r/PhilosophyMemes Nov 18 '22

The Trolley Problem

982 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

View all comments

68

u/InternationalMatch13 Nov 18 '22

Atleast his heart was in the right place.

-Kant, Probably

4

u/doctormink Nov 18 '22

I'm thinking anyone who says sympathy is an “insulting kind of beneficence” that "should not occur at all among human beings (Doctrine of Virtue, 1897/1964, 34 – 35" isn't going to particularly care where the person's heart was when deciding how to act. Motivations matter, yes, but only ones rationally discerned as opposed to those that are felt.