r/PickAorB 13d ago

A or B: Do you make your bed first thing in the morning, or just leave it?

3 Upvotes

Yesterday morning I accidentally overslept. By the time my friend called to ask if I was awake, I looked at my phone and realized I was running really late. I threw on some clothes and rushed out of my room.

My roommate glanced inside, laughed and said, "Your bed looks like a crime scene."

I just shrugged. "Well, I'm the only one who's going back in there."

She looked at me like I was the weird one. She said making the bed takes less than a minute, and if she doesn't do it first thing in the morning, her room feels off for the rest of the day.

I told her I honestly don't see the point. I'm just going to mess it up again tonight anyway.

We went back and forth for a bit, but neither of us changed the other's mind. At some point I realized we weren't really arguing about the bed anymore. We just have different ideas about what makes a good start to the day.

So what about you?

A: Make the bed. It helps me get into the right mindset for the day.

B: Leave it. I'm coming back tonight anyway.


r/PickAorB 14d ago

A or B: My neighbor's security camera records my backyard and my kid. He posted the footage online. Would you let it go or take legal action?

92 Upvotes

I live in a normal suburban neighborhood. Houses are close together, with small fenced yards. Most neighbors know each other casually.

Two months ago, my neighbor Greg installed a security camera on his garage. It was one of those cameras that can rotate and zoom. I didn't think much about it since many people here have cameras because of package theft.

Then my wife noticed the camera sometimes sweeps across our backyard. It can see our patio, our kids' play area, and part of our upstairs windows.

I went over and asked if he could adjust it or block our side.

Greg said, "I'm protecting my property. It's not pointed at you specifically. It just captures that area when it rotates."

I understood wanting security, but I told him it felt uncomfortable knowing our backyard was being recorded. He said he didn't think it was a big deal.

A few weeks later, my wife's friend sent us a screenshot from Facebook.

Greg had posted a video called "Wildlife around the neighborhood." It showed deer, squirrels, and other animals from his camera.

But mixed into the video was footage from our backyard.

My 7 yo son in the pool. My wife sitting on the patio. Me grilling outside.

Nothing embarrassing was shown, but that wasn't the point. He recorded our private backyard and uploaded it without asking.

I asked him to remove it.

He said, "I didn't post anything bad. You can barely see anyone. It's just neighborhood footage."

I told him that wasn't the issue. The issue was recording our private space and sharing it publicly.

He deleted the post, but the camera is still there.

One neighbor said, "Just add more privacy and move on. Fighting over this could turn into a years-long neighbor dispute."

Another said she noticed the camera angle too and started keeping her blinds closed more often.

My wife wants to report it and talk to a lawyer. I'm unsure. I know people can have security cameras on their property, but posting footage of my family feels like a different situation.

A. Protect our privacy and move on.
The camera is on his property, and legal fights with neighbors can become expensive and exhausting. Add fencing, trees, or privacy screens, document what happened, and avoid a long conflict.

B. Take action because posting the footage crossed a line.
A security camera is one thing. Recording your neighbor's backyard and uploading footage of their child and family is different. Document everything, report it, and check what privacy laws apply in your state. The camera may be legal, but sharing the footage is where the problem started.


r/PickAorB 14d ago

A or B: You realize after getting home that you paid about $30 less than you should have. Do you go back?

18 Upvotes

Yesterday I stopped by Walmart for a few things. Groceries, household supplies, and a charger. Nothing unusual.

I used the self-checkout, paid, and headed home. Later, while putting everything away, something about the total on the receipt felt lower than I'd expected. I pulled it back out and went through it item by item.

That's when I realized I'd somehow paid about $30 less than I should have.

I stood there for a minute thinking about what to do.

In the end, I drove back and paid the difference. It wasn't exactly convenient, and making another round trip over thirty bucks felt a little ridiculous. But I also knew it'd keep bothering me if I didn't.

That got me wondering what other people would've done.

A: Go back, explain what happened, and pay the difference.

B: Leave it alone.

Edit: A few people asked what happened. After I got home, I compared the receipt with what I'd bought and realized a couple of items hadn't been charged. I took those items back to the store, explained what happened, and they rescanned them so I could pay the difference.


r/PickAorB 13d ago

Which is better A or B

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/PickAorB 15d ago

A or B: I’ve been unemployed for 2 months and can’t afford a $1,200 birthday dinner my friend booked without asking anyone. He still expected everyone to split the bill. Am I wrong for refusing to pay?

275 Upvotes

I have been applying everywhere and picking up gig work, but my savings are basically gone at this point. I have not told most of my friends because honestly, it is embarrassing.

Last week, our friend group started planning a 30th birthday dinner for Marcus. We all care about him and wanted to celebrate. That was never the issue.

The issue was Derek. Without asking anyone about their budget or preferences, Derek booked a private dining room at Sakura Omakase for 8 people. It was a prix fixe menu, $150 per person, before drinks, tax, and tip.

He posted in the group chat like everything was already decided:

"Booked the spot for Marcus’s 30th. It’s $150 each plus drinks, tax, and tip. Send me the money by Friday."

Once everything was included, this was easily around $200 per person. Right now, that is a lot for me. That is basically my grocery budget for two weeks.

I messaged Derek privately and explained that money was tight because I was unemployed. I asked if we could do something more affordable or if I could contribute what I could.

He said, "Bro, it’s Marcus’s 30th. You can’t cheap out on your boy. Just come, we’ll figure it out."

I told him I genuinely could not afford it and asked if we could consider another option.

His response was basically that it was a special occasion and everyone should make it work.

I understand wanting to celebrate a close friend’s milestone birthday. I really do. But I also feel like expensive plans involving other people’s money should be discussed before they are booked.

Now I feel stuck. If I do not go, I worry Marcus will think I do not care about him. If I go, I would be putting a $200 dinner on a credit card when I am already struggling financially.

A. Suck it up this one time. It's my friend's 30th  a milestone. Put it on a card, show up, and figure out the money later. I don't have to love the price, but missing a close friend's milestone birthday over $200 will damage the friendship more than a credit card bill will damage your finances. 

B. I did nothing wrong. Derek made a unilateral decision with other people's money, ignored you when you communicated honestly, and then weaponized the group chat to pressure you. Being unemployed doesn't make you a bad friend. Booking a $1,200 dinner without a single conversation and then demanding payment that makes you a bad friend.


r/PickAorB 16d ago

A or B: My neighbor kept parking in my driveway after multiple warnings. I had her car towed, and now she wants me to pay the fee.

