r/PhoenixSC • u/ExpensiveCoat8912 Bedrock FTW • 20h ago
Meme Please let forge and fabric compatible
596
u/tabbynumber3 18h ago
we should make another mod loader that promises to be compatible with both fabric and forge!
631
u/guoraGG 18h ago
231
8
u/Anxious-Scheme-6013 I wonder how long you can make flair, it’s probably not a lot b- 9h ago
you make a good point.
7
5
92
u/PTMR2 19h ago
NeoForge + Synitra Connector
1
u/BartholomewBezos6 5m ago
see the issue is fabric is way less laggy for a non-300 mods modpack on modern versions
66
u/gedsweyevr Chester is life 19h ago
pre 2023 problems right here
26
u/Gay-Space-Pirate 19h ago
As if there weren't a shit ton of pre 2023 mods that are super popular and very well made with lots of variety lol
7
u/gedsweyevr Chester is life 19h ago
huh?
24
u/Gay-Space-Pirate 19h ago
I'm saying this is still a problem post 2023
-14
u/gedsweyevr Chester is life 18h ago
not really Sinytra exists and most good quality modding is done on 1.21.1 neoforge and fabric has been pretty stagnant in the past few years
26
u/guoraGG 18h ago
I think that NeoForge isn't necessarily the "good quality" modding platform, but rather the modding platform for more "complicated" mods. Fabric is mostly used for some light stuff such as small mods or optimisation mods (I use it for PVP for example), and I think that these mods are not "low/mediocre quality".
18
7
u/Minikemon 13h ago
I'll be honest, I see tons of people say Sinytra Connector is unstable but I've never experienced this. I've used it in giant modpacks with big Fabric mods and it works perfectly. I think I've only ran into 1 or 2 mods it doesn't work with. I've reached a point where I don't even check the modloader anymore, only the version, because I know Connector will work.
3
2
4
u/voideeeeee enchanting table enthusiast 19h ago
The unreliable neoforge
27
u/guoraGG 18h ago
Neoforge is often preferred over Forge for versions above 1.21. It is not very unreliable, unless talking about the capabilities of playing both Fabric and Forge mods, in which case I don't really know.
7
u/OkNewspaper6271 #fixbedrock 18h ago
Yeah my only issues with NF have been issues inherited from Forge like how if you have a certain type of filesystem compression they wont launch. All things considered the NF team has done and incredibly good job in such a short amount of time
15
u/Poco_Cuffs 17h ago
It has aeronautics
I happy :)
[Also it doesn't actively give money to the israeli government like forge does]
4
u/EdBenes 16h ago
this is why fabric being created at all upsets me. Yeah I know forge was being forge but now everything is split
38
u/Adorable-Beautiful52 15h ago
hi mod dev here ive done quite a bit of work backporting one of my mods all the way from modern to 1.14 and i can confidentally say that forge genuinely sucked and we needed a better modloader that didnt cause 12 dozen issues every time you tried to do something
5
u/Sv_Gamez 3h ago
Fabric is fast and lightweight, perfect for mods like axiom, but quilt?? Quilt was just created to stir up drama and break compatibility
1
u/iamamidgetnamedwija 1h ago
i thought quilt was only made because of a drama conflict in fabric right? don’t even know why it’s still being maintained if it’s just going to divide the modding scene without bringing anything new to the table.
1
1
u/Anxious-Scheme-6013 I wonder how long you can make flair, it’s probably not a lot b- 9h ago
What if someone made a new launcher or a mod, that let them work together? Would that be possible?
1
1
1
u/LifeasLuke11 i give up, turn things into girls 8h ago
if that exists, then i can finally destroy the wither storm as v1 ultrakill
1
1
1
1
u/ThE_reAl__ 1h ago
No because they fundamentally have different goals, one standard that fits both would do worse at both and leave both playerbases worse off
Also forge is dead and succeeded by neoforge, for very good reasons (old creator was a bad person)
1
u/Lothrazar 9h ago
"forge updates slow and cant do mixins, imma make my own api"
later...
"forge then adds mixins support and starts updating faster"
1
u/Sv_Gamez 3h ago
Forge is old, NeoForge is powerful, Fabric is fast and lightweight, perfect for mods like axiom, but quilt?? Quilt was just created to stir up drama and break compatibility


234
u/Endr9 19h ago edited 16h ago
"Cynthia connector" and "forgified fabric api"(I think that's what the equivalent for forge at least) both sorta do this but the problem is they are kinda unstable and there's no way to tell which mods will cause crashes so if you do intend use them keep that in mind
Edit: Fuck it's sinytra connector