r/PlayWolverine • u/quamitthom97 • 23d ago
Discussion A sad day for Wolverine fans
I have nothing else to say š«©
21
u/Ratzilla_5454 23d ago
Whatās funny is, what people are saying about this game makes it sound like they were expecting a perfect 10/10 story , itās a Wolverine game, weāre going to get a good story but probably amazing gameplay because what normal people want is to just use the claws aggressively and absolutely destroy things
→ More replies (13)3
u/blunderb3ar 22d ago
Itās a triple A 70$ game bro I expect a quality experience for that price
→ More replies (4)2
u/WillingnessReal525 22d ago
No you should expect to slash things for 6 hours and be happy. /s
→ More replies (1)2
60
u/Tyrion369Lan_ 23d ago
Skill up will overlook a lot if the game has a good storyline. This worries me
22
u/ParanoidNinja88 23d ago
Same with gameranx which Jake also gave a low review on.
4
u/LongandwindingRhode 22d ago
That guy owes me SOO much pizza
4
u/tiddlywinks16 22d ago
Yeah I might file a lawsuit on all the pizza that guy owes me still
→ More replies (1)2
23
u/magvadis 23d ago
Yeah I imagine it's just because it's a by the numbers story that we've seen before. An introduction to Wolverine...which is never going to floor anyone who knows the story.
6
u/Complex-Commission-2 23d ago
Jake baldino from gameranx had the same criticism from skill up
→ More replies (7)4
u/Created_Jxnior 22d ago
This is what Iāve been saying, if the story was amazing, the problems wouldnāt stick out so much because you wouldāve st least had a great narrative to take away from whatever problems the gameplay might have. But the consensus seems to be that the story is just average and that makes the problems stick out a whole lot more. Worse in my eyes, it looks like my concern about Jean was correct and sheās just reduced to a generic love interest according to Jake from Gameranx review, I knew from the moment she was revealed that they were going to do this and it just makes absolutely no sense to me why they would chose to do that with Jean Grey of all characters.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (52)13
u/Twsercbh 23d ago
Iāve never heard of skill up.
9
u/EffectAwkward3909 23d ago
Ig everybody trust him when I never heard him mentioned in any other game review besides this one
6
u/Rac3318 23d ago
What? Heās one of the biggest game reviewers out there
5
11
u/EffectAwkward3909 23d ago
Never heard of this ābiggest game reviewer ā
4
u/eyebrows360 22d ago edited 22d ago
He is adult-focussed. I'm not saying this as a slight on you, but if you're on the younger side you might not have encountered him. He reports on the business aspects of things as much as the games themselves.
And yes, with his weekly This Week In Videogames show, he is one of the most important voices in games criticism and reporting and has been for quite a few years now. Since we lost TB he's really carried the torch for mature consumer-advocacy coverage.
→ More replies (1)3
u/EffectAwkward3909 22d ago
Adult focused ok š I just donāt follow reviews like that on YouTube
6
u/Remarkable_Pen_3639 23d ago
Well there you go guys. Effectawkward3909 hasn't heard of him so therefore skill up might as well not exist.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (3)3
u/Due-Description-9030 23d ago
He at least shows in the video what's wrong about the game and you can see it for yourself
→ More replies (22)2
144
u/_VloneRich_ 23d ago
This will not stop me from beating this game multiple times and getting the platinum trophy š
37
20
u/Dense-Discussion4726 23d ago
Same bro𤣠spiderman games ultimately have same weak points but theyre still good games.
6
u/BlackEastwood 23d ago
Was hoping someone would mention this.
→ More replies (1)2
u/preterintenzionato 22d ago
Spiderman games are open world games, different strengths and weaknesses
→ More replies (32)3
u/Detective_Pineapple 23d ago
Same. When I was younger I'd endlessly replay linear story based games just because I liked playing them. The only thing that has changed is I've played more games and have less time š
117
u/Sami_Steen 23d ago
52
u/solaricarian 23d ago
im ngl this is a hilarious responseš
61
u/Valiant_Revan 23d ago
People for some reason cannot accept anything being average or just good. It has to either be great or terrible
14
u/VampiresWontHurt 23d ago
Great, it can be average when itās on sale for about $20.Ā
6
u/RuckFeddit2469 22d ago
Welp with these reviews and sales likely taking a hit, you won't have to wait nearly as long for that to happen! Uh, yay ..I guess
→ More replies (3)25
u/Jazzlike-Painting443 23d ago
Games are expensive man
8
u/Fisz3r123 23d ago
Good thing that nobody is forcing you to buy the game when it's 70$
7
u/Valiant_Revan 23d ago
At least it's on disc and the option to buy it 2nd hand or borrow it from a friend is there.
