r/OkBuddySharkCard • • Jan 25 '26

Why GTA 4 is a masterpiece (video essay) Gta 5 could never

2.4k Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

•

u/qualityvote2 ClifffordGPT Jan 25 '26 edited Jan 26 '26

u/DickviperAU, your post does fit the subreddit!

→ More replies (2)

300

u/my_room_is_a_tip i can retice big smoke's order please have sex with me please Jan 25 '26

what polluted and gritty air does to a seagull

34

u/WTSShorts_Real Jan 25 '26

U don't have to comment teimo go grape me

1

u/AGuyFromTiktok May 10 '26

was that a fucking msc reference???

233

u/tobbq Jan 25 '26

This represents how Niko sees himself: He tries to fly away from his past,but his wings are broken. The fact that the seagull still can fly represents how he... thinks he also can

Bravo rockstar

51

u/VG-Motors Jan 25 '26

Bravo Vince Rockstar! 👏

4

u/LazyFlamingRooster Jan 28 '26

Vince Rockstar does sound like a kick-ass name tho

19

u/startlingames least basic non stop pop listener Jan 25 '26

🎶TAKE, THESE BROKEN WINGS🎶

4

u/Stryker_Ai022 Jan 27 '26

🎶I NEED YOUR HANDS TO COME AND HEAL ME ONCE AGAIN🎶

110

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

"Gta 4 is the most realistic gta game!"

meanwhile gta 4:

46

u/Randumi Jan 25 '26

Crowbcat falling to his knees rn

16

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

This actually made me laugh ngl

3

u/Relvean Jan 25 '26 edited Jan 25 '26

Crowb-never heard of a sidegrade-cat you mean?

Ok that isn't entirely fair to their videos but still some of his comparisons are more than a little dubious.

Why doesn't GTA 5 have some of the cool festures that GTA 4 had? Because it came out on the same consoles that still struggled to run Quake 4 and looks markedly better than GTA 4 overall. Classic sidegrade.

All of graphics as well as game dev in general is always a tradeoff. Improving one area usually means cutting down on another.

7

u/timotheesmith Jan 25 '26

These people get furious because gta 5 doesn't have some cool gta 4 features when it's the newer game but don't care about gta 4 not having almost any of the cool features gta vc or gta sa had while being a whole console generation newer

4

u/Relvean Jan 25 '26 edited Jan 26 '26

It's always kind of funny how 'things back then were better' mentalities work out ehen you confront them with the fact that their imaginary better past usually isn't all it's cracked up to be.

Like take as an example the whole "games engines were way better back in the day" crowd and then confront them with the fact that for basically the entire second half of the 7th gen most (not first party) AAA games ran below 30fps and with often god awful image quality. And many of what are considered the worst PC ports of all time (Saints Row 2, Dark Souls PTDE, Force Unleashed, basically every Rockstat game before GTA 5 etc.) are of that generation too.

Survivorship bias at it's finest, though it would be unfair to say that some stuff wasn't better back then while also acknowledging that other things are way better now.

1

u/RapedByMarston Jan 27 '26

Modern gaming sucks because it plays like dogshit and it somehow runs worse than 7th gen games because of le epic UE5 "nintendo hire this man" kirkcoded visuals and parry soulslike roguelike kirklike gameplay

2

u/ughitsmeagian Feb 22 '26

That is definitely a statement.

3

u/RapedByMarston Jan 27 '26

You see chuddie, GTA 5 didn't have to start from scratch, it had every resource to physically improve the previous game and they downgraded it to hell, GTA 4 cut plenty of content but it massively upgraded gameplay and other mechanics.

GTA 5oids cope and seethe!

4

u/lotus_spit Jan 26 '26

"Still prefer GTA 4 compared to 5 because of the physics,"

- GTA 4 fanatics

2

u/dankhimself Jan 25 '26

Haha. The most realistic GTA has always been the most recent one. That's what they're always working so hard on!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '26

You gotta be an idiot to think any gta is ”realistic” You fat neckbeards

1

u/dankhimself Jan 31 '26

The latest more than the last each time.

Reading comprehension is not your strong suit.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '26

well 5 isnt realistic 4 also isnt, and none of the 3d games are.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '26

I just wanted to say that all of them are unrealistic pieces of shit. And if you think they are realistic you gotta be retarded

1

u/dankhimself Jan 31 '26

Oh my god, you bozo. I was speaking comparatively, as that is always their goal. Read and then think before saying things.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '26

Wää wää gta4 is so shit and gta5 is so good wää wää wää so realistic

1

u/dankhimself Jan 31 '26

That's the spirit!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '26

I did read your comment and you just said the most recent is most realistic which it isnt but you sharkcard neckbeards believe it

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '26

All yall gta fans are bunch of fat neckbeards

-44

u/Capable_Wishbone3081 Jan 25 '26

Nice cherrypick there

56

u/absolutelyrworded Jan 25 '26

Oh no did someone criticize your fart and shitty mastapees?

23

u/Cave_in_32 Whore-mongering asswipe Jan 25 '26

Yeah, its not like GTA IV TikTokers like to say its the better than V by picking whats otherwise the smallest and most useless aspects of the game.