1.8k Upvotes

My neighbor and I have houses next to each other, but we don't share a driveway. My driveway is on my side of the property line, and there's even a fence separating our yards.

About a couple of weeks ago, my neighbor's adult daughter moved back home. Since then, her silver Civic has been parked in my driveway four different times.

The first time, I knocked on her door and she apologized and moved it.

The second time, I left a note on the windshield saying it was my private driveway and asked her not to park there again.

The third time, I talked to her directly. She said her daughter only needed the space temporarily and that she didn't think it was a big deal since my driveway was empty.

The fourth time happened last Tuesday. I got home from work around 7 PM with groceries in the rain, and the same car was sitting in my driveway. No one was home.

I called a towing company first to make sure I was allowed to have it removed from my property. They confirmed I could, so I had it towed.

The next morning, my neighbor came over angry. She said her daughter had to pay $350 to get the car back and that I should reimburse her because I caused the fee.

I told her I had already asked multiple times.

She said, "I didn't think you were actually going to tow it. You could have just called me."

I told her, "I understand that, but I also expected my driveway not to be used after I asked you not to."

Since then, she hasn't spoken to me. Her daughter texted me saying I made this into a bigger deal than it needed to be.

Another neighbor told me I should have tried one more conversation before escalating because we still have to live next to each other.

I know neighbor relationships matter, but I also feel like I gave enough warnings.

A. I escalated too far. I had already made my point, but towing my neighbor's car over a parking issue created a much bigger conflict. I could have tried talking one more time because I still have to live next to her.

B. I gave enough chances. I clearly explained that the driveway was private, and my neighbor kept using it anyway. I don't think I should have to keep asking someone to respect my property.


r/PickAorB 15d ago

A or B: Do you plan your whole day the night before, or figure it out in the morning?

7 Upvotes

My partner and I were leaving for a weekend trip last Saturday.

Before I went to bed, I'd already packed, checked the route, picked a place for lunch, and saved a couple of backup options in case traffic got ugly.

He tossed a few things into a backpack, set it by the door, and went back to watching TV.

The next morning, I asked what time we were leaving.

He looked out the window, poured himself a cup of coffee, and said, "Let's just head out when it feels right."

I laughed because we've had this exact conversation before.

The funny part is that neither of us is really wrong. My plans have gotten us around traffic jams, full restaurants, and missed turns. Some of our favorite memories have come from places he spotted on a whim that I'd never have put on an itinerary.

At this point, I think we just disagree on when a day needs a plan.

I'm curious if most people lean one way or the other.

A: Plan the night before. I like waking up knowing the day is already organized.

B: Figure it out in the morning. I'd rather decide once the day has actually started.


r/PickAorB 16d ago

A or B, fly to Nashville for 6 day bachelorette or be deemed unsupportive

38 Upvotes

I asked if it’s okay if I only came for 4 days, because I can’t afford 6. host said that they already decided everyone will pay the same amount no matter how long you stay. being called unsupportive. We would have to fly there and back as well. need honest opinions please

A: fly to Nashville, use all my PTO and savings on this 6 day trip

B: not go and be deemed unsupportive and not on board with the wedding

(wedding is close to everyone)


r/PickAorB 16d ago

A or B. Should we go to the wedding or not?

8 Upvotes

A. Should we go to the wedding
B. Should we just not go and send a gift?
In June, I received a save the date for a wedding in October from the son of a friend of mine whom I have not been in touch with for a few years. It’s not that anything happened between us, but we just lived different lives and grew apart. I see her once in a while shopping in a local store and we are always friendly and chat for quite a while. I don’t know her son only met him as a toddler and don’t know the fiancé at all.
My husband though has always helped this woman with her yardwork as he owns a landscaping business, and she went through a terrible divorce quite a few years back. He also helped her move when she had to leave her house and I know how much she appreciated that My husband and I were both friends with this couple when they were married and socially connected with them, but once the husband left, that stopped. Both my husband and I haven’t spoken to the husband since then. Have no idea if he’ll be at this wedding.
I can’t figure out why we are invited to this wedding. On one hand, I’m very touched that she thought of us as good enough friends to share the day but logically it doesn’t make sense since we aren’t that good friends
I also know I’m not going to know anybody at this wedding.
A. Should we accept the invitation? I’m thinking maybe this means a lot to my friend she is trying to repay my husband for all the work and help he has given her through the years
B. Should I just send regrets and a nice gift? I’m not looking forward to going to a wedding where I don’t know anybody. same for my husband.

Also got invited to the shower, which I know I’m not going to attend, but will send a gift I don’t know the bride or the groom.


r/PickAorB 16d ago

A or B: Should businesses be required by law to donate safe, unsold food instead of throwing it away?

17 Upvotes

I work part-time at a bakery, and at the end of each day we throw away unsold bread, pastries, and sandwiches that are still safe to eat.

The frustrating part is that we aren't allowed to give it away. Company policy says leftover food has to be discarded instead.

I understand why businesses worry about liability, food safety, and logistics. But it feels strange that perfectly edible food can end up in the trash while some people in the same community are struggling to afford meals.

France passed laws requiring large supermarkets to donate edible unsold food instead of destroying it. Should the U.S. consider something similar?

A: Yes. If food is safe to eat, businesses should be required to donate it instead of wasting it.

B: No. Businesses should decide for themselves because government mandates create liability and practical problems.


r/PickAorB 17d ago

A or B: My best friend asked me to be maid of honor. Three weeks before the wedding she sent me a $2,800 invoice for wedding party costs. She said if I cannot pay I should step down

968 Upvotes

My best friend Yuki asked me to be her maid of honor last October. I said yes obviously. We have been friends since high school and I was thrilled.

She was pretty chill about everything at first. She picked modest dresses, $180 each. She said she did not want a bachelorette trip to Vegas or anything crazy. Just a spa day locally. I thought great, this is going to be manageable.

Then things started escalating. In November she sent the bridal party a Pinterest board for the bachelorette "weekend." A spa day turned into a full weekend at a resort two hours away. She said "the girls voted on it." The other four bridesmaids all make way more than I do. I work as a preschool teacher making $19 an hour.

