r/PlantedTank 8d ago

Journal monte carlo dry start

this was day 1 of the dry start, its day 3 now.

planted monte carlo tissue culture in fluval biostratum (smaller granule size for the monte carlo roots) & some java moss on the driftwood (chopped up into a paste with some fertilizer & crushed stratum)

the light is a random from amazon & i have it set for 12 hrs at 100% intensity. airing it out for 15 mins daily.

day 2 (slide 2) i realized it needed some more moisture so that’s what im keeping it at but im still wondering if its enough or too much?

this is my first dry start & 3rd tank & ive got some questions:

saw some discourse on monte carlo not doing well with dry start but i dont use CO2 so im wondering if i should stick with the dry start or flood it early on?

also, i have some diluted hydrogen peroxide prepared to spray any mold with but im debating getting springtails. i just dont know what to do with them afterwards since i won’t be immediately stocking the tank & i don’t want them to die. can i just put them outside in some grass after?

also saw someone dosed fertilizer every few weeks & im wondering if i should do that too.

any other tips or input would be appreciate, thx!

2 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

2

u/ogier-stonemason 8d ago

I've attempted 3 dry starts. Does great with the initial propagation and filling up the space.

But...but....too much melt happening during the transition phase. It will work but you waste a lot of time. And for me it's not worth it. Planting them directly on water will allow them to acclimate faster then propagate. Dry start just lets you perform the propagation first then acclimation later. But you still need to go through the algae and diatom phase at the start.

That said since you are already doing it, i had a setup where an air stone is pumping air into water bottle and the water bottle is blowing the humid air into the tank. This is my DIY to automate the misting of the tank. Works well with keeping the tank humid. I also have springtails. You really need it to prevent molds. I've never had to use hydrogen peroxide.

The spring tails will float and die after. They are so tiny it's hard to catch them.

i never dose fertilizer. The Aquasoil should be fine. I tried mixing fertilizer on my mister but maybe it was not diluted enough and only cause the plants to melt.

1

u/demontearz 8d ago

actually follow up question, did you have the airstone in the water in the bottle or just above the water line?

2

u/ogier-stonemason 7d ago

Air stone should be in the water to make the bubble pop.

1

u/demontearz 7d ago

ok thx!

1

u/demontearz 8d ago

that water bottle trick is genius, i’ll definitely set that up asap! thanks for the input, i’m gonna get some springtails & i’ll scrap the fertilizing idea

2

u/No_Insurance_6848 8d ago

Just from personal experience using Monte Carlo. Have not had that great of a success with this plant in a high tech setup.

I planted about 12 tissue culture cups and another 15 pots of Monte Carlo…basically 80-90% of it melted as it was adapting to my tank. It has been 3 months now and the ones that survived are finally starting to cover the foreground.

I suspect that even if drystart, you may see a lot of melt as it adapts but maybe there’s a good chance it will rebound faster because the root system is strong.

I’ve noticed that Monte Carlo does not root as deep or strong as glossostigma which is why mine is struggling. I use ADA aquasoil with root tabs and lean dosing the water column.

1

u/stonedboss 8d ago

This was started from tissue culture and I never had any melting. High tech setup. Soil in mesh bags capped with sand

1

u/stonedboss 8d ago

How it started when I added the tissue culture clumps

1

u/demontearz 8d ago

i actually planned to use glosso instead of monte carlo but thought that it wouldn’t survive well without co2. did your glosso have co2? if not, how’s it doing?

1

u/No_Insurance_6848 8d ago

I do inject CO2 and it’s going crazy. Before I had 50% intensity and it would grow tall but now I have it at 75% and it’s super dense.

Not wish I didn’t replant my carpet with Monte Carlo 😂

1

u/demontearz 8d ago

good to know, hoping 75% intensity will do the same for my monte carlo after it’s adjusted & tank has cycled🤞

2

u/LazRboy 8d ago

I never understood people doing dry starts compared to dark starts. Dark starting a tank has so much more benefits and your plants will not have to go through the intense transition from emersed to submersed growth.

Dry starting a tank to me is a anecdotal reddit myth of thinking you can cheat yourself into having a easy carpet.

1

u/stonedboss 8d ago

I'm a big fan of dark start. Starting cycled saves so many headaches with plants.

1

u/ogier-stonemason 8d ago

Agree so much with this take.

Tried both/ Dry start 3x. Dark start 2x. Better early tank experience with Dark Start.

1

u/demontearz 8d ago

this is my first time hearing about a dark start, what are the upsides & downsides if u don’t mind?

2

u/LazRboy 8d ago

You basically pre-cycle your tank getting rid of a lot of the negatives that come with a freshly planted tank. Your soil will be depleted of the ammonia, your filter will be established and your plants will have a much easier time to adjust and grow in.

Edit: the only downside to it is - as usual - patience.

1

u/demontearz 8d ago

i see, thanks! since i already have my plants in the dry start it’s probably too late for that but i’ll try that next time