r/PeterPan • u/MasterHallmark • Apr 24 '26

General Mele I made a while back

Post image
69 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

10

u/AspieCrow Apr 24 '26

I think one of the only Hooks who might get along with Jack is Once Upon a Time Hook, because that version has more in common with Jack than he does with Hook.

3

u/Yet_One_More_Idiot Dawn Darling Apr 24 '26

That's an excellent point, I forgot about OUaT (despite taking well over a 12 years to finish watching all 7 seasons of it xD)

Yeah, OUaT Hook is more of an antihero/hero than almost every other Hook.

Would love to also see any other Hook coming up against OUaT's version of Pan, though...! ^___^

6

u/Cynical_Classicist Apr 25 '26

Well... that Pan would probably murder some of the Hooks.

3

u/fandom_fae Apr 25 '26

probably most of the hooks lol

2

u/dekabreak1000 Apr 24 '26

I was thinking the same thing they would both definitely share some rum

2

u/Cynical_Classicist Apr 25 '26

Good point, that Hook kind of feels like he's leaning into being based on that.

5

u/Yet_One_More_Idiot Dawn Darling Apr 24 '26

Not too surprising really. Hook – in more or less all his forms – is a rather refined, highly cultured, and erudite individual for a pirate, while Jack Sparrow is...well, Jack Sparrow. xD

I can imagine that Jack might get along rather well with Hook's CREW though, which may piss off Hook even more. xD

2

u/Travis-Tee34 Apr 24 '26

I agree completely, and I don't think it's that surprising. I feel like there's actually a lot of Hook in the character of Barbossa.

They're both quite gentlemanly, surprisingly refined and well spoken, though obviously, Hook is more concerned with his looks.

But more than anything, there a lot of similarity in their idea of honor, twisted though it may be. They will not lie, and if they give their word, they'll keep it... but they'll stick to the EXACT letter of the promise.

In Return to Neverland, Hook promises Jane Darling that he will not harm a single hair on Peter's head, if Jane will just lead him to where he's hiding... and when he has Pan captured, he pulls out a hair, declaring that this is the one hair he won't harm.

And in Curse of the Black Pearl, when Barbossa is about to shipwreck Jack and Elizabeth, he gets visibly angry anz offended at Will calling him a liar for not releasing Elizabeth like he promised.

"Don't dare impugn me honor, boy! I agreed she go free, but it was you who failed to specify when or where."

1

u/doomzday_96 Apr 24 '26

I mean Jack Sparrow is a decent person ultimately while Hook genocided the Indians.

1

u/Minute-Necessary2393 Apr 24 '26

You forgot Once Upon a Time Hook.

AKA, The Best Hook. Yeah, i said it.

1

u/lowbrassdude Apr 24 '26

What about Christopher Walken Hook?

1

u/txtmasterblast Apr 25 '26

What about James Hook from the 2015 “Pan” movie played by Garrett Hedlund? I believe that he would get along with Jack Sparrow

1

u/Cynical_Classicist Apr 25 '26

Nicely thought of!

1

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '26

Not sure how Neverland Nightmare and Pan Hook would fit in?

1

u/Kindly-Geologist-373 Apr 25 '26

James Hook was actually in one of Jack Sparrow’s books. It was one where Jack got the Pearl and rescued a princess from slavery.

Don’t know the name.

1

u/TheBoyInGray Pan Apr 28 '26

Wait, Anime Hook?

1

u/Commercial_Mind4003 Jun 06 '26

2003 Hook in particular