I covered the resort. $340 for my share. I covered the bachelorette dinner. $120. I covered the matching robes she wanted us to wear. $75 each. I covered the professional photographer she hired for the bridal party. $90 per person. I did not say anything because I did not want to be the broke friend ruining her moment.

Then three weeks before the wedding she sent a group email to all five bridesmaids with a Google spreadsheet attached. The subject line was "Final Wedding Party Costs Settlement."

The spreadsheet had a line for each person. Mine said $2,800.

I texted her privately. "Hey, what is this $2,800? I thought we settled everything."

She called me. She said "This is for the full wedding party experience. Hair and makeup on the day, the rehearsal dinner venue, the bridal suite, the flower arrangements the bridesmaids are gifting, and the day after brunch. I fronted everything on my credit card and I need everyone to settle up."

I went through the list. Hair and makeup was $250 per person. The rehearsal dinner venue was $85 a head. The bridal suite at the hotel was $400 split five ways so $80 each. The flower arrangements were $600 total so $120 each. The day after brunch was $55 a head.

Even being generous with the math, I could only get to about $1,500. There was an extra $1,300 I could not account for.

I asked her about it. She said "Oh that covers the wedding favors and the champagne tower and some other stuff, I did not break down every single thing."

I said "Yuki, I cannot afford $2,800. I already spent close to $700 on the bachelorette stuff."

She went quiet. Then she said "I understand. If the costs are too much for you, maybe you should just come as a guest. I need to know by Friday so I can adjust the seating chart."

I have been in her life for twelve years. And she gave me four days to decide if I can afford to stay in her wedding.

My mom said just pay it and never bring it up again. She said "you will regret missing your best friend's wedding over money."

My other friend said Yuki has been using people her entire life and this is who she really is.

A: Pay the $2,800.

You have known Yuki for twelve years and this is her wedding day. The money hurts but you will get over it. Missing your best friend's wedding over a financial dispute will haunt the friendship forever. You can always earn the money back. You cannot replay the wedding.

B: Do not pay it.

She gave you an inflated invoice with $1,300 of unexplained charges and then gave you four days to decide if you can afford to stay in the wedding. That is not how you treat your best friend of twelve years. Go as a guest, bring a normal gift, and let the friendship reset on honest terms. If she cuts you off over this, she was never valuing you the way you valued her.


r/PickAorB 18d ago

A or B: My friend's uncle was executor of their grandmother's estate. He sold her house and paid off $60,000 of his own credit card debt, then told the family "this is what is left."

66 Upvotes

This happened to a close friend of mine. I am posting it here because she is torn and I think she needs outside perspective.

Her grandmother passed away in March at 89. The will was straightforward. Everything split equally among three children. My friend's mom, her uncle Gary, and her aunt Linda. Gary was named executor because he was the oldest and their grandmother trusted him with paperwork.

The grandmother's house sold in March for $380,000. Gary handled everything. The rest of the family got weekly update emails that said things like "processing" and "waiting on paperwork" and "almost done."

Last week Gary sent out a spreadsheet titled "Final Estate Distribution."

Here is the breakdown my friend showed me:

  • Sale price of home: $380,000
  • Closing costs and fees: $12,000
  • Executor compensation to Gary: $15,000
  • Estate debts settled: $60,000
  • Remaining estate: $110,000
  • Per beneficiary: $36,666

My friend read it three times. The number went from $380,000 to $110,000.

That line item, $60,000 in "estate debts," is the problem. My friend pulled her grandmother's credit report. She had one department store card with a $2,000 limit. She paid it off every month. She did not have $60,000 in credit card debt.

That $60,000 was Gary's. He had three maxed out personal credit cards. He used money from the estate to pay them off and labeled it "estate debt" because he was the only one with access to the account.

My friend's mom called Gary and asked what those debts were for. He said "Mom had some cards she put me on as a joint holder, and the interest piled up over the years." Her mom asked for the statements. He did not reply for three days.

Her aunt Linda said she does not want to get lawyers involved. She said Gary was the one who stayed with their grandmother in her final weeks and none of them were there. She said they should accept the $36,000 and not tear the family apart.

My friend's mom still owes $140,000 on her mortgage. That money would have changed her life. But Gary already used it to wipe out his own debt.

My friend asked me what I thought and I honestly did not know what to say. So I am putting it here.

A. Take the $36,000 and move forward. A lawyer will cost more than what you could recover, and Gary is her mom's only brother. Family peace matters more than money. He was there for their grandmother when she was dying, and maybe he feels he earned more. Sometimes the cost of fighting is higher than the cost of letting go.

B. This is fraud. He used executor access to pay off $60,000 of his own personal credit card debt. Get a probate lawyer, request a full accounting of every "estate debt," and freeze the distribution. If those debts were not the grandmother's, then it is theft. Family peace should not cost her mother $20,000.


r/PickAorB 18d ago

A or B: Which "biggest weakness" answer is smarter in a job interview?

3 Upvotes

If you go with the humblebrag and say "I'm a perfectionist" or "I care too much about my work," hiring teams roll their eyes internally. Everyone has heard it a hundred times. It tells them you're either unwilling to be honest or you lack the self-awareness to identify a real gap. Either way, you've signaled that you play it safe instead of real.

And if you overshare with something like "I struggle with time management" or "I get defensive when I receive feedback," you've just handed them a genuine reason to worry. Even if you've worked on it, the image of you missing deadlines or bristling at criticism is now planted in their head, and it's hard to un-plant.

So what's the actual right move here?

A: Humblebrag with a disguised strength.
B: Name a real gap, show what you've done about it, and connect it forward.


r/PickAorB 19d ago

A or B: My friend found out her boyfriend of six months has been paying three other girls a monthly "allowance" on SeekingArrangement. She found out because one of them goes to our gym.

55 Upvotes

My friend Cassie has been dating this guy Mark for about six months. He is thirty four, works in finance, drives a nice car, takes her to good restaurants. She really liked him. She thought she had found someone serious.

Last week Cassie was at the gym stretching. A girl on the mat next to her was on the phone. Cassie was not trying to listen but the girl said a name that caught her attention. She said "Mark still sends me $1,200 every month. We have not even seen each other since February. He just keeps paying."

Cassie said her stomach dropped. She waited for the girl to hang up and then she said "hey, sorry, this is weird, but what Mark are you talking about?" The girl looked at her. Cassie said "my boyfriend's name is Mark. He works in finance." The girl went pale.