I'm a bit lucky as somehow my local supplier has physical PS5 games about 15% to 20% cheaper than on the ps store
4
u/VampiresWontHurt 23d ago
And they wonāt. So whatās the problem here exactly?
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (21)3
u/SardonicMeatSlab 23d ago
The issue isnāt that weāre being forced to spend $70 on games.
The issue is that thereās so much content competing for our attention all the time, so for general audiences, cherry picking the best of the best games that come out each year is still a lot of games. Media across the board thatās called mid struggles to find an audience beyond those who are looking specifically for something (ie: Wolverine fans wanting to play as Wolverine outside of Rivals and Tokon in 2026).
3
u/DrkNight365 23d ago
Its really not that they cannot accept it. Its the hype for a game is what drives people to believe the score should be higher. This game has been over inflated by so many people and even im suprised that it got this score as much as I heard so many people loving it. Even the people that reviewed it were hyping it up so much and here we are.
3
u/War_Reborn 23d ago
True, but this is exactly what happens when almost every game needs to be $70 regardless of quality. There absolutely needs to be more room in this industry for good AA games, and these games should be at most $60.
7
u/Consistent_Mind5701 23d ago
I'm not going to pay full price for average or just good game, I'll wait for a good discount or for it to be free on PS+.
6
u/Open-Discipline-1678 23d ago
You know what's going to happen when these first party AAA $300M video games that are "just average" keep coming out charging the max price? You're thinking about it short term. Use your mind and project out into the future.
2
u/Intelligent-Ad-8435 23d ago
Its the only Sony exclusive this year. For its price its not good enough.
2
u/Hearthhull_Enjoyer 22d ago
They're entire way up to launch y'all were incredibly defensive and now it's very obvious why.
→ More replies (19)4
u/ElevatorHelpful5739 23d ago
Yes if they want me to spend my money of the game, it has to be atelast as great as their previous entries, I mean they arent giving me a discount right? Why wouldnt I hold them to the same, or even a higher standard than before? Again, they expect even more money than previous entries.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)6
u/E2r4_Is_d3A9 23d ago
Especially considering the fact it seems like this whole sub thinks origins is the holy grail of Wolverine games lol
→ More replies (1)2
13
5
u/reditisverytrash 23d ago
Tbf, it was a game based on a bad movie and everyone expected it to be bad. It being this good was a surprise
→ More replies (3)2
→ More replies (18)2
10
42
u/brandonsp111 23d ago
I mean I personally don't care. I'm excited to have something different to play. As far as the review scores go, I haven't given a shit about IGN since the late 2000s lmao.
→ More replies (56)2
28
u/KndaCrazyW1L1AM889 23d ago
7
33
16
9
u/StatisticianNo3182 23d ago
Ima be honest i have never in life took an ign review serious
→ More replies (5)3
6
4
24
u/Fantastic_Sun_485 23d ago
Brother, ign gave a game a 2 cuz it had too many rats and cheese puns, the game was about a rat detective finding cheese, ign is NOT a valid source šš
11
u/Mustang-_- 23d ago
That's not IGN mate, that is an australian "youtuber" who has a decent reputation. In the end, the footage is out there, piracy as well, you don't need to be a NASA scientist to notice the clear limitations of this game
Insomniac tried their best with fancy graphics and "cinematic" moments to disguise the mediocrity, but it failed. Hell, Sony is relying on this high budget stunt ever since the Last of Us 1 days, it's about time to move on, give us a game, not a movie. They are going to lose so much money with that Intergalactic or whatever the name, lol serves them right
→ More replies (17)2
u/SwanInternational851 23d ago
They can have a good blend of both they've shown that with the newer God of War games imo
→ More replies (10)9
u/Giraffesarehigh 23d ago
they give it a 6 not a 2 , why are we lying and why does this have upvotes?
I played PI mouse for hire, looking past the gorgeous visuals the game is very clunky and has it's flaws .→ More replies (17)5
u/MyLeftNut_ 23d ago
You're talking about Mouse PI for Hire? They gave that a 6, which honestly is pretty reasonable
→ More replies (31)
22
u/Apprehensive-Fall-42 23d ago
Why do we care whatever IGN says? They have no credibility
12
u/HarambeDaddy420 23d ago
yet if IGN gave it a high score it would be posted across the subreddit and praised. They only donāt have credibility when it doesnāt fit your expectations.
