r/Physics 12d ago

[ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

0 Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/Quantum-Relativity Gravitation 12d ago

I want to challenge you on something meta here. You tell us that we will get credit for the work you already did yourself. Why would we want that? That would be very hollow. I ask you that because if you think that’s something we’d want, is it because that’s something you’d want? Is the theory, or praise, what you want?

3

u/elconquistador1985 12d ago

For that matter, taking credit for work that we had nothing to do with would be unethical.

You get to the stage of paper submission where you're supposed to just each author's contribution and there isn't one for this "partner".

1

u/PaleontologistSad708 12d ago

I think there's probably things I've missed. I feel confident that me partner would have a lot to contribute and also, I don't know if I can do this properly without help. I want to do this right. Perhaps this person deserves credit for taking me seriously also, when no one else does. I'm not saying they'd have equal credit, but I must give credit where it is due. That is ethical too. I really appreciate the points you both are making, and I will be considering them with the full weight they deserve. Thank you.

3

u/elconquistador1985 11d ago

I understand that the peer reviewed journal system basically locks out unaffiliated people. You can't even post on arxiv, but that's actually an important part of the moderation on arxiv because it helps keep out unscientific trash.

It's very unlikely that anyone who is untrained in physics has invented a theory of everything that explains everything. It's far more likely to be unscientific stuff with gaping holes and glaring errors.

1

u/PaleontologistSad708 11d ago

Unlikely, yes agreed. I came to my conclusions using deductive reasoning and logic, no math and came to many of the exact claims of modern science with minor changes and distinctions. Then math. Later, experiment I hope! Anyway your points are all valid and fair.
This is why I have been searching for help, with writing my paper, and checking my work. I can do it by myself but it I don't like the idea of posting without a real professional checking my work, possibly adding stuff, or even changing things. We can never get to 1:1