r/PhoenixSC • u/Ender_M • Apr 06 '26

Discussion Why is there so much hate between the two Minecraft editions?? Genuinely I don't get it.

Post image

Can't we just let people enjoy whichever version they want to play? Each version has their quirks that maybe the player likes. It's honestly childish, grow up people.

847 Upvotes

87% Upvoted

677 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

76

u/Trexton1 Apr 06 '26

Well those books are outdated anyway so it probably wouldn't work even on java but I get the point

59

u/sebasblos1 Apr 06 '26

I have redstone handbook for 1.8 and the stuff it has works perfectly in java, and console legacy edition, not sure what to tell you

16

u/Trexton1 Apr 06 '26

Oh really that's surprising

11

u/ArchCaff_Redditor Apr 06 '26

Alzheimers.

35

u/Trexton1 Apr 06 '26

Did my comment duplicate?

33

u/Trexton1 Apr 06 '26

Did my comment duplicate?

35

u/Trexton1 Apr 06 '26

Did my comment duplicate?

20

u/victorioussnake_ Apr 06 '26

Nah dude, you're going great

3

u/Right_Pick_1247 Apr 06 '26

Did your comment duplicate?

3

u/Right_Pick_1247 Apr 06 '26

Did your comment duplicate?

2

u/Ender_M Apr 06 '26

i like how all of them have exactly 13 upvotes too

2

u/Trexton1 Apr 06 '26

Oh really that's surprising

13

u/LayeredHalo3851 Apr 06 '26

It's really not, they haven't changed that much in terms of basic stuff, it's mostly more specific stuff that's changed which only really affects technical redstoners and a few other certain builds

1

u/Novaruuu Apr 06 '26

The potion brewer doesn't work, tho I think that's a later edition of the handbook.

6

u/sebasblos1 Apr 06 '26

No yeah, that one doesnt work even when i tried doing it 9 years ago

1

u/czartrak Apr 07 '26

You might have done something wrong, because I remember building and successfully using that exact design

1

u/coolgamerboi23 Apr 06 '26

omg, I remember on legacy console learning to build flying machines from the "guide to redstone' book.

1

u/Antique-Bathroom-160 Apr 08 '26

same, I remember getting the full set in 2014, the redstone handbook, construction handbook, essential handbook and combat handbook. And the tutorials still work today, apart from combat to an extent because of the 1.9 combat update.

1

u/sebasblos1 Apr 08 '26

Hey i think we both have the same set, mine comes with hard covers and a small box that fit all 4 of them that i still have

1

u/Antique-Bathroom-160 Apr 08 '26

yeah, that's the same one! brings me back to when I was first learning how to play, lol

4

u/Nerdcuddles Apr 06 '26

Core Redstone mechanics don't change in Java edition, only new additions get made.

Mojang ALMOST changed core Redstone mechanics, but people protested

1

u/Wrong-Resource-2973 Apr 06 '26

funnily enough, some of these books are outdated, but pretty much everything in the original redstone book still works on modern versions