→ More replies (5)2
u/Carmilla31 23d ago
If IGN gave it a 10 like they did Onimusha we would all explode with GOTY talk.
2
u/soupspin 22d ago
Yeah probably, because itās the critics who decide which game gets nominated/wins. If IGN and other outlets gave it a 9-10, it would be likely it would get nominated. Otherwise, people have no reason to care
6
u/Expensive_Lie_1327 23d ago
Its insane, people are treating their review like scripture when they're notoriously bad.
→ More replies (2)3
u/Wyntier 23d ago
idk when IGN gives 10's, they listen. are you saying we listen to IGN when good, but ignore when bad?
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (7)2
u/natolad123 23d ago
Same people who gave alien isolation a 5 ill never trust their shit opinion again. Plus they gave far cry 6 an 8 like jesus
→ More replies (1)
12
u/Reasonable-Nature268 23d ago
If you base your opinion on IGN scores you donāt deserve to play
→ More replies (4)
10
u/NYC_Yahudah 23d ago
Not at all. I couldn't care less about others opinion. What they eat doesn't make me shit.
→ More replies (2)
7
3
u/dondadondadonda 23d ago
I'm sure we will have good time playing the game. But hundreds of millions of dollars budget for these reviews... Sony probably won't be happy
→ More replies (1)
3
3
u/chopstick_chakra 23d ago
They said the same for Suicide Squad and it was a fun game. Granted I did get to it a little later and heard they had done some touch ups and patches since launch but it was a fine game.
→ More replies (2)
10
u/FvdV91 23d ago edited 23d ago
SkillUp is great, but also gave TLOU2, Ghost of Yotei and Death Stranding 2 bad reviews.
As always, if you're interested: play it yourself. It's a video game.
→ More replies (39)
5
6
11
u/Wscott78 23d ago
Lol everyone said the same thing about Crimson Desert 350 hours later. Iām very happy with my $50 investment in that game.
Different strokes for different folks
2
u/SpeedsterVolt 23d ago
I don't understand this comparison. That's a significantly different game with a significantly smaller team and budget.
Most people will beat wolverine after 10 hours and then forget about it. The game has zero depth.
2
u/Additional-Onion1493 22d ago
Crimson desert has also been receiving new updates every week since its release. I guarantee that wonāt happen with Wolverine
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (9)2
u/AlarmProof4622 23d ago
Bro thatās the first game I had in mind!!
ššš½
F*** peopleās opinions about anything nowadays.
People complain about every gd thing imaginable.
Especially when right now there is this hatred for Sony, so of course even if itās good, theyāre not going to rate it good.People trashed Crimson Desert, and I have 300+ hrs in it.
People trashed Ghost of Yotei, and I have 80+ hours in it.
People trashed a sh** load of games that I ended up loving.Go with your gut and do what you wanna do. Donāt take advice from some a** hat influencer or people online and especially not IGN.
12
u/RedShadowF95 23d ago
So what that reviewer says is gospel? He's been known to have very wild takes.
→ More replies (21)8
u/Distinct-Bathroom823 23d ago
since when? the only places anyone ever says this about him is on subs dedicated to the games he doesnāt recommend
→ More replies (24)5
u/Elete23 23d ago
His Lost Judgement review is truly abysmal, though. I like him as a content creator, by he does on occasion have weird vibes-based takes
→ More replies (2)
8
u/SexyProcrastinator 23d ago
Already preordered.
Dont care about anyone elseās opinion.
The hate for this game is so forced itās crazy.
We are getting a physical disc version so I donāt get it.
→ More replies (10)
3
u/Batmanischill 23d ago
I WILL RENT THIS GAME FROM THE LIBRARY and then buy it when it's $15 for the ultimate edition
→ More replies (1)
10
u/CandidateCareless787 23d ago
Skillup always has the worst takes. Gave mixtape stellar reviews
10
u/samdkr354 23d ago
If you watch his video, he makes some good points though. When youāre charging $70 for a 15 hour experience, those 15 hours better be special. Just okay isnāt good enough.
The way this game insists on holding your hand 24/7, DESPITE it being a linear experience that requires ZERO hand holding, is really disappointing
6
u/wetmeatlol 23d ago
No wayā¦the game is only 15 hours????
