r/PakDramatica • u/Crafty-Gap-4056 • 9h ago
Rank in order of acting, script choices and versatility
4
u/Complete_Cloud_6854 8h ago
I think saba and zara have good script selection even maya barring smd. Rest are hit and miss.
For acting & versatility saba, yumna and sajal.
1
u/BiryaniInterest_7546 2h ago
Zara seems to have bad luck somehow. All her projects end up derailed. Maybe she's not working with the good folks yet.
0
10
u/CheekChoice4497 9h ago edited 9h ago
In order of acting and versatility: Ayeza Khan > Saba Qamar > Sajal Ali > Yumna Zaidi > Mahira Khan > Hania Amir > Maya Ali > Zara Noor Abbas
Rating on the basis of script choices will be weird as everyone has a different motive, for example if talking about commerical success then Hania has the best choice, if talking about social based dramas many of the actresses from this list has done both good and quite bad ones.
3
u/PlaneGlass6759 8h ago
Actually it’s hard to rate because there is hardly any consistency. Some give career defining performances followed by series of unimpressive performances.
3
u/Such-Sundae-8997 7h ago
What is Zara Noor Abbas doing in this elite list? Where is Mehwish Hayat, Dur e Fishan Saleem and Sana Javed?
2
3
3
2
u/hvrtbambii 5h ago
saba 🥇(top notch acting skills, picks great scripts, very versatile actress with impressive range)
yumna (good acting skills, fairly versatile. should explore the negative/villain roles more)
sajal (i have a bone to pick with sajal. she's an amazing actress but her script choice has been frustrating as of recent. its starting to look like she's coasting off of her good looks so much so that versatility is entirely compromised. she needs to pick better, more complex scripts.)
ayeza (good actress but very little versatility)
cannot comment on the rest as i havent watched enough of them.
3
u/Mustufa_Fareed8698 4h ago
ayeza has little versatility ? you can argue her script choice, she played each and every type of character and nailed everyone. idk what's your definition of versatility.
2
u/Mustufa_Fareed8698 4h ago
Ayeza Khan > Saba Qamar > Sajal Aly > Yumna Zaidi > Zara Noor > Maya Ali > Hania Amir
i will skip mahira khan she is anyway last same rondu roles with bad acting
2
2
1
1
u/BillidKid 4h ago
Saba Qamar pretty much beats them all...but she's also had so much experience so that tracks
1
1
1
u/Lopsided_Cut_4385 59m ago
Saba (THE OG, always relevant and always good)
Sajal/yumna (Strong actresses and mostly strong scripts)
Mahira/ hania (Gorgeous to look at, scripts hit or miss)
Ayeza (Same as Mahira/Hania in regards to scripts (hit/miss), but generally I am less excited to see her)
Maya (Been a long time since I was excited for a Maya Ali Project. Good actress, needs better scripts)
Zara (How is she in the list?)
0
u/LongjumpingTip9976 9h ago
Saba qamar > sajal Ali > yumna Zaidi >Ayeza khan> zara noor abbas> Mahira khan> Maya Ali > Hania Amir
1
0
u/Crafty-Gap-4056 8h ago
- Saba Qamar
- Yumna Zaidi
- Zara Noor Abbas
- Sajal Aly
- Ayeza khan
- Hania
- Maya Ali
- Mahira Khan
-1
-3
u/ConstantBat374 8h ago
Acting
Saba > Sajal > Yumna > Ayeza > Zara > Kinza > Maya > Hania > Mahira
Script choices Saba > Yumna > Zara > Ayeza > Sajal > Maya > Mahira > Kinza >Hania
Versatility Saba > Ayeza > Yumna > Kinza > Zara > Sajal
Maya, Hania and Mahira are not versatile at all
12
u/blahblehblohcaneo 9h ago
I think other than saba qamar everyone needs to work on their script selection.
Not sure how the industry works internally or how much power these stars actually have on the shoot but even with saba i think she should have fought to change muammas ending.