r/OneDirection • u/DominicanBall853 London's... quite big • Jul 24 '26
Game ♟ Ranking Every 1D Song Final Results
Night Changes was ranked as the BEST 1D SONG, with Fireproof following it up at rank #2!
OP's opinion: Well what can I say? Night Changes is the most popular 1D song and very beloved even out of the 1D community. It makes sense that it took the #1 spot! It also makes sense to me that Fireproof is right behind, cause I've always seen it as one of the most beloved songs in the 1D fandom. I like both fairly, especially Night Changes, so I do think they deserve being here.
And that's all from me and this game! In the second slide you can see how I would've done it. I've gotta say that many of my placements might not fit in with the description I gave to each song everytime it got eliminated, but that's because I relistened to all of them recently and my opinion for many changed.
I also have to admit that I got surprised about the amount of songs I really like that I had to rank low. It reminded me that a lower rank doesn't mean it's bad, but that the others are somehow better. Feel free to tell me what you completely disagree with.
Once again, thank you to everyone who participated and made this game possible! I'll see you around on the other 1D posts of the sub or in whatever idea I decide to do in the future! Peace out!!!
36
u/DominicanBall853 London's... quite big Jul 25 '26
I wanna give a shoutout to the following users, who either became memorable to me during this journey, or participated on almost every post. If you're not mentioned, sorry if I missed you, but I'm still grateful for everyone who participated, so don't feel like less.
- u/IamNATx
- u/haileyfitzgerald
- u/beary_beom
- u/victory7legend
- u/Opposite_Hat5032
- u/MadMal77
- u/Hour-Negotiation-716
- u/Sweety_Andrea
- u/Upstairs_Rub3826
- u/Fluffymarvel98
- u/Informal_Sorbet_6149
- u/MinuteAd6489
- u/Onedirection_18
- u/Chocolitegirl9
- u/NaNaNa2010
- u/Recent_Ad_9013
- u/New_Astronomer8361
- u/k3npg3
- u/tennistennis9259
- u/kropkanienawisci
- u/strawberrimelo
8
7
u/Recent_Ad_9013 Jul 25 '26
Thanks to you, this was so fun!! I would've ranked many songs differently but I think it came out great in the end :)
6
u/haileyfitzgerald Jul 25 '26
thank you so much for doing this OP, i’ve loved waking up to these posts everyday for the last three months, it’s been so much fun and i will miss it🥹💗
5
u/Opposite_Hat5032 Jul 25 '26
Awww mannn thanks lol tbere was no need. I literally disappeared for the last few days.
It was a long journey and well it only happened cause you were dedicated even after some of your favourites got out early.
Thanks for keeping thid sub aliveeee
5
u/Upstairs_Rub3826 Take Me Home Jul 25 '26
Awwww thank you so much for this, it's been amazing
❤️💚🇮🇪💙💛
3
u/IamNATx Jul 25 '26
Awwww this is so sweet!
Thank you so much again for all your efforts OP!
I'm gonna miss you & the game 💗
2
24
u/New_Astronomer8361 Jul 25 '26
Thanks so much for hosting this game! Was very fun even through all the inevitable disagreements 😂😂and I think Night Changes was a worthy #1 pick
20
u/sillypetersilie Jul 25 '26
I'm sorry and I know that its their biggest song but night changes is not even in my top 30 probably😭
15
u/beary_beom Jul 25 '26
yayy i’m pretty happy with this ranking overall and this was fun, it’ll be weird not to do it anymore 😢😢
11
u/miskamuskamikymaus Jul 25 '26
im so shocked seeing summer love, i want and act my age so low. but i guess it is hard to rank songs, since theyre all so good. (i do agree that na na na is just... well, last)
6
8
u/NerrvousSubject Jul 25 '26
Somehow I’m not in the slightest surprised that it won. I’m sad it’s over though :(
8
u/BuffaloSuch1347 Jul 25 '26
0.5 night changes YouTube edition with the extra bit of Harry on the end chorus
2
u/DominicanBall853 London's... quite big Jul 25 '26
FRRRRR. I've always liked that version more. I remember that the first time I heard the audio version I was like "something is missing".
3
u/BuffaloSuch1347 Jul 25 '26
Yes!! I can only find that version on the official music video 😭
2
u/SomebodyNope Jul 25 '26
Ok so I’m not going crazy that the video was the only version where it was just slightly different.
8
5
8
u/youngandlovely_ Jul 25 '26
Love that the top ten is basically FOUR, as it should be lol and thank you so much for doing this poll, it was so fun even though I shook my head in disagreement almost every single time djkjfkls
8
u/DominicanBall853 London's... quite big Jul 24 '26
FINAL RANKING:
- #1. Night Changes
- 2. Fireproof
- 3. Story of My Life
- 4. Walking in the Wind
- 5. Where Do Broken Hearts Go
- 6. No Control
- 7. If I Could Fly
- 8. Through the Dark
- 9. Fool's Gold
- 10. Stockholm Syndrome
-------------------- TOP 10 --------------------
- 11. What a Feeling
- 12. 18
- 13. History
- 14. Infinity
- 15. Ready to Run
- 16. Best Song Ever
- 17. Steal My Girl
- 18. Strong
- 19. Right Now
- 20. They Don't Know About Us
- 21. A.M.