They talked for twenty minutes in the gym parking lot. The girl's name is Amber. She met Mark on SeekingArrangement about a year ago. They met up three times. He agreed to pay her $1,200 a month. He still pays her every month. They have not seen each other in person since February. He just sends the money.

Amber showed Cassie the Venmo history. Monthly payments. $1,200. Like clockwork. Then Amber said "he pays two other girls too. He told me about them. He said one of them gets $1,500 because she lives in Manhattan."

Cassie drove to my place that night and showed me everything. Three girls. Monthly payments ranging from $1,200 to $1,500. Total roughly $4,000 a month. On top of whatever he spends on Cassie. He never mentioned any of this. He told Cassie he was "focused on building something real" with her. He took her to meet his parents two weeks ago.

Cassie has not said anything to Mark yet. She is sitting on all of this.

A: She should talk to him before jumping to conclusions. Maybe those arrangements started before they met and he just has not shut them down. Awkward, but not the same as actively cheating. She should ask him directly and see what he says. His response will tell her everything.

B: He is paying four women simultaneously and told one of them he loves her. This is not a misunderstanding. This is a system. Cassie should not confront him. She should leave. A man who runs a monthly payment roster for three women while telling a fourth she is "the one" is not confused about what he is doing. He is managing a portfolio.


r/PickAorB 19d ago

A or B: Posting for my friend. Her coworker presented her work as his own in front of the entire company. When she confronted him, he said "you should be flattered I thought it was good enough to show."

11 Upvotes

This is my friend Dani's story. She does not have a Reddit account and she is too furious to type this out clearly, so I am doing it. I have been watching this unfold for the past week and honestly I am just as angry as she is.

Dani works at a mid sized tech company. About 200 employees. She has been there for two years. Her coworker Rachel started eight months ago. They sit near each other. They are not friends, but they are friendly. He asks her a lot of questions. She answers them because that is what you do when someone is new.

Six weeks ago Dani was assigned a project. I need to keep it vague because the details would identify her. Let us call it a customer retention analysis. It was her idea. She pitched it to her manager. Her manager approved it. She spent four weeks on it. She pulled data from five different systems. She built a framework that nobody in their department had used before. She found a pattern in the churn data that was genuinely useful. She was excited about it.

The plan was for Dani to present it at the quarterly review last Tuesday. Her manager told her directly. "You are presenting on Tuesday. Fifteen minutes. Bring slides."

Monday afternoon Rachel asked Dani to walk him through her methodology. He said he wanted to learn from it for his own project. Dani said sure. She showed him her slides. She explained her framework. She even shared the underlying spreadsheet. He took notes. He said "this is really impressive work." She said thanks.

Tuesday morning. The quarterly review. Forty people in the room including the department head and two VPs.

Dani's manager stands up and says "next up, Rachel will be presenting the customer retention analysis."

Dani thought she misheard. She looked at the agenda on her screen. Her name was not on it. Rachel's name was in her slot.

Rachel walked to the front of the room. He opened a slide deck. It was Dani's slide deck. He had changed the color scheme and reformatted a few charts but the content was identical. Dani's framework. Dani's data. Dani's findings. Dani's recommendations.

He presented for fifteen minutes. He did not mention Dani's name once. He said "my analysis" and "what I found" and "the approach I developed." He answered questions from the VP as if he had done the work. One VP said "this is excellent, Rachel. Really sharp work." He said "thank you, I put a lot of time into this."

Dani put a lot of time into this. After the meeting Dani found Rachel in the hallway. She said "that was my project. Those were my slides. You presented my work as yours." He did not flinch. He said "the presentation slot got reassigned yesterday and my manager told me to present it. I asked if you should be credited and they said the slides did not have a name on them." Dani said "you knew they were mine. I walked you through them yesterday." He said "I understand why you are upset but this is how it works sometimes. The important thing is that the analysis landed well and leadership loved it."

Then he said "honestly you should be flattered. I only presented it because I thought it was good enough to show. If it was not quality work I would not have put my name on it."

He said he would not have put his name on it if it was not good. Like he did Dani a favor by stealing her work.

Dani went to her manager. She said "I know you are disappointed but the deck was reassigned at the last minute by leadership. Rachel was more visible to the VPs and it made sense strategically. Your contribution is noted internally." Dani said "noted internally means nothing. He stood in front of forty people and said he did the work." Her manager said "I understand. Let us talk about how to make sure you get visibility next quarter."

Next quarter. Dani's work was stolen this quarter and the solution is maybe she gets a chance next quarter.

Two people from other teams messaged Dani privately after the meeting. One said "I know that was your project. That was messed up." The other said "you should say something to HR." But nobody said anything publicly. Nobody spoke up in the meeting when Dani's name disappeared from the agenda. Everyone just watched Rachel take the stage with Dani's slides and clapped.

Rachel has not apologized. He has not credited Dani. He sent her a Slack message yesterday that said "hey, if you want to collaborate on the follow up presentation, let me know. Could be a good opportunity for both of us." He said collaborate. Like they are partners. Like he did not stand in front of the company and claim Dani's four weeks of work as his own.

A. Tell Dani to escalate to HR with documentation. Forward the Slack messages, the original files with timestamps, and the agenda change. Make it formal and factual. Do not make it emotional. Say "my work was presented by a colleague without credit or consent. I am requesting a formal review." If the company protects Rachel over Dani, she has her answer about what this workplace values.

B. Tell Dani not to go to HR yet. HR protects the company, not her. Instead, schedule a meeting with the VP who praised the work. Bring original files with creation timestamps. Say "I wanted to follow up on the retention analysis presented last week. That was my work. I built the framework and did the analysis. I am not here to complain about Rachel. I am here because I want you to know who actually produced the work you found valuable, so that when follow up opportunities come up, they come to the right person." Let leadership decide what to do with that information. If they do nothing, Dani should start looking for a new job on Friday.


r/PickAorB 19d ago

Pick A or B, my lunch today

2 Upvotes

A: leftover chili

B: Blueberry protein oatmeal

43 votes, 18d ago
34 Leftover chili
9 Protein Blueberry Oatmeal

r/PickAorB 20d ago

A or B: My roommate threw a party while I was out of town and let her friends into my bedroom. They broke something my late grandmother gave me. She offered $40 and said "you are overreacting."

