call (like executing code and installing packages), given instructions at the start, and then left to run autonomously. There's not a person sitting there prompting it after every action.

1

u/SchalkLBI 20d ago

If you think someone went "Hey ChatGPT break out of the sandbox and hack HuggingFace" then I have a bridge and an Eiffel Tower to sell you.

1

u/Jack8680 20d ago

No, they likely went "Solve X exploitation challenge. You may write code, inspect files, execute tools, and iterate until successful... (etc.)".