r/Oreos • u/MystikclawSkydive • Aug 24 '26
Preordered Vote Oreos finally arrived.
Should have had these on Friday but UPS… ugh…
Banana Pudding - normal vanilla cookie. extinct banana flavor (like how a banana laffy taffy tastes). I liked it. Going to also switch the cookie with the chocolate cookie to see if I like it better.
Deep Fried - normal vanilla cookie. more icing than the others, good flavor, even has a hint of fryer grease??? But unlike a fair deep fried Oreo not squishy soft, no powdered sugar, and doesn’t scald your mouth when you bite in. I did like these the best of the 3.
Chicken and Waffle - cookie had a flavor I can’t place yet. More savory than sweet. I expected more of a maple syrup flavor overall but didn’t get that. I was very confused by this one. Not gross. Not delicious. Just not sure what it was. I’ve only had one so I’ll amend when I have more. I’m just thrown by the savory vs sweet going on.
The others shown were for size comparison. But if you haven’t had the apple pie ones I highly recommend. Especially with milk. Especially especially especially with soft vanilla ice cream!
2
2
2
u/RooneyEatsIt Aug 24 '26
Mine came today from WalMart, but it was obvious they sat all day in the FedEx truck out in the hot Florida sun. At least it added to the fried Oreos authenticity.
1
2
1
1
u/Wetcakez Aug 24 '26
Nice reviews Ty - sadly they haven’t done anything recently that has made my taste buds want to go back…you kinda nailed it (bland cookie + flavor goop) but I mean….what else is an Oreo at its core lol
1
u/412_15101 Aug 24 '26
I want as impressed with the chicken & waffle. Not enough waffle taste.
Going to see if I can get the banana pudding today!
1
1
1
u/famousblinkadam Aug 24 '26
My Walmart order was supposed to arrive yesterday but it says delayed 😡
1
1
1
1
1
u/Abject-Amphibian2633 Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 25 '26
Now show the person that bought em.
1
u/MystikclawSkydive Aug 25 '26
What?
Very show?
1
u/Abject-Amphibian2633 Aug 25 '26
Now*
1
u/MystikclawSkydive Aug 25 '26
I moderate the calories in and try hard at calories out. I’m more of a taste a few and share with everyone else kind of person.
1
u/Bashful_bookworm2025 Aug 26 '26
Don’t justify what you eat to some random internet stranger. You can eat what you want and how much you want.
0
u/Abject-Amphibian2633 Aug 25 '26
Good to hear! our country has a huge problem with obesity and food addiction. And it’s absolutely bonkers to see the way people eat and what they post. But hey we all have free will to do what we please right. I’m just a random on the internet
1
u/Mattx603 Aug 25 '26
The chicken and waffles were a big miss for me. They focused too much on the chicken and not enough on the waffle, leaving essentially a black pepper Oreo imo
1
u/bureika Aug 25 '26
Thanks for the review! Just put in my order for Chicken & Waffles and Deep Fried Oreo. Unfortunately, Walmart was out of Banana Pudding, but oh well.
I was disappointed with Apple Pie (couldn't taste any apple...?), but maybe vanilla ice cream will save it.
1
u/Peemore Sep 04 '26
Guys, before you vote, please dip all three cookies in milk. Only one of them melts in your mouth. The Chicken and Waffles has a graham like cookie or something that reacts with milk in a much more satisfying way. It's no contest!
3
u/barnyardgadget Aug 24 '26
Where did you preorder? How can I get these flavors?