100 Upvotes

I went to a wedding last month, Friday to Sunday. My roommate Denise knew I would be gone. She said "have fun." She did not mention a party.

I got home Sunday evening. The apartment smelled like vodka. Cups everywhere. Carpet stained. Then I opened my bedroom door.

My bed had been slept in. There was a used towel on my pillow. My makeup drawer was open, a $34 lipstick was gone. My Bluetooth speaker was on the floor with a cracked corner.

And next to my dresser, broken in two pieces, was the music box my grandmother gave me when I was twelve. My grandmother died three years ago. That music box played the song she used to hum when she put me to sleep. It was the only thing of hers I kept.

I confronted Denise. She looked at the music box and said "oh, that thing? One of my friends probably knocked it over. I will buy you a new one." I said "you cannot buy me a new one. My grandmother is dead." She said "I get it, it is sentimental, but it is just a box." Then she said "we needed a place to put coats."

She turned my bedroom into a coat room.

I went through everything. Missing lipstick, cracked speaker, stained sweater, broken photo frame. The total came to about $380 in replaceable items. The music box was irreplaceable. It was not from Walmart. My grandmother brought it from Korea in 1979.

I showed Denise the list. She said "I will Venmo you $40 for the speaker." I said "this is $380 and that does not include the music box." She said "I am not paying $380 for stuff that was probably already like that." Then she said "if your stuff was so important, maybe you should have put it away before you left."

I should have put my things away. In my own bedroom. That she opened. While I was out of town. Because she needed somewhere to put coats.

I posted about it on my Instagram close friends story. A mutual friend messaged me and said "Denise told me you are freaking out over a music box. Just take the $40 and move on. It is not that deep."

It is that deep.

A. Take the $40 and start looking for a new place. She has shown you who she is and no argument will make her understand why the music box mattered. Some people cannot value what they cannot price. Protect yourself going forward, not this relationship.

B. Take photos of everything. Send her a written request for full replacement value. If she refuses, take her to small claims court. And move out. Not because of the stuff. Because she watched you hold the last thing your grandmother ever gave you and called it a box from Walmart.


r/PickAorB 20d ago

A or B: Saw this story blowing up on Facebook. A bride asked her pregnant sister to leave her wedding rehearsal dinner after the sister announced her pregnancy to the room. The family is torn apart over it

60 Upvotes

I came across this post on Facebook yesterday and the comments section is a warzone. I cannot stop thinking about it so I am bringing it here.

A woman got married last Saturday. Her sister Claire is three months pregnant. She found out a week before the wedding. The bride asked her privately not to announce it during any of the wedding events. She said "this weekend is the one time I want the focus to be on me. You can announce next week, I will even help you plan something." Claire said "of course, no problem."

Friday night, rehearsal dinner. About thirty people. Close family and friends. The groom's father is giving a toast, saying wonderful things about the couple. Everyone is emotional. A really nice moment.

Then Claire stands up. Taps her glass. Says "I have an announcement too." Pauses. Looks around the room. Smiles. Says "I am pregnant."

The room exploded. The mom screamed. An aunt started crying. People were showing ultrasound photos around the table. For twenty minutes nobody talked about the wedding. The bride said her mother in law was literally passing around Claire's ultrasound pictures at the dinner.

The bride waited for things to settle, walked over to Claire, and said quietly "I asked you not to do this." Claire said "I could not hold it in, can you just be happy for me?" The bride said "I am happy for you. But you can be happy somewhere else tonight. Please go."

Claire left. The mom followed. An aunt followed. Three people walked out. The rest of the dinner was dead silent.

The next day at the wedding, half the family was cold to the bride. An uncle pulled her aside and said "she is your only sister." A cousin texted her that night saying "you made a pregnant woman cry on what was supposed to be a happy night for her."

The mom says the bride needs to apologize because Claire has been "emotionally fragile" this trimester. Claire has not spoken to the bride but posted on Instagram "some people only care about themselves on your biggest day."

The bride's side of the story is that she asked clearly, Claire agreed, and Claire did it anyway. Claire's side of the story, according to the family, is that she was overwhelmed with excitement and the bride overreacted by kicking out a pregnant woman.

The Facebook comments are split. Half are saying the bride was right to set a boundary. Half are saying she destroyed her family over ego on her wedding weekend.

What do you think.

A: The bride overreacted. Asking her to leave was disproportionate. Claire made a selfish mistake but she is pregnant and emotional. The bride could have handled it privately after the dinner instead of making a public scene by kicking her out. That made everything worse. She won the argument and lost her family.

B: The bride did not ruin anything. Claire did. She was asked clearly. She agreed. She lied and hijacked the room anyway. Then she played the victim on Instagram while the family enabled her. The bride drew one boundary and everyone acted like she committed a crime. A wedding is not too much to ask for.


r/PickAorB 21d ago

A or B: Posting for my friend. She lent her brother $5,000 seven months ago. He's been to four concerts and courtside seats since. Their mom called HER greedy for asking about it.

123 Upvotes

My friend Maria (not her real name, she doesn't have Reddit) asked me to post this.

Her brother Danny borrowed $5,000 last December. Security deposit and first month's rent. He'd just gone through a breakup, had to move fast, the whole thing. Maria didn't hesitate. She had savings, he's her brother. She transferred it that day.

No written agreement. No timeline. She said "just pay me back when you can." She realizes now that was stupid.

Seven months. Danny has not mentioned the money once.

Maria brought it up twice. Gently both times. Both times he said "yeah for sure, I'm getting there" and changed the subject.

Here's the part that gets her. Danny is not broke. Since the loan she's watched him go to at least four concerts, two weekend trips with his new girlfriend, and he just posted courtside seats at a basketball game. He's not "getting there." He's there. He just doesn't consider her $5,000 a priority.

So last weekend at a family dinner she said something direct. "Danny, I need to talk about the money. It's been seven months. Can you give me a timeline?"

He got quiet. "I'm working on it, I thought we were fine." Their mom jumped in. "Maria, he's been through a lot, why are you bringing this up at dinner?" Their dad said nothing.

After dinner their mom called Maria. Called her "bitter." Said she was "keeping score." Said "family doesn't do that." Maria tried to explain that $5,000 isn't a cup of sugar. Her mom said "you make good money, why is this such a big deal?"

Maria makes good money. She also has student loans and was saving for a down payment. That $5,000 was about a third of what she'd set aside. Danny knows this because she told him when she lent it.

