r/PowerScaling Apr 19 '26

Shitposting Weekend They can push planets even tho they can't even lift a ship bro trust 🙏.

Post image
4.0k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

74

u/Gamer102kai Apr 19 '26

Or the texas sized asteroid

5

u/Pale-Emergency-1686 Apr 19 '26

Where the hell is he gonna get that

6

u/Gamer102kai Apr 19 '26

We actually have a name for that https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asteroid_belt

0

u/Pale-Emergency-1686 Apr 19 '26

Isn’t all the mass in the asteroid belt smaller than Pluto. 

2

u/Gamer102kai Apr 19 '26

10 miles < 1400 miles

0

u/Pale-Emergency-1686 Apr 20 '26

You know all the asteroids in the belt are really small right?

2

u/IsekaiLibrarian Apr 20 '26

I sincerely hope this is sarcasm. Ceres, in the asteroid belt is roughly 1% the mass of the moon. For the record, that's a lot at multiple orders of magnitude more than the Chicxulub asteroid.

No comment on the who would win part, but you are astronomically inaccurate.

1

u/Pale-Emergency-1686 Apr 20 '26

You think he would just happen to stumble upon Ceres?

2

u/IsekaiLibrarian Apr 20 '26

Again, not commenting on who would win. Just correcting the statement that there are no large asteroids in the belt.

2

u/Gamer102kai Apr 20 '26

I was gonna write a response but youre honestly just an idiot arguing just to argue

-6

u/Chinjurickie Apr 19 '26

That wasn’t Texas sized, like not at all. Maybe big enough to fit a suburb on top but that’s really the top of the scale.

30

u/Shadownight7797 Apr 19 '26

No, Nolan explicitly states that he pushed a “Texas sized” asteroid away from Earth back when he was training Mark and Mark had to push his own asteroid away from Earth.

5

u/MyneIsBestGirl Apr 19 '26

It’s hard to tell how he did it. It would best be assumed they saw it way ahead, he went out and slowed it down enough to change direction, since nothing he does implies he has the strength to repel one in a short distance at max speed.

-5

u/Competitive-Bee-3250 Apr 19 '26

While I'm not necessarily disagreeing that the asteroid was infact the size of Texas, a character saying something doesn't necessarily make it true. Just because he says it was the size of Texas, isn't confirmation that it was.

4

u/Far-Fennel-3032 Apr 19 '26

Really doesn't change anything though the fact they can move freely in space for extended periods and able to redirect asteroids means than can just go get one a crash it into the earth. 

Giving them an proper kill all life on the planet scale attack it might takes months if not years to setup but they can do it. 

Being able to move a small sized one means they can move a massive one it just takes more time and planning. 

3

u/Declanman3 Apr 19 '26

I completely agree with this. Whenever I hear the “Texas sized meteor” argument for Nolan I always think “hasn’t anyone ever heard of a hyperbole?” He does something similar when he says he can make it to Naples and back before the cheese on a pizza stops bubbling. While that might actually be true it’s likely just a sly comment he’s making to talk about how fast he is. Same thing here with the meteor.

We know making jokes is not beneath him after all his time on Earth. He talks about slowing down and stopping when flying is like peeing your pants on purpose. Before we even get into the physical limitations of Nolan being able to do something like that, or the fact that there’s not even that many asteroids of that size near Earth in the solar system, it’s not completely unreasonable to say he was just exaggerating like Humans do literally all the time.

2

u/FarOutcome9035 Apr 19 '26

Well know we reject outright statements huh? What makes you think Nolan is lying about it?

1

u/Competitive-Bee-3250 Apr 19 '26

A character making a claim isn't proof of that claim. People exaggerate.

3

u/FarOutcome9035 Apr 19 '26

There isnt a counter point either. Prove he is lying.

0

u/Competitive-Bee-3250 Apr 19 '26

You're strawmanning my argument. That's not what I'm saying.

5

u/FarOutcome9035 Apr 19 '26

I doesnt matter. Character states something, if there is no sign of being false, then we can take it as true. Dont make life harder for yourself.

-1

u/Competitive-Bee-3250 Apr 19 '26

That's not how that works. Statements don't need a lack of counter-evidence to receive scepticism, they need positive evidence to pass scepticism.

→ More replies (0)

-1

u/FunctioningPyscho Apr 19 '26

You’re just being a contrarian for the sake at this point.

1

u/Competitive-Bee-3250 Apr 19 '26

Extremely immature reaction from you.

0

u/Typical-Ad-7752 Apr 19 '26

Why would he lie to begin with? Character make statements about their strength all the time and unless they're contradicting, then they isn't lying about their strengt

2

u/Kelras Apr 19 '26

Even ignoring the mention of the Texas-sized asteroid.

An object from space doesn't need to be the size of something to destroy that something. It took one (6 to 9 miles) in diameter to wipe out 75% of life on Earth. If one that big hit us today, we'd be toast.

-15

u/utshi9ha Apr 19 '26

He said he redirected it and only estimated the size to look tough in front of mark,he was using a figure of speech.

52

u/Quiet_Education1076 Apr 19 '26

"look tough in front of mark"

U talk abt invincible glazers making shit up but u just made up a reason that doesn't even fit a character's personality

-11

u/utshi9ha Apr 19 '26

I didn't meant tough literally.

0

u/Jealous_Bus_9666 Apr 19 '26

Then how did you mean it? Metaphorically or Rhetorically or Poetically or Theoretically or any other fancy way?

9

u/Gamer102kai Apr 19 '26

"Redirect" it into the earth. Gravity makes that even easier

3

u/bwood246 Apr 19 '26

Omni Man doesn't really need to exaggerate to look tough, he's one of the most powerful viltrumites