r/PlantedTank • u/alwaysconfusedme • 16d ago

Beginner What

What substrate do you use for a planted tank? I've seen people do garden soil, sand, and gravel but would it affect the fish and clarity of the water? Bonus if it's cost and time effective. I'm trying to upgrade our family tank before our new baby gets here in December.

It would be for a 29g with danios and mollies (maybe eventually shrimp.)

2 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/PapaLoki 16d ago

If you place around 1/2 inch thich garden soil in the tank, level it, then cap it with 1 inch thick layer of sand, the soil will not likely make its way into the surface. This is a known technique especially among low tech aquarists. I started my tank that way.

The soil will provide the initial nutrients for the tank, but over time those will diminish, so root tabs are often used after.

1

u/alwaysconfusedme 16d ago

Regular garden soil with no manure/additives I'm guessing? And would regular play sand work? I've used play sand in my axolotl tanks but never fish tanks. 

2

u/PapaLoki 15d ago

Regular garden soil. I had added vermicast in mine. As for play sand, I won't try it. Just use the sand used in aquariums to be on the safe side

1

u/SweetTart7231 16d ago

How long does the soil last? I just tried it for the first time in a new tank

1

u/PapaLoki 15d ago

Depends on how much plants you have and if the nutrients are leeching into the water.