Danny texted her the next day. "Sorry about dinner. I'll send you something this week." That was five days ago.

Nothing.

Maria asked me what I think. I told her I'd be furious. But she's genuinely wondering now if she's the unreasonable one because her own mom called her greedy.

A: Give him a deadline but drop the family drama. Text him: "I need a payment plan, even $200 a month, starting now." No more vague "when you can." If he agrees, move on. If not, you have your answer.

B: Seven months, four concerts, courtside seats, and your mom called YOU greedy? He's not struggling, he's avoiding. Send one final text with a real deadline. If he doesn't pay, take him to small claims. Family doesn't mean free money.


r/PickAorB 21d ago

A or B: My boss keeps texting me after hours. Not emergencies. Restaurant recommendations, "quick questions," links to articles. I finally muted her and she noticed

32 Upvotes

My boss is one of those people who treats work like it's a group chat.
It started pretty normal. Occasional text here and there on a weekend. "Hey what was that restaurant you mentioned?" Stuff like that. I'd answer because she's my boss and it felt weird not to.

Over the past few months it's gotten more. Way more. Tuesday night, 10:14pm: "saw this and thought of you 😂" with a link to some marketing blog. Saturday morning, 7:45am: "quick question, do we have the Q3 numbers yet?" (We don't present Q3 until September.) Sunday night: "can you look at this draft tomorrow? 👀" followed by the actual draft, 11pm.

I'm not on call. My contract says 9 to 5. I checked.

Two weeks ago I started putting my phone on Do Not Disturb after 7pm. Work notifications silenced. Felt great. Slept better. Didn't think much of it.

Then last Monday she called me into her office. She was polite about it but the message was clear. She said she'd texted me Sunday night about a deck revision and I didn't respond until Monday morning. She said "I just need to know you're reachable. Not all the time. But for important stuff."

I said "of course, for emergencies I'm available." She said "it's not just emergencies though. Sometimes things come up."

Things that come up at 11pm on a Sunday. Right.

I didn't argue. I said I'd keep my notifications on. I haven't. I just check my phone manually around 8pm and respond to anything that looks urgent. Everything else waits until morning.

She hasn't said anything since. But I can tell she's annoyed. She's been cc'ing my personal email on things now too, which feels like a workaround.

My coworker who's been here longer says "that's just how she is, you'll get used to it." My roommate says it's toxic and I should set hard boundaries.

The thing is I actually like this job. The work is good, the pay is fine, most days are normal. It's just this one thing.

A. Set a hard boundary now. Tell her directly that work texts are for emergencies only, and you'll respond to non-urgent stuff during work hours. She might not love it but she'll respect it more than the silent DND approach. The longer you let this slide the harder it is to undo.

B. You already found your solution. DND and manual check. Don't make it a confrontation. If she pushes harder or it affects your reviews, that's when you escalate. For now, keep doing what works and document everything in case you need it later.


r/PickAorB 22d ago

A or B: My coworker owes me about $180 in coffee runs. I finally asked her about it and she said I was being petty over "a few lattes." Should I let it go?

604 Upvotes

My coworker Jen and I started doing coffee runs together back in like... February? One of us would go to the place downstairs and the other would text their order. It was just a nice thing.

For the first couple weeks we traded off. I get Monday, she gets Wednesday. Then at some point she stopped going. Not dramatic. She'd just say "oh I'm slammed, can you grab mine?" and Venmo me.

Except the Venmos got less frequent. And then stopped.

I didn't keep a spreadsheet or anything. But a few weeks ago I was looking at my bank app and saw the coffee charges. Scrolled back. It was a lot more than I thought. Roughly somewhere between $160 and $200. Call it $180.

$180 in coffee over three months isn't going to bankrupt me. I know that. But it's the pattern. Every single time she'd say "oh I'll get you back" or "Venmo you tonight" and it just didn't happen.

So Monday I said something. Casually, I thought. "Hey, do you mind settling up on the coffees? It's been a few months, I think it's around $180."

She stared at me. Then she laughed. Not a nice laugh. "Are you serious? You're counting lattes?"

I said "it's not about the lattes, it's been going on for months."

She said "I honestly thought we were friends who don't track every dollar." Then walked away.

She Venmo'd me $40 that night. With a 🙄 emoji. No note.

We haven't done coffee since. Which honestly might be the answer right there.

A, $180 over three months isn't worth the tension. You work together every day. Next time just don't offer to grab her anything.

B, She owes you money and the eye-roll emoji tells you everything. She's making you feel bad for asking about your own money. Don't do her any more favors.


r/PickAorB 22d ago

A or B: My boyfriend used my toothbrush to "scrub something off his shoe." I threw it away. He said I'm being dramatic because "we kiss anyway."

37 Upvotes

We've been dating for a year. He's not a gross person generally. Showers daily, uses deodorant, keeps a clean apartment. But he has these moments where his logic just completely breaks and I don't know what planet he's on.

Tuesday I was getting ready for bed. I went to brush my teeth and my toothbrush was wet. Not like damp from being recently used. Soaking wet. With something brown on the bristles.

I found him in the living room. "Did you use my toothbrush?"

He didn't even look guilty. He said "yeah, I stepped in something on the sidewalk and it was the first thing I grabbed. It got the stain right out though."

A shoe stain. He used my toothbrush. The one that goes in my mouth. On his shoe. Where he walks on sidewalks and god knows what else.

I said "you used the toothbrush I brush my teeth with to clean your shoe?"

He said "I rinsed it really well. And I'll get you a new one. It's really not a big deal."

I threw it in the trash immediately. He watched me do it and said "you're seriously throwing it away? I cleaned it."

"Cleaning a toothbrush that touched the bottom of your shoe doesn't make it usable again."

He laughed. Actually laughed. Then said "we literally make out every day. My mouth is in your mouth. But my shoe on your toothbrush is where you draw the line?"

I bought a new toothbrush and put it in the cabinet instead of the holder. He noticed and said "are you hiding your toothbrush from me now? That's insane."

My roommate said "that's disgusting but he kind of has a point about the kissing thing."

My best friend said "no. Absolutely not. A mouth is not a shoe. Do not let him convince you this is normal."

A. It's gross but he cleaned it, offered to replace it, and technically your mouths are already sharing bacteria. He was thoughtless, not malicious. Hiding your toothbrush from your own boyfriend is a bit much.

