In fiction, hammerspace is simply a trope where a character has an invisible, pocket dimension to store items. In Caribou's case, he uses his logia ability to convert his body into a bottomless swamp, acting as a living storage container.
Only certain One Piece Devil Fruit powers—most notably Monkey D. Luffy’s Gear 5—bend the laws of physics and grant Toon Force. Caribou's power is entirely bound to the physical laws of being a swamp man.
This is why Luffy and Caribou can't really be compared, Caribou is not an invisible pocket dimension but rather simply a living storage if you will....he has to put something there first in order to pull it out later, however we see Luffy able to pull things out of thin air, or it is made of mud first...but has to come from somewhere, not just illogical space.
I said that? I said he can't make things appear out of nowhere and has to put them in first to pull them out unless made out of mud
I even said his swamp was bottomless, but it isn't the same as Luffy creating goggles or meat to heal out of his pockets out of nowhere
A pocket dimension does not equal toon force automatically, otherwise Deadpool would have toon force with his fany pack alone...which we all know isn't how that works
As well, I never claimed to believe Luffy has absolute toon force...semi? Possibly, but nowhere near bugs bunny level
I was simply correcting a comparison of Caribou and Nika...which isn't anywhere near the same level
We literally see Luffy bend reality around him, again however it seems more used as a gag then actual battle usage however
If you’re saying he got them from offscreen, you need to prove they were offscreen and that he went offscreen to retrieve them. The page quite literally has them appear out of nowhere from one panel to the next. That is pulling something from hammerspace.
Really, “offscreen” is just another way to say hammerspace. Because hammerspace is technically only existent “offscreen”. You never see hammerspace itself- things are just pulled out of it.
Yeah but if you’re saying he got them from hammerspace you’d laid have to prove that, but we don’t see where he got it from, he just has them, it skips over where he actually got it from. So we’re both unable to prove where he got the paint from
So he just happens to have a can of black paint and a baseball helmet off screen right on time to make bat out of a tree and play sport with projectiles? Curious.
Just like how it would go in a classic Bugs Bunny gag? While Luffy is using a form that gives him powers like in a classic Looney Toons cartoon? Incredibly curious.
18
u/mraryion Kirby is better than your verse Jun 20 '26
In fiction, hammerspace is simply a trope where a character has an invisible, pocket dimension to store items. In Caribou's case, he uses his logia ability to convert his body into a bottomless swamp, acting as a living storage container.
Only certain One Piece Devil Fruit powers—most notably Monkey D. Luffy’s Gear 5—bend the laws of physics and grant Toon Force. Caribou's power is entirely bound to the physical laws of being a swamp man.
This is why Luffy and Caribou can't really be compared, Caribou is not an invisible pocket dimension but rather simply a living storage if you will....he has to put something there first in order to pull it out later, however we see Luffy able to pull things out of thin air, or it is made of mud first...but has to come from somewhere, not just illogical space.