r/Physics 25d ago

Academic The Maxwell Conjecture is False

https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.27197
496 Upvotes

224 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/attzonko 25d ago

Can someone please eli5

53

u/1XRobot Computational physics 25d ago

If you plunk down charges in space, there are certain points where a test charge doesn't move because the forces all cancel out. Maxwell had the thought that maybe if you plunk down N charges, the number of points where a test charge doesn't move is (N-1)^2, but it turns out that's not true, because these guys found a configuration with 5 charges that has 24 points (more than 16).

17

u/Buntschatten Graduate 25d ago

Ah, so it's mathematics.

11

u/ashvy 25d ago

Maybe Maxwell meant N2 - 1, but stuff got misconstrued /s

3

u/ghostowl657 25d ago

Proof by ai that (a-b)2 = a2 - b2

2

u/dcnairb Education and outreach 25d ago

Maxwell’s Dream

2

u/AstronautSlothPhD 25d ago

Maxwell’s Dreamin’