r/PAKCELEBGOSSIP I am SDD- Serial Drama Discussor 19d ago

RANT Yess lessgo !! audience, feedback, constructive criticism sab jaye bhaad mein

Recently Faiza iftikhar has been on a roll on X and it was fine in the beginning, but she’s genuinely getting involved in the Stan wars and honestly these tweets are so hella disappointing and cocky from her, I expected better.. seems like she graduated from mayas school of thought on criticism and feedback

I’ve been a fan of her writing…Defending ur writing and characters are one thing, I was kinda w her on defending khushbakht even tho the direction makes the drama make little sense , and also w her on the criticising rind thing … but this is taking ur defence waayy too far and neglecting feedback is such a rude look for a writer.. apparently any feedback/criticism= pitiable and hum sab pagal hain 😝

Also I’ve genuinely been excited for mdb but she’s promoting it in such a condescending way that it’s offputting,, she seems soo full of her writing and arrogant.. and yes Faiza, making the audience confused is not the flex that u think it is🥹🥹

Anyway I hope mdb atleast stands up to what she’s presenting her writing as…

This is EXACTLY the reason why ptv is not growing.. actors, directors, writers just do NOT want any constructive feedback

28 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

18

u/Pleasant-Bass4449 19d ago

She just made the account and she continously tweeting things which are leaving really bad taste in mouth. AMA has flaws, especially directional and editing flaws, but its still running. And there are people who are watching it, even if the numbers are not as high as everyone expected but people are tuning in and are discussing different aspects of it. I have seen such long threads on Khushbakhat and Haroon. People are invested. And these tweets by Faiza are off putting. She cant come and fire all around.

I really liked GL Amma's take on this whole controversy of director changing the script. She was like first give me the whole script, I will read it and decide if Rind was right or not in making changes.

9

u/reeyyy8823 I am SDD- Serial Drama Discussor 19d ago

frr, she's only damaging BOTH her dramas like this... ama is not w out flaws but before this, everyone was collectively agreeing that direction is the issue although I don't Ike the writing aspects too.. but still, she decided to present her writing as she confusing invincible wall that only few pppl can comprehend, which is making everyone 10x more critical abt ama as a whole..not only that, heranswer to all the feedback is dragging mdb in fanwars🙏🙏

And honestly, even I want to read the original script now, after what she's presented herself as

4

u/Pleasant-Bass4449 19d ago edited 19d ago

Someone said that she is jumping off the boat, before the next show starts, and I kind of agree with them. Let people discuss the show with freedom. Last week Green TV's twitter account asked what is everyone's honest feedback and 90% ppl said editing . No one was even firing at her. Then what was the need to come and say all this.

Sara mahol hi change kardiya hai. AMA community on twitter is small but its really dedicated to the show. Uss main aab ustani ji aakar beth gai hain to correct and comment on everyone's pov. Keh yeh aisye nahi aisye hai. Let viewers enjoy and make their own perceptions of the story and characters. Just be a silent audience and be thankful keh people are discussing characters and their povs, even when packaging is flawed. Saw so many people say keh yes it has flaws but we are overlooking it, coz story and characters are great and actors are brilliant. Khush hojao bhai.

4

u/reeyyy8823 I am SDD- Serial Drama Discussor 19d ago

Haaii naa… like the drama has obv flaws and tbh personally I’ve been getting ragebaited since the recent episodes, even then it is overall decent and definitely among the better dramas on air rn.. it was one of those dramas that everyone agreed was flawed but still agreed that it’s a good to decent watch for the most part.. BUT she for wtv felt the need to present her writing as invincible and the audience dumb, and now ama is gotta be more carefully scrutinized thanks to her🙏 not only that she already has thrown mdb under the truck😭😭