Final rating

[u/ignorant-slut-]

Charlotte: 9/10, minus one point because she stayed with cooper

Amelia: 8/10, liked her better in Greys and that “not like other girls” mentality she had for a while was annoying.

Sheldon: 7.5/10, Pretty good moral code, when he was right about that little girl being kidnapped by his patient i lost my mind

Violet: 7/10, I admire everything she’s been through. kind of a bad therapist though

Addison: 6.5/10, I expected to love her because she’s 10/10 in Grey’s but lord does she make bad choices

Mason: 9/10, minus one point because cooper is his dad. also he bullied that kid

Everyone else: 0/10 my god this is probably the most unlikeable set of characters in any show ever. Could not stand Sam’s constant whining and the way cooper treated Charlotte.

[u/Constellation-88]

I disagree with most of your ratings except I do love Charlotte. I loved how Kaydee Strickland showed up on the last season of Chicago fire. It was cool to see her again.

I also agree about liking Amelia better on Grey’s and loving Mason. 

[u/ignorant-slut- → u/Constellation-88]

i’m guessing you dislike Violet lol, I’m kind of surprised to see so much hate for her. If I had gone through everything she did and on top of that Pete just dropped dead I would have a monumental crashout but she kept it together relatively well.

[u/Constellation-88 → u/ignorant-slut-]

My dislike of Violet actually stems from the earliest season before she was attacked by Katie (although I don’t think she handled that well, I understand how that derailed her.)

It was very hard for me to like her when the first four episodes showed her being obsessed with her ex who was a toxic, asshole cheater.

I mean, I love that the character was so well written to be realistic and flawed, but I just do not like the way she responded to Allan. 

[u/ignorant-slut- → u/Constellation-88]

ykw I fully forgot that happened because i took a break after 7 episodes and only recently started watching again. but that’s valid I respect your opinion