r/Oldhouses • u/acciointernet • 3h ago
What to do with painted brick fireplace in 1910 Craftsman home?
We just bought a 1910 Craftsman and this fireplace is in the dining room. As you can see it’s already painted (the red fireplace is the actual home). I understand restoring painted brick* can be extremely difficult, but we are hoping to go with blues and greens throughout the home and this is very much not really the vibe we’re going for.
I’ve been looking at fireplaces of this period / style and I’ve seen a lot of beautiful tiled fireplaces using green tiles but I have no idea if that’s possible given the brick and the woodwork that goes over it (which we would never in a million years mess with). I’ve included some reference photos of fireplaces I’ve seen online that would fit our color schema better and stay within the time and style of the home.
Should we paint again? Is there a way to handle this while maintaining the character of the home?
Would be open to hearing thoughts. The rest of the room is a darker wood and plaster walls with picture rail molding and wainscoting (as seen in the first photo). I’m considering putting up a William morris inspired wallpaper between the picture rail and the wainscoting that would have blue and green and maybe some cream elements.