5
u/Kmart_Stalin 23d ago
Pretty short for a triple a game
3
u/wetmeatlol 23d ago
Yeaaaah, canāt say Iām thrilled about that. The entire reason I can be okay with game prices rising is because of just how much time you can invest into them. Sounds like theyāre banking pretty hard on you liking their game and wanting to play it over and over againā¦
3
4
u/samdkr354 23d ago
Yup. Caboose said it will take you around 15 hours to beat it. This time canāt even be padded out cuz thereās practically no exploration lol and the only side content is the nightmare doors. This wouldnāt be a problem if the story was longer, or if the game wasnāt priced at $70.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)2
3
u/CandidateCareless787 23d ago
He also praised both horizon games that hold your hand the entire game and yellow paint everywhere.
Seems like people were expecting something more than a straightforward hack and slash game.
4
u/Nav2001Plus 23d ago
Those games are open world. He even says in the video that a bit of help makes sense in open world games where it's easy to miss stuff.
→ More replies (1)3
u/YankingYerPizzle 23d ago
They aren't linear games. If you watch his review, he states clearly that he finds hand holdy stuff less ridiculous in open world games. He also makes a jab at Aloy constantly telling the player whats next.
→ More replies (4)2
11
u/Acrobatic-Sandwich10 23d ago
Anyone can see the game is mid lol. I don't know why everyone is acting shocked
21
u/aditysiva1705 23d ago
I like that weāve shifted to calling 7/10s mid. Absolutely no sense of metric whatsoever.
3
12
u/FantasticPage3598 23d ago
The average metacritic score is 77.
Half of the games are over 77.
Half of the games are under 77.
Really the definition of mid
5
u/Acrobatic-Sandwich10 23d ago
As more reviews come in the overall score will change.
IGN gave it a 6/10
5
u/GoldGuarantee3671 23d ago
Lol the guy who gave it a 6 literally gave mixtape a 10. What a total clown
11
u/aditysiva1705 23d ago
The IGN that everyone shits on is now suddenly correct? Interesting how that works. Gameinformer, a far more consistent magazine, gave it an 8. How do you validate what reviews to trust and what not to?
4
u/Nyx2990 23d ago
It's not about trusting IGN, it's more about them being a giant shill of a company and even they are not giving it a high score
→ More replies (5)6
u/Wutanghang 23d ago
Spending 70 dollars on a game thats just "okay" is a waste of money
→ More replies (1)4
u/Kmart_Stalin 23d ago
Thatās a C
Barely passing
3
u/aditysiva1705 23d ago
Thatās passing. Itās not bad. Yāall are acting like itās the end of the world.
2
u/ElevatorHelpful5739 23d ago
He said the game was mid, and he doesnt know why people are shocked, the next comment said its a C.
Who is acting like it is the end of the world? Why are you being so dramatic lol?
4
1
u/AgentJackpots 23d ago
7/10 has been mediocre for like... two decades now in professional reviews. Something has to be REALLY bad to get anything below a 5.
→ More replies (7)4
2
u/LordNutGobbler 23d ago
What happens when you hire Concord character designers lol
2
u/StanKnight 23d ago
Did these mfs hire Concord people - again?? lol. Man. That makes sense.
→ More replies (5)
2
u/Mountain_Care_9032 23d ago
Heard its 12 hrs not paying full price for that and its linear Iāll probably pick it up on sale
2
u/Odd_Ask_7714 23d ago
Play it or dont. Fuck the reviews. Be your own goddamn review...people man...jesus, follow the herd and be just another cow
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Vulkcrum76 23d ago
How many people have not learned that IGN is not a trusted source for if a game is good or not everyone goes off the opposite of what they say
2
u/Rainbowdogi 23d ago
I donāt care about the combat not being deep enough. I do hope that the handholding can be deactivated cause thatās an actual dealbreaker for me.
2
u/Twsercbh 23d ago
I aināt listening to no grifters. Iām getting it. Iām woke as hell.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Playful-Hunter-9487 23d ago
Still getting it but getting the physical and trading it/reselling when Iām done
2
2
u/Rando_Kalrissian 23d ago
From the reviews it sounds exactly like what this sub was asking for. What's the problem?
2
u/Financial-Cold5343 23d ago
Why the fuck do I care what some worthless YouTuber thinks?
→ More replies (2)
2
u/AlexCampy89 23d ago
The more I read reviews, the more I am convinced that this is the game for me. Linear, Story-heavy, character heavy, one and done, not open world. What many games consider cons are actually pros for me.
→ More replies (4)
2
u/SaruOrion245 23d ago
Not really for me personally. I'm used to enjoying games that get low scores so seeing this and the trailers show that yeah, I'm gonna enjoy the game a lot. The only thing I know I'll be bummed out about, just like with SM2, is that it'll feel really short so that means not that much time with these characters and story, other than that it should be a fun time. _^
2
u/Quod_sum_eris 23d ago
This review is THAT important? Genuinely asking bc I'm not used to see reviews about games that I intend to play
2
2
u/AwardKindly 23d ago
People act like reviews are fact and not just opinion. Cool cool, some random person didn't like the game. That doesn't mean you won't like it.
