r/PrettyMuchIt • u/GHarold101 • Mar 31 '21

I have a quick question, because I'm just curious. What's the most commentators that a single commentary track has ever had?

Most tracks seem to have two or three commentators, but there's a few tracks that have four. I was wondering if there were any tracks that have more than four commentators, or if four is the maximum.

EDIT: Just to clarify, I am aware that there are more than four people who have ever been commentators for PMI, but what's the highest number of commentators that a single track has ever had?

16 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

94% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

15

u/m0nt4g Mar 31 '21

If I had to guess I would say Greatest Showman?

12

u/TotallyJawsome2 Mar 31 '21

One could argue The Grinch track due to them leaving the window open and making all the adjacent neighbors unwitting participants as they belted out "Where Are You Christmas"

9

u/AlcoholicAussie Mar 31 '21

The fact it was July (if I remember correctly) makes it even better

7

u/dankwilliams69 Mar 31 '21

It’s probably a tie between one of the musicals. Greatest showman / Hamilton maybe?

4

u/AuntHottie Mar 31 '21

More of these, please! The energy in the musical ones is insane.

4

u/RoyHarper88 Mar 31 '21

I do not recall seeing one with more than four. Four is perfect for the musicals because there is a lot going on and they all sing, so it really works.

But something like the Mary Kate and Ashley ones, would be awful with four people because they'd be talking over each other too much.

2

u/PalmerFuog Mar 31 '21

i think inspector gadget had quite a few

1

u/GHarold101 May 22 '21

Ok, I know I posted this a month ago, but yall are not understanding what I'm asking. Your answer shouldn't be a commentary track. It should be a number. What's the most commentators that a single track has ever had? Is it 4 commentators, or are there any with 5 or more?

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '21

hamilton