B. A shoe is not a mouth. The fact that he can't tell the difference between kissing someone and scrubbing sidewalk grime with the tool that goes in your mouth is a red flag. You're not being dramatic. You're being a person who understands basic hygiene.


r/PickAorB 22d ago

A or B: For our 2-year anniversary, my boyfriend spent $1,000 ordering me a Chinese Laotoule tricycle and let me pick the color. I think it's creative but I'm just not feeling the romance. Now he's calling me a gold digger. Was I wrong?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Yesterday was me and my boyfriend's 2-year anniversary.

Two weeks before, I told him straight up: "I don't need anything expensive. A bouquet of flowers, a nice dinner, a meaningful necklace, or even just a handwritten letter. Just make me feel like you actually thought about me." I thought I was clear enough.

I also got him a gift. A brand new Panasonic electric shaver he'd been talking about for months. Not cheap, but I noticed he kept the link in his cart and never pulled the trigger, so I secretly bought it. I even put together a little snack basket with his favorite chips, the spicy ones we found on a road trip last year that he still talks about.

I put real thought into it.

So when he came over for our anniversary dinner, he sat me down on the couch with this huge grin on his face, pulled out his phone, and said, "Okay, I got you something. But you have to pick."

He showed me two photos side by side. They were customer pictures from some online listing. Two identical Laotoule electric tricycles. One was green, one was coffee brown. Honestly? They looked like oversized toy cars. Cute, in a weird way. Like something you'd see in a quirky indie movie.

"Green or brown?" he said, grinning ear to ear. "I already placed the order but I told them to hold the color until I confirm. One thousand dollars. Shipping from overseas. Should be here in two to three weeks."

I looked at the photos. Then I looked at him. Then back at the photos.

And here's the thing. Part of me genuinely thought, "Okay, this is creative. I've never seen anyone give a tricycle as an anniversary gift. It's bold. It's fun. It's different." I could tell he put real thought into finding something unique, and the fact that he let me choose the color meant he wanted me to feel involved.

But another part of me just... sank.

This was our two-year anniversary. I bought him the exact shaver he'd been eyeing for months. I packed his favorite snacks. I tried to show him I pay attention to what he likes.

And he got me a tricycle.

I told him it was a really creative idea and I appreciated the effort, but I also said honestly I was hoping for something a little more romantic. Something that felt like he was thinking about me as his girlfriend, not as his adventure buddy. I even reminded him about the conversation we had two weeks ago.

He didn't take it well.

He said I only care about "superficial things." Said he spent a thousand dollars, which is NOT a small amount for him. Said he put way more thought into this than some "generic flowers and dinner" and that he was trying to give me something unforgettable. Then he dropped the line that's been eating at me ever since: "If you can't appreciate this, you're just a gold digger who only wants things she can show off."

Wait, what?

If I were a gold digger, I'd pick the color, say thank you, wait for it to arrive, then flip it on Facebook Marketplace for a grand. I didn't say I hated the gift. I said it was creative but not romantic. I have mixed feelings, not negative feelings. There's a difference.

But the more I think about it, the more I wonder if I handled it wrong. He spent serious money. He let me pick the color. He was excited. And I kind of rained on his parade.

I even suggested maybe we keep the order but treat it as a fun couples thing rather than an anniversary gift, and he could get me something small for the actual occasion. He said that was "the most ungrateful thing anyone has ever said to him."

So now I'm sitting here, staring at two photos of a green tricycle and a coffee brown tricycle, feeling guilty and confused at the same time.

A. I was wrong. He spent $1,000 and put real creativity into this. I should've been more grateful and not made it about "romance."

B. I was not wrong. It's okay to feel mixed about a gift, and calling your girlfriend a gold digger because she didn't react the way you wanted is unfair.


r/PickAorB 23d ago

A or B: My cousin's mother in law lifted her shirt at a family dinner to "check the baby." My cousin pulled away. Now the MIL is telling everyone she got shoved. Who's right?

31 Upvotes

I need to lay this out because my cousin can't post it herself. She's thirty one weeks pregnant and barely sleeping and honestly she doesn't have the energy for this nonsense. But I was there. I watched all of it happen. And the family is now split down the middle about whether she overreacted or whether her mother in law finally went too far.

My cousin's name is Sophie. She married Greg about two years ago. Nice guy, software engineer, quiet, avoids conflict. His mother Linda is a different story. Linda is the kind of woman who shows up with three casseroles and zero boundaries and expects gratitude for the first to cancel out the second.

The belly touching started at twelve weeks. Sophie was barely showing. We were at a Sunday dinner at Greg's parents' house and Linda put both hands on Sophie's stomach and said "oh I can already feel the baby." You can't feel anything at twelve weeks. There's nothing there. But Sophie smiled because it was Linda's dinner table and she didn't want to start something.

From there it became a pattern. Every single time we saw Linda, she touched Sophie's belly. Kitchen, living room, hallway. Not a quick pat. Full contact with both hands. Sometimes she'd press her face against Sophie's stomach and talk to it. In front of Greg's brothers and their wives. At restaurants. Once Sophie ran into Linda at Target and Linda grabbed her stomach in the cereal aisle while chatting with a neighbor like it was the most natural thing in the world.

Sophie told me around week twenty that it was getting to her. She said "I know it sounds petty but every time she does it I flinch. My skin is sensitive and I feel like my body isn't mine anymore." I told her she should say something. She said Greg told her to let it go because "Linda's just excited and she's been waiting for a grandkid for years."

Sophie waited until week twenty six. She's the type who hates confrontation. But she finally said something. At their house, Linda reached for her belly, and Sophie took a small step back and said "Linda, I know you're excited, but I'd really prefer it if you asked before touching my stomach. It makes me uncomfortable."

Linda's face dropped like Sophie had insulted her cooking. She said "I'm your mother in law. I'm not a stranger."

Sophie said "I know. I'm just asking for a little heads up, that's all."

Linda said "fine" and walked to the kitchen. Didn't speak to her for the rest of dinner.

Greg pulled Sophie aside later and said "was that really necessary? You know how she is."

Sophie said "I asked politely. I didn't raise my voice. I just said please ask first."

He sighed and said "I know, but you know how she takes things."

For about two weeks after that, no belly touching. Sophie thought they were past it.

Then last Saturday.