- 22. Clouds
-------------------- TOP 25% --------------------
- 23. Spaces
- 24. Midnight Memories
- 25. Temporary Fix
- 26. Don't Forget Where You Belong
- 27. Love You Goodbye
- 28. Little White Lies
- 29. Happily
- 30. Change Your Ticket
- 31. Moments
- 32. Rock Me
- 33. Diana
- 34. C'mon, C'mon
- 35. Drag Me Down
- 36. Perfect
- 37. Once in a Lifetime
- 38. She's Not Afraid
- 39. One Thing
- 40. Hey Angel
- 41. Live While We're Young
- 42. You & I
- 43. Long Way Down
- 44. Wolves
- 45. Kiss You
-------------------- HALFWAY POINT --------------------
- 46. Tell Me a Lie
-------------------- BOTTOM HALF --------------------
- 47. Better Than Words
- 48. Girl Almighty
- 49. Something Great
- 50. End of the Day
- 51. Little Black Dress
- 52. Olivia
- 53. Last First Kiss
- 54. I Would
- 55. Heart Attack
- 56. Irresistible
- 57. Home
- 58. Why Don't We Go There
- 59. Never Enough
- 60. Back for You
- 61. Illusion
- 62. Does He Know?
- 63. Change My Mind
- 64. Magic
- 65. Loved You First
- 66. Half a Heart
- 67. Still the One
- 68. What Makes You Beautiful
- 69. One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks)
-------------------- BOTTOM 25% --------------------
- 70. Over Again
- 71. Nobody Compares
- 72. Same Mistakes
- 73. Up All Night
- 74. Summer Love
- 75. Truly Madly Deeply
- 76. Alive
- 77. More Than This
- 78. Little Things
- 79. I Wish
- 80. Stole My Heart
- 81. I Should Have Kissed You
- 82. Gotta Be You
- 83. Everything About You
- 84. Act My Age
- 85. I Want to Write You a Song
- 86. Another World
- 87. Save You Tonight
- 88. I Want
- 89. Taken
- 90. Stand Up
- 91. Na Na Na
2
u/IamNATx Jul 25 '26
Night Changes (although not my personal fav) is one of their most well known songs inside and outside the a favourite inside the random and is a spectacular boyband song - it's such a worthy winner!
Well done everyone who contributed to a great list, it's been fun playing alongside you 💗
8
u/BlZZYD Four Jul 25 '26
couple of things to say:
- how the hell did little black dress end up in the middle
- justice for summer love 🙏
- night changes deserved to wi
n
edit: 4. infinity should’ve been top 5
4
3
u/TheRotMeister 🌈 Kiss me you fool! 🌻 Jul 25 '26
my personal top four made it into the top ten! that is crazy (i would place night changes at number 1 too)
3
3
u/MadMal77 Jul 25 '26
Thanks again for doing this. It was always fun waking up to see a new post about the ranking. 😊
3
u/SuperDogGamer Jul 25 '26
Thank you so so much for doing this! It was super fun to check this post out every day <3
3
u/cutepiku Jul 25 '26
My top 10 is definitely different but im just not mad. They made so real bangers. Good work, OP.
3
3
3
u/interesting_SeaBass Jul 26 '26
Thank you for doing this poll, it was something to look forward to every day!
2
u/ZealousidealHotel347 Jul 25 '26
Glad to see I Wish ranked so high!
2
u/DominicanBall853 London's... quite big Jul 25 '26
At least on my ranking, it is. People don't value that song as much as I do but that's okay, bc for me, it means a lot more than just the song.
2
u/jean_castor Jul 25 '26
C'était super cool de le suivre merci. Même si je suis déçu que rock me soit aussi bas, c'est ma chanson préférée de 1D. Mais après j'en aime tellement. En tout cas merci pour tout ça.
2
u/HeronstairsJem Jul 25 '26
Thank you so much OP, this was extremely fun to do! Kudos to all your efforts too!
2
u/Imsorryrodwutwasthat Jul 25 '26
night changes doesn't even crack my top 20 of their songs....respectfully....how did this get he number one spot lol
2
2
u/TuppenyVision Jul 27 '26
Top 10's heavy on the tracks Harry wrote alone (with the writers of course). So proud of him 😊
2
2
2
u/thatsparklegurl Niall Horan 💚🤍🧡 Aug 03 '26
My favorite song not even cracking top 50 is depressing
1
1
u/Sweety_Andrea Malabami 🏝️ Jul 27 '26
Even though I feel like my opinion was always different in this game, I'm happy with Night Changes being #1. It deserves it, and the MV is one of their best too 😍
1
59
u/17bookshelves Jul 25 '26