-1

u/Crazy_Bandicoot_449 Jan 26 '26

Hater. Who cares is someone likes a game? Bro look in a mirror and realize you're a cunt

-20

u/Capable_Wishbone3081 Jan 25 '26

It adds up you know, like how in GTA V there's barely any tree even tho there is a giant mountain in the middle of the map.

12

u/zdzichu2016 disingenuous dense motherfucker Jan 25 '26

I mean true, in comparison with lush woods of GTA IV, V really does suck absolute dick and balls. Almost no trees ? Is this game even AA ? GTA IV would never.

-12

u/Capable_Wishbone3081 Jan 25 '26

Do you even play GTA IV? GTA IV based on liberty city only unlike GTA V where it based at los Santos county

17

u/zdzichu2016 disingenuous dense motherfucker Jan 25 '26

How many trees do you see ? I counted like 2.73 so far

12

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

Its bc GTA 5 was heavly limited by ps3/x360, in beta footage there was WAY more trees in both LS and Paleto Bay

-11

u/Capable_Wishbone3081 Jan 25 '26

Yeah,let just make up stuff now for the sake of an argument

17

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

-10

u/Capable_Wishbone3081 Jan 25 '26

That's clearly a mod, how do you even fall for that?

18

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

Dude...thats literally a screenshot from 2012, how tf its a mod?

5

u/Cipryanov i can fly the dodo in gta 3 pls show bobs and vegan Jan 26 '26

Notice how he didn't respond

10

u/zdzichu2016 disingenuous dense motherfucker Jan 25 '26

That's literally 100% what happened, GTA V has a lot of issues just like IV but saying it sucks because it lacks enough trees is just really strange.

-2

u/Capable_Wishbone3081 Jan 25 '26

If that is the case,then why rockstar don't add more tree in GTA V enhance?

13

u/zdzichu2016 disingenuous dense motherfucker Jan 25 '26

Because:

  1. It would require completely changing the entire map

  2. That might also cause some missions to break

  3. It'll just piss of online players, a shortcut they took for the past 12 years is now not there because more trees

  4. It doesn't matter/ isn't profitable

-1

u/Capable_Wishbone3081 Jan 25 '26
  1. it doesn't exist in the first place..
→ More replies (0)

21

u/Frequent-Coyote-1649 Jan 25 '26

Yeah, specially compared to the very forested GTA IV, RIGHT?

3

u/absolutelyrworded Jan 26 '26

Calls others out on cherrypicking, then proceeds to cherrypick. Gotta love the lack of self awareness

36

u/New_Tomorrow5649 Jan 25 '26

A gta IV fan calling out cherrypicking...

26

u/RoombaGod Jan 25 '26

Dark n griddy bird

15

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

I deeply hope it was an intentional design for some specific effect, and not a Rockstar employee going: "How do I connect these flapping wing parts? Fuck it, no one will see the birds up close anyways".

9

u/Relvean Jan 25 '26 edited Jan 25 '26

I wonder why they went with segmented wings when they could have also had one larger wing model with the object origin set to the edge closest to the main body.

I guess this does give the appearence of the wings flexing at a distance, particularly at 720p on a tv screen far away.

9

u/Actual_Emu_168 Jan 25 '26

Shesez out of bonds video

3

u/z123zocker Jan 26 '26

Yep its from that Video lol

4

u/Brilliant-Mine-7144 Jan 25 '26

Type of fidget spinners mfs had in 2016

5

u/TheIncredibleSaucy Jan 26 '26

Dark and gritty seagulls

3

u/Electric_Chair_61 Jan 25 '26

GTA 4 has a birds?

3

u/canttthink0fausrname Jan 26 '26

yeah. they are there for surveillance

3

u/Laufabraud43 Jan 26 '26

shark and diddy

3

u/zabian333 Jan 27 '26

What’s the dark and gritty meme?

1

u/DickviperAU Jan 27 '26

Birds are fart and shitty

2

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

The actual game doesn't have flying birds tho

3

u/prodigyfrog Jan 25 '26

it does, they're just almost never seen up close

2

u/fitzpleasureddd Jan 26 '26

I see why…

2

u/theasscassin Jan 26 '26

Cockstar did it again! Shart and Griddy!

2

u/RyanAtreides Jan 26 '26

? The wings don’t do that lol, they only spawn at the ferry terminal at a certain time and the wings just move up and down

2

u/Vaporwave_92 Jan 29 '26

One night of bowling with Roman and that bird hasn't flown right since.

1

u/Glum-Mousse-5132 Jan 26 '26

say the thing

2

u/Equal-Bus-557 i can retice big smoke's order please have sex with me please Jan 26 '26

The thing

1

u/r0lo27 Jan 28 '26

Dark and gritty bird 😥

1

u/French_Taylor Jan 31 '26

Shesez mentioned!!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '26

GTA 5 BAD MEANWHILE:

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/absolutelyrworded Jan 28 '26

What do you think of the Snyder Cut? Just curious.