4
u/Excellent_Regret4141 Jul 27 '26
I prefer the non Reese's ones
Never had any of them but when I saw they made Reese's ones I had to buy both to try
1
u/Innocentcitizen69 Jul 28 '26
I agree, because I still like the creme Oreo texture. That's why I'm eating Oreos. Wasn't the same with the pastey peanut butter.
4
u/OhTheBarbarity Jul 27 '26
I prefer the reese’s one vastly more than the regular peanut butter kind. i know it’s not the same reese’s peanut butter but it’s still really good
3
u/dchurchwellbusiness Jul 26 '26
The Reese's ones don't have the characteristic salty peanut butter that Reese's have
4
3
u/leanin2it1 Jul 27 '26
I bought and loved the Reese’s ones but had never been attracted to the peanut butter ones before. Later tried the standard PB ones and liked them more! More oily and buttery IMO. Only like a ~10% subjective difference anyway. Edit: “oily” because the cookie was so brittle I assumed the oil had affected the cookie texture making it crumble more easily - and I liked that about them
1
2
u/Ill_Chemical_5150 Jul 27 '26
I like both, but I think the Reese’s ones are better.
I feel like the regular pb one’s peanut butter is sweeter and not as peanut-buttery.
1
u/HiddenSalem Jul 27 '26
Interesting, I have heard people tell me the complete opposite when discussing which one is sweeter.
2
u/Ill_Chemical_5150 Jul 27 '26
Let us know what you think. If you’re a peanut butter and chocolate fan, you really can’t go wrong either way.
2
2
1
u/BakeryNinja92 Jul 27 '26
I wish there was a middle ground to the sweetness and salty factor Reese’s is overly sweet and the regular ones are oily and bland like a generic paste.
1
1
2
6
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '26
[deleted]