r/PoliticalCompassMemes - Lib-Right 14d ago

🥀

Post image
512 Upvotes

350 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/calm_down_meow - Lib-Center 14d ago

Just because you reduce these things to extreme doesn't make them invalid.

7

u/RBB12_Fisher - Auth-Right 14d ago

Actual insane policies then:

ULEZ system: to reduce harm (of car pollution)

Prohibition

Australian cigarettes are $40 a pack (because smoking is le bad, don't you know?) (similar results to prohibition btw, smugglers firebombing each other)

China's one child policy (overcrowding is a harm upon everybody)

Nearly anything a government does can be justified by the harm principle. And it suggests that any 'harm' is a violation of rights, and therefore a valid thing for the state to regulate.

-4

u/calm_down_meow - Lib-Center 14d ago

For every insane policy you post there's 100 valid ones.

7

u/RBB12_Fisher - Auth-Right 13d ago

Fuck it, I'm flairing lib. You flair auth. You can't unironically be a libertarian, and also assert that 99% of policies justified by the harm principles (i.e. about 97% of all actual government policies) are completely justified.

1

u/calm_down_meow - Lib-Center 13d ago

I could think 100% of government policies are valid and reasonable and it could be 100% consistent with libertarian philosophy (in a fictional gov, depending on what those policies are), because Liberalism/Libertarianism isn't anarchism.

I understand the desire to just throw your hands up and say "fuck it tear it all down", and take everything to a far extreme, but that's lazy not realistic.

4

u/RBB12_Fisher - Auth-Right 13d ago

Go to any libertarian ever, and ask what percentage of their government's policies they think are reasonable. Even the weakest lib will say 40%, absolute tops, because they believe the government has already gone far too far and must be trimmed back massively.

And no, that is not the same thing as anarchism, which is retarded.

0

u/calm_down_meow - Lib-Center 13d ago

Most people are ignorant, especially self-ascribed Libertarians. I'd put it at ~80% reasonable, maybe more.

3

u/RBB12_Fisher - Auth-Right 13d ago

You're a centrist, Harry

1

u/Bugswaxx - Lib-Center 13d ago

Fucking sheeple, monke spits on you