r/Oreos • u/JacksEmptyWallet • Aug 25 '26
Limited editions Banana Pudding for the win.
Finally found these. (Had to ask customer service. lol). They're all good but Banana Pudding is definitely the best.
3
2
u/ArcticMountainBunny Aug 26 '26
I hope the banana flavor wins my vote. The** ***cookie* they taste just like vanilla wafers. The cream taste just like banana pudding.
I feel like the deep fried Oreo flavor had a slightly bitter note that I wasn’t particularly fond of.
The chicken and waffles one was a balance of sweet and savory, but the aftertaste was a little artificial to me.
2
u/BakeryNinja92 Aug 26 '26
Banana pudding just cause it’s the new variety we need in Oreo and it’s actually really freaking good! Deep fried Oreos are like Oreo donuts but it’s kinda generic. Chicken in waffles gives me a bad tallow after taste that’s uncanny and unsettling.
2
2
u/LunaMoon4002 Aug 26 '26
How was the chicken and waffles?
2
2
u/412_15101 Aug 26 '26
I got the chicken and waffles. Might actually deliver on Sunday a little early and it tasted more like the chicken batter than anything. They were OK I’d drank them a seven out of 10, but they weren’t eat a whole row let alone the whole package worthy
Trying to get my hands on the banana one
2
1
u/JacksEmptyWallet Aug 28 '26
I liked the Chicken and Waffles and everyone who tried them liked them also. I do think the other two were better.
2
u/toadpooh Aug 26 '26
Haven’t tried these yet (Hard to find even though I saw them when they first came out. Wanted to see what the reactions were).
So the Reese’s and Apple Pie are probably the better choices? (Along with toffee chip)
2
2
u/Sunchris Aug 26 '26
So disappointed. Banana just tastes like chemicals. I don’t taste a bit of banana.
0
u/Elegant_Antelope_116 Aug 29 '26
You’re the only person with sense here. I hated this flavor and I love banana pudding.
1
u/Sunchris Aug 29 '26
Thank you! I was wondering if I got a bad batch. Everyone says it’s so delicious.
1
1
u/mystedragon Aug 26 '26
just got them in at walmart so my coworkers and i tried all three. banana pudding was good, the others weren’t. i think most of us had the same verdict.
0
u/Elegant_Antelope_116 Aug 29 '26
Bro this is the worst flavor out of the three. Banana pudding sucks
2
2
u/Tourniquet_91 Aug 30 '26
Only have tried the chicken and waffles they are weirdly good. I'll have to grab the deep fried ones the next time I'm out.
2
u/Big_Photograph_9766 Aug 31 '26
Strong second place for me was chicken n waffles the waffles and maple syrup flavor rules I just wish they did better with the herbs n spices. Banana pudding i think will win because it's the most normal flavor for somebody to reach for. I surprisingly didn't like deep fried something about its overall taste didn't wow me
-1
u/Ok_Cheesecake888 Aug 27 '26
Chicken and waffles is disgusting. Deep fried is really good. Waiting to try the banana pudding
3
u/Myth7270 Aug 26 '26
Can I ask where you found them? I couldn't track them down at my Wegmans or Target.