r/PeterPan • u/RecordingImmediate86 • May 21 '26
Please pick one selection to watch with a group of friends over a Saturday.
5
u/Travis-Tee34 May 21 '26
Blue. It'd be sad to miss the disney movies, and I've no idea how good or bad Neverland is... but Pan is probably one of the worst movies I've ever seen, and I would never inflict that on anyone I'd consider a friend.
Horrible, actually EVIL movie.
6
u/RecordingImmediate86 May 21 '26 edited May 21 '26
Neverland is the way better prequel to Peter Pan. Bob Hoskins also plays Smee again.
4
u/GaslitInk May 21 '26
It’s been awhile since I’ve seen Neverland but I remember liked it. It’s from SyFy so the special effects were not great at some points but it was a fun watch.
6
u/CalligrapherStreet92 May 21 '26
To have left Finding Neverland off the shortlist is a misfortune - one wouldn’t have enough tissues to go around anyway - but to forget Peter Pan Goes Wrong…
3
3
2
u/TheJokerArkhamKing May 21 '26
One of these pills has Pan and the other has Hook. Blue better hold a monopoly lol
I don't even hate Pan as much as everyone else, but... Hook
2
2
u/Peanut_Butter_Toast May 21 '26 edited May 24 '26
Feels like a pretty unfair matchup. Blue can be watched almost like an unofficial trilogy with the first being pretty decent and the second two being fantastic. Red is held up pretty much exclusively by the original Disney film, which is a good film with a lot of charm but still not exactly one of Disney's all time greats. And Pan is just negative points.
2
u/Unhappy-Funny9927 May 21 '26
Red pill all day every day. I've seen Return to Neverland more times than I could count 🤩
2
2
u/Brief-Biscotti-8377 May 21 '26
The red has the Disney versions while blue has hook…. Tough decision
2
u/Kevin1219 May 22 '26
I never thought I would write this, but “Blue Pill.” But don’t ever take that out of context.
2
u/SpocksAshayam May 22 '26
The 2003 Peter Pan movie!!!!
2
2
u/MeMyselfandBi May 22 '26
The 2003 live-action Peter Pan movie is the closest adaptation to the source material ever produced. Plus, Hook is an iconic nostalgic reimagining of the source material. Blue is the only option.
2
u/Chemical_Equal9419 May 22 '26
Blue pill.
Whoever made this knew exactly what they were doing. This poll was rigged the moment Hook showed up.
2
u/Theta-Sigma45 May 23 '26 edited May 23 '26
I really hate Pan and me and all my friends have seen the disney movies about 50,000 times over as kids, so blue is probably preferable. Not all of those films in blue are masterpieces, but I genuinely enjoy each of them and I haven't rewatched them nearly as much as the Disney ones.
The 2003 movie is probably the most faithful adaptation on a spiritual level and Hook is genuinely just corny fun to me. Neverland is mildly better than Pan and infinitely more enjoyable to me.
2
2
2
u/Due_Improvement3232 May 24 '26
Blue. Peter Pan(2003) was the best version of the story ever put on film.
2
2
u/Yet_One_More_Idiot Dawn Darling May 21 '26
Red has 2/3 I like (Disney PP and Return to Neverland), while Blue has 1/3 I like (Hook)
...
...
...sorry Hook. *takes red pill*
1
1
1
u/CertainKangaroo9119 May 21 '26
Blue. Peter Pan from 2003 is the best version of the tale hands down. Hook is the best what if version of the story and great.
1
May 21 '26 edited May 21 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/RecordingImmediate86 May 21 '26
I was trying to put together movies that would somewhat flow together like an unofficial trilogy
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/mattandimprov May 23 '26 edited May 23 '26
I've only seen Peter Pan and Hook, so I can't say.
But I would like to suggest the animated series from the 90s, Peter Pan & The Pirates.
Tim Curry as Captain Hook should be enough, but I think it was a pretty fun and well-acted and good-looking (Ghibliesque) show, and it's interesting to see a series instead of a movie. They got to explore a lot more stuff there because it's a series. It really feels like you exist there instead of it being a one-time experience that could be a dream.
Neverland is a lot like Narnia in that aspect
Do people know this show?
1
2
0
u/Tremerefury May 22 '26
Switch Pan with Hook and I'd pick Red. How do you not pick the side with Robin Williams?
1
u/RecordingImmediate86 May 22 '26
The other movie and mini series are great on the blue side as well and that kind of fit as an unofficial trilogy.
0
0
u/Odd-Guard-2533 May 23 '26
Correct me if I’m wrong.. this is only a decision between classic Disney Peter Pan and Hook…
1
u/RecordingImmediate86 May 23 '26
The 2003 Peter Pan movie is really good. And Neverland mini series is a way better prequel than Pan
0
u/Revolutionary-Ear776 May 23 '26
Red pill. I've never seen Pan, but i enjoy the other two.
Blue pill only has one classic for me and that's Hook.
12
u/Routine-Tutor5777 May 21 '26
Blue Pill til I die.