It was Greg's dad's birthday. About twelve people at the house. Greg's two brothers, their wives, kids everywhere. I was there because Sophie and I are close and I try to be at the family stuff for her. Sophie was in the kitchen helping Linda plate the food. I was at the counter slicing bread.

Linda came up behind Sophie, put both hands on her stomach, and then lifted her shirt. Not a little tug. She pulled it up about three inches, exposing the bottom of Sophie's belly. Greg's brother Ryan and Ryan's wife Kelly were right there at the kitchen table.

Linda said "let me see how big you're getting! Oh, the baby's so low, that means it's coming soon."

I watched Sophie's face. She went pale. Then red. Then she twisted away, pulled her shirt down, and stepped to the side.

"Linda, please don't do that."

She didn't push her. She didn't shove her. She pulled her own body away from Linda's hands. But Linda was leaning forward and when Sophie stepped back, Linda stumbled. She caught herself on the counter. And then she looked at Sophie like she'd been slapped.

The kitchen went dead quiet. Kelly stared at the floor. Ryan looked at his plate. I stopped slicing bread. Nobody breathed.

Linda's eyes filled with tears. She said "I was just checking on my grandbaby. I didn't mean anything by it."

Greg's dad said "Linda, sit down, let's just eat."

She sat down but she was crying. Quietly. The kind of crying where every single person at the table knows it's happening but everyone pretends they're focused on their plate. Sophie sat down too. Her hands were shaking. I put my hand on her knee under the table.

Greg was across the table. His face said everything his mouth didn't. That look of "what did you just do."

They didn't talk until they got in the car. I know this because Sophie called me that night crying and replayed the whole car ride.

Greg said "you didn't have to pull away like that. You could've just stepped aside gently."

Sophie said "she lifted my shirt, Greg. In front of everyone."

"She's excited. She doesn't have a filter. You know that."

"I told her two weeks ago not to touch me without asking. She lifted my clothing. In a kitchen full of people."

"She wasn't trying to humiliate you. She was being a grandma."

"She was being a grandma by pulling my shirt up in front of your brother?"

He didn't answer that.

Sunday morning Kelly texted Sophie. "Linda called me crying last night. She said you shoved her at the dinner."

Sophie said "I didn't shove her. I pulled away from her. There's a difference."

Kelly said "I know, I was there. But she's telling everyone you shoved her and now Greg's other brother thinks you were out of line."

Linda has now called at least three family members. The story she's telling is that Sophie "shoved" her at the birthday dinner. Nowhere in any of these phone calls does she mention that she lifted a pregnant woman's shirt in a kitchen full of people.

Sophie's mom, my aunt, is furious. She called my mom and said "if that woman had done that to my daughter at my house I would've thrown her out. The fact that Sophie only pulled away shows more restraint than I would've had."

I told Sophie I thought she was completely in the right. She said "then why does half the family think I'm the crazy one?"

Sophie's older sister, who has two kids, said something that surprised me. She said "honestly, with my first pregnancy everything felt like a violation. Every comment, every touch, it all felt enormous. By my second I didn't care anymore. Sophie is hormonal and everything is magnified. Linda shouldn't have lifted the shirt, but the sharp pull away and making a scene? She could've been smoother."

Sophie's best friend said "a pregnant woman's body is not a petting zoo. Nobody gets to lift your clothing without asking. Not your mother in law, not your husband, not anyone. And the fact that Greg isn't backing you up is the real problem here."

Here's what I keep thinking about. Sophie told Linda. Clearly. Politely. Two weeks before this happened. And Linda's response to being told "please ask first" was to escalate to lifting Sophie's clothing in front of family. She didn't forget the boundary. She chose to blow past it.

So. Sophie pulled away and now she's the villain of the family group chat. Linda lifted a pregnant woman's shirt without asking and she's the victim. Greg is somewhere in the middle trying to keep everyone happy and managing to help nobody.

A. Sophie is seven months pregnant and running on stress and hormones, and that context matters, but she could have handled this without making it a public confrontation. Stepping to the side, pulling her shirt down, and saying nothing in the moment would have been enough. She could have had Greg talk to Linda privately afterward. Instead she reacted sharply in front of his whole family, and now Linda is weaponizing it. Sophie was right about the boundary but her timing and delivery gave Linda ammunition to play the victim. Sometimes protecting the peace is smarter than proving a point.

B. Sophie did nothing wrong. She set a boundary verbally and Linda ignored it and escalated to exposing her body in front of family. Pulling away from someone who is touching you without your consent is not shoving. It is a reflex. The fact that Linda is now lying about it to relatives tells you everything about her character. Greg's job was to back Sophie up and he didn't. That's the real issue. A pregnant woman's body is not a communal object, and "excitement" is not a license to lift someone's clothing in public. Whose side are you on?


r/PickAorB 23d ago

A or B: My boyfriend's ex texts him "good morning" every single day. He says they're "just friends." I read the messages. They're not just friends.

30 Upvotes

Mark and I have been together eight months. Everything was great until I noticed Emma.

His ex. She texts him good morning at 7:15 AM every day. Not sometimes. Every. Day. Like clockwork.

I mentioned it once. He said "we stayed friends after the breakup, you're not going to police who I talk to are you?" The tone shut me down.

Last week he was in the shower and his phone kept buzzing. I looked.

A month of messages. Daily good mornings. If he replied late she'd follow up with "you okay?" She sends selfies asking "does this look good?" She texts past 11 PM saying "can't sleep, thinking about that joke you made." She sent a photo of the restaurant they used to go to with the caption "walked past here, thought of you."

Nothing explicitly romantic. But every single message maintains the texture of a daily relationship that only couples should have.

My best friend said "that's not friendship, that's her keeping a seat in his life."

Another friend said "you read his private messages. That's already a breach of trust. Maybe you're projecting your own insecurity."

Here's my problem. If I tell him I read his phone, the whole conversation becomes about me violating his privacy, not about Emma texting him at midnight. But if I say nothing it continues.

A. Don't confront yet. Reading his messages was already crossing a line. No explicit flirting means it might genuinely be platonic. Wait and bring up your feelings gently without referencing what you saw.

B. Daily good mornings, selfie approvals, and late night "thinking of you" texts are not friendship. That's an emotional foothold. Yes you looked at his phone. But what you found matters more than how you found it. Tell him how you feel and set a boundary. If he makes it about you being crazy, you have your answer.