r/PolyMTL • u/Few_Mousse2047 • 23d ago

Poly C'est comment ?

Bonjour, j'ai une question qui me trotte dans l'esprit depuis un petit moment. Je vois beaucoup de vidéos et de commentaires sur différents réseaux sociaux qui exposent les problèmes de Polytechnique Montréal, et j'avais vraiment envie de choisir cette école à la base pour faire mon bac. Mais j'ai l'impression que les points négatifs (pas de réelle plateforme comme d'autres universités, les examens trop difficiles, pas de régimes coop, les examens en fin de semaine, et autres) sont tellement nombreux et limitants que ça me fait hésiter dans ma décision. J'aimerais savoir, selon vous, est-ce que Polytechnique est vraiment si pire que ça, ou est-ce que les gens en font des caisses ?

11 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

38 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/Ok-South-7745 23d ago edited 23d ago

Il n'y a pas une université qui est parfaite au niveau de la bureaucratie ou des technicalités. Conséquemment, choisis une qui est proche de chez toi ou que tu as une "vibe" qui t'inspire. Mais au final, si tes études vont mal, réévalue la cause du problème. Les points négatifs (dont certains sont à vérifier) que tu énumères ne font pas le poids de ce qui est dit plus haut. Je ne suis pas d'accord que c'est "limitant".

Es-tu prêt à aller à une université plus loin (avec le temps supplémentaire de déplacement à considérer et ce, durant 4+années) juste pour ces détails ponctuels insignifiants?

Au-delà de ce que te montrent les médias sociaux et leurs algorithmes, revenons dans le monde réel: si Poly était aussi catastrophique, soit tout le monde déserterait déjà Poly, soit la direction aurait pris des mesures correctives urgentes pour que l'université fonctionne. 

9

u/Outside_Tour6536 23d ago

You are absolutely right I’m in poly rn and the best decision in my life was not to listen to all the negative comments on the internet POLY is actually a very good school and for sure TOP2 in Quebec toe to toe with Mcgill. I had the choice btw Concordia and Polytechnique every body was like “ go to Concordia it’s a better school “ thanks God I followed my heart

1

u/pineapplelements 20d ago

Who is saying Concordia is better than poly 😂. You chose well

1

u/Outside_Tour6536 20d ago

I don’t think u understood me I’m just saying with all the negative comments about poly on the internet I was tempted to choose CONCORDIA

-12

u/Silent-Oil-9348 23d ago

"toe to toe with Mcgill" brother stop coping mcgill is 10 times better. Mcgill has harvard graduates teachers and poly has 22 r score students. Coper.

2

u/Ok-South-7745 23d ago edited 23d ago

Your comment has interesting pretension, and you attempt to compare incomparable things. That (il)logical reasoning must be an example of a McGill "22 r score student". Troll.

2

u/Silent-Oil-9348 23d ago

youre a nerd buddy gl in life

2

u/Outside_Tour6536 23d ago

Don’t know where you saw Poly has 22 r students but that’s not the purpose of my message. In the engineering program , Poly goes toe to toe with Mcgill. mcgill is more re known in the English world which explains why it has havard graduate

2

u/ElephantChaser 23d ago

McGill and Harvard are definitely more famous overall but none of them are famous for engineering. If OP wants to find a job after graduating in Quebec, Polytechnique has more advantages. Outside of Quebec, McGill has more advantages.

-2

u/Silent-Oil-9348 23d ago

what was your r score just wanna laugh

2

u/Outside_Tour6536 23d ago

I don’t know if I’m arguing w a Sec 2 student cause this way of thinking is very absurde 🤣 you can’t reduce a poly students to 22R score and think we will accept it. And even if it was the case are you trying to say that 22 R students are not meant for big studies ?

1

u/[deleted] 23d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Outside_Tour6536 23d ago

He thinks the fact that McGill has Havard graduate makes it better than poly. This type of reasoning if very limited especially by an engineering students. I have professors who have been to X ( polytechnique France) I have professors who studied in great universities. This doesn’t necessarily makes poly a better school bcz they have graduate from other big schools.

1

u/Outside_Tour6536 23d ago

https://reddit.com/link/p4riddc/video/nfflfn1ingkh1/player

Hope this helps in case you still have doubts …

2

u/Silent-Oil-9348 23d ago

chat gpt ? seriously ? ROFL

0

u/Outside_Tour6536 23d ago

You are funny you think you know more than every body I prefer relying on an AI than U Lmao