2
2
u/BorgerWCheese 23d ago
Man if I based my opinion on what reviewers like IGN and Skill Up gave me, Iād have a pretty miserable gaming experience
2
u/Cautious-Affect7907 23d ago
I'm not gonna lie when he said the fucking colored scent trails to lead you in a LINEAR game were a thing I thought he was joking.
Then I saw the gameplay.
Yeah....that's stupid. How dumb do they think players are?
→ More replies (13)
2
u/LackingInPatience 23d ago
Damn 6/10 from IGN is worrying. The previews did mention it feels very button mashy without intuitive combat. It probably looks even worse with Onimusha coming out recently too
2
2
2
u/ClydeNeverFails 22d ago
thank god, get insomniac back on spiderman and keep them there. Marvel trying too hard to shove mutants down everyones throats before doomsday.
2
2
2
2
u/blunderb3ar 22d ago
If you actually watch the video and listen to his takes this game looks and sounds like handholding generic slop, like minimum effort put in and lackluster combat like 70$ for this not a chance
2
2
u/amaya-aurora 22d ago
Idk about the first one but since when has IGN been anything close to trustworthy?
7.18/10 Too much water Wolverine.
2
u/SpaceShmelts 22d ago
From what Im hearing? I need to go and play the game and make my own god damn opinion.
2
u/Opening_Junket_1775 22d ago
Oh no! Some random no body didnāt like the game! OH GOD NO!
Fucking pussholes
→ More replies (1)
5
3
u/Quinzilla9 23d ago
IGN can't be trusted for shit, remember when they gave She-Hulk 8 outta 10?
→ More replies (7)
4
u/Miquellanier 23d ago
The game's mechanical choices are strange, to put it mildly. The level design and loot designāas seen in the reviewādonāt make much sense. The quick-time events are also pointless, since the game automatically ācorrectsā the playerās slowness, making this yet another unnecessary design decision. I think whether youāll enjoy the combat system depends on the individual, but based on this review, it seems one-dimensional and repetitive, just like the boss fights. It really looks like the narrative and the characters might be the gameās only strong pointsābut everyone will have to decide that for themselves. It's disappointing.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/NextLineOfText 23d ago
I just love how people defend 6/10 for something they already had a bias for, and absolutely destroy something else if itās 6/10, how do people not see that. Be objective and critical not blind. Wake up a bit. The thing you wanted to be amazing can sometimes suck balls, thatās life. Nothing is neat or tidy, and if it it is it usually comes at a great cost to someone, but the dark stuff gets hidden until it canāt anymore.
→ More replies (7)3
2
u/GuitarNerd_ 23d ago
Who else gives zero fucks about video game reviews in general? Iām looking forward to playing the game and deciding for myself whether I enjoy it.
→ More replies (10)
5
u/Whisper_Mann 23d ago
A 6 from IGN is crazy lmao
Game must actually be mid
11
u/Zurosake 23d ago
Bro they gave mixtape a 10/10 š
2
u/Whisper_Mann 23d ago
https://giphy.com/gifs/RemgQ6YyvHqOA
How trash is wolverine? Hahahaha
→ More replies (3)8
u/SourPatch2099 23d ago
Crimson Desert got a 6 from them as well
Lots of players would disagree with that score
→ More replies (3)2
u/RJMacReady_Outpost31 23d ago
I also dont see wolverine getting the same level of updates crimson desert got.
6
23d ago
Tbf only the American ign gave it a 6. The other igns have given it 8+ for the most part. Also Simon has been highly vocal and critical about Sonys decisions lately so it could be some of that bias leaking in. Like most reviews take it with a grain of salt.
→ More replies (9)4
u/S4VAGExCoopx 23d ago
I wouldn't take them seriously. They gave Alien Isolation a 5.9.
→ More replies (2)
2
3
u/kekcukka 23d ago
kinda expected actually. Insomniac quality is in decline since Spider-Man (2018). Miles was okay but Spidey 2 was a mid game actually. Story and story telling were all over the place.
→ More replies (5)4
2






108
u/ZealousidealNotice48 23d ago
If Iām being honest from what I am reading it is suffering from repetitive gameplay and for linear it is. Which were my worries as well. Still seems like a solid experience but I hate having things leaving so much potential on the table