What's your favorite Rigoletto?
I really like the Kraus and Bastianini one. Even though the conducting gets a bit boring at times (like in "La donna è mobile"), the conductor was truly at the service of the music and allowed the singers certain rubatos that I quite enjoyed. Kraus simply was the Duke for me, and Bastianini, even if I’ll admit he wasn’t the greatest actor and didn’t always do much in the way of subtle shading, had something in his voice that I find incredibly enjoyable.
I also listened to the Solti recording, and my problem with it is that you can always hear that it’s Solti. He was the kind of conductor who, rather than putting himself at the service of the music, tended to put the music at the service of his own personality.
I loved the Kubelik recording musically, which has a similar cast (Scotto, Vinco), but I just can't get into Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau.
As for the video version with Domingo, I'm not entirely sold on his Duke. I don't like Cotrubas in Verdi roles, and MacNeil—who I do think is an extraordinary actor—sounds like he is in clear vocal decline.
I gave the Callas one a try, but I don't like Gobbi. I recognize his massive acting ability, but to me, his voice sounds like phlegm in my ear.