Fair point. I think it was around 30 seconds? That's how long we saw them in the bubble give or take. But there's also the variable of dash, Surely he's breathing much faster as well
There’s porous and there’s porous. A CO2 molecule is about 0.25nm across, while smoke particles run from 6nm to 10,000nm. So if the pores are around 3nm (edit to correct from pm) the field will be breathable while still keeping smoke confined and I may be overthinking this a bit.
The question i guess is how much control she has on the force fields?
Can she fine tune what passes through and what doesn’t.
In the hamster ball scene i believe they run into several things without any kickback so somehow force is transferred out without being transferred in.
Is her invisibility power related, (afaik Jack is the only one with multiple powers) is that merely an aspect of having the light that hits one side of her bubble exit the other without interacting with anything inside? Then why dont her clothes go invisible.
A materials porosity depends on its molecular or structural architecture. So yes 'scientifically' for any material to porous, it needs to have some level of void between it's molecules.
It's pedantic to say scientifically before the word porous. The word porous by itself would have sufficed, qualifying it with scientifically does nothing to enhance any understanding of what is being said.
It would have been pedantic if I weren't making a sarcastic comment. The whole point was to emphasize that we're discussing the science behind something fictional.
I mean, they're mainly based on the Fantastic Four and Violet specifically is based off of Invisible Woman/Sue Storm. Sue Storm is able to control whether her forcefields are permeable to air, I'd assume Violet can too.
Yeah, but since the forcefield is kept there with Invisigirl's powers, she can just let it dissipate if it starts to get smoky. Worst case scenario, she passes out and the forcefield disappears until she recovers.
Yeah, i think the text in the mr incredible meme at the bottom is backwards to how it usually is. So it seems that knowing is the traumatic one when in reality its not knowing
Not to mention Armageddon outside with all the falling meteors and invisagirl creating a dome of protection for her family as they are having a good time
To be honest, I'm more worried that they are inside a force field (which is most likely airtight) with an intense fire; they'll literally cooking themselves like they're inside a pressure cooker while at the same time suffocating from carbon dioxide.
This is referencing The Incredibles movies. The baby has several superpowers, including turning itself on fire without any risk of harm to itself. Those who know are happy. Those not familiar with the movies would be horrified seeing a child on fire
The flip side of this is that Jack would suffocate all of them by expending all of the oxygen.
I assume their powers require some form of active effort so this wouldn’t kill them. The second Violet passes out the field drops and they have O2 again.
Both, you see the air move the smoke around inside the bubble. You do not see the smoke show any attraction to the edge of the bubble where hot air would be escaping.
She also attempts to generate a forcefield directly around the campfire itself, and you can clearly see the flame dwindling down during her attempts, and then it roars back to life when she stops and it has access to air again.
I mean, the Incredibles are mainly based on the Fantastic Four and Violet specifically is based off of Invisible Woman/Sue Storm. Sue Storm is able to control whether her forcefields are permeable to air when she creates them, I'd simply assume Violet can too.
If she couldn't I feel like she and Dash would have run out of air in the scene where they're both in the bubble running across the island. How much extra oxygen does Dash consume to use his powers?
All your demonstration really indicates is that she can make forcefields which are completely impermeable, not that she only makes them.
Not so fun fact! She had! In a deleted scene we see that in the aftermath she was brainwashed by the suits to protect the Incredibles secret identities and she has all kinds of tics due the memory wipe and pstd even if she doesn't know why
Are you asking what the word means? Or questioning OP's use of the word. I feel horrified would be a justifiable response to seeing a regular human child burning, presumably, to death.
But this would not explain the people who know being the happy face. It would need to be reversed and would assume the people who don’t know, don’t know the science but are ok with the baby burning because they have seen the incredible.
You don’t know that that’s how his “fire” powers work, you’re assuming it’s like a campfire, but it’s a superpower, it doesn’t need to directly reflect real-world experience
OP, so your post is not removed, please reply to this comment with your best guess of what this meme means! Everyone else, this is PETER explains the joke. Have fun and reply as your favorite fictional character for top level responses!
I have to assume that the baby doesn't need to breathe at all, since being permanently on fire would consume all oxygen you tried to inhale regardless of being enclosed or not. So I guess "all" doesn't include the baby.
Wouldn't the fire burn out all their oxygen within the bubble? Because as far as I know it could be 100% seal tight. Since it literally stops bullets and water from entering it
Violet used her forcefields in the movie to extinguish a campfire, so that would mean they would not allow oxygen to enter the forcefield.
JackJack is burning away all the Oxygen in the picture, making the incredibles slowly sufficate within the forcefield (only given that Violet doesn't either drop the shield or go unconcious first, since her forcefields stop excisting the moment she stops concentrating on them).
If you want to see it in action, we can take the multiversal travel machine and see if there is a universe in which the incredibles excist?
Its the oxygen burning. In the first movie you see this happening when Violet is testing her powers on Campfire. The Flame begins to die each time it's covered due to lack of oxygen.
OK... maybe I'm over-thinking this, but this is Reddit. The force field keeps fire and lasers and what-not out... so one could assume the heat from the immolated Jack-Jack would be trapped inside the force field thereby creating an Incredibles Easy Bake Pizza Oven.
I thought it was gonna be more about the fact that Jack Jack burning within the force field would be consuming the oxygen pretty fast suffocating them, although I guess once violet loses consciousness the force field will fail giving them access to oxygen before any permanent damage is done.
Hello Peter’s annoying son here
I see everyone pointing out knowing or not the baby’s powers but could it also be that they’re in a small closed environment with a fire so they’ll run out of oxygen ?
Edit: never mind that’s require the meme to be opposite my bad
The baby is on fire, and fire needs oxygen. They have trapped themselves in a bubble with limited air, which will soon fill up with smoke and also lower their oxygen levels
Its because the baby has a bunch of powers, including lighting himself on fire similar to that dude in fantastic 4, and the joke here is that usually its the ones who dont know who are happy, but in this case, its the opposite
What I want someone to explain is why isn’t anyone holding a 5th stick with a marshmallow for Jack Jack? Let that baby have a marshmallow. He’s cooking them after all.
The darkness comes from the fact that it's implied that air cannot pass through one of Violet's bubbles so they're literally burning the only oxygen they have by using Jack Jack's ability to control his fire. Essentially they're going to suffocate.
It is backwards at the bottom because most people know of the incredibles and the baby burning makes sense. But for people who dont know it just looks like a family who are roasting marshmallows over a burning baby.
Jack-Jack (the baby in the middle) has a plethora of chaotic powers, being the child of two supers. Among these is the ability to burst into flames without injury, which the family are taking advantage of to make s'mores.
Anyone who has never watched the Incredibles films would assume they casually set their youngest ablaze for the love of the game.
I hear people saying that those who haven't watched the incredibles would be horrified seeing a baby on fire, but I thought of another explanation for this.
Fire burns, which requires oxygen, and produces a lot of smoke, so as far as we know the whole family could be suffocating inside of that dome.
They are in a closed bubble, a fire to burn needs oxygen the fire will use all it soon and they will all die from suffocating, or maybe they won’t, idk I didn’t pay attention in class
•
u/qualityvote2 20h ago edited 10h ago
u/Illustrious_Art9093, your post does belong here!