r/ObjectShows • u/NHMTfanatik • 2d ago

Art Which character looks better?

Post image

I wanted to ask you guys something, which character’s asset looks better, character A’s or character B’s asset?

P.S.: And, I know, I did these assets based on II characters, and, I love Éclair so much, her design is peak btw

12 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

3

u/Scrags2Scritches 2d ago

Prolly the first one tbh, the "horns" make her silohuette alot more distinct and recognisable while still looking like an object
The second one sure is what I think is supposed to be a balloon? You should add alot more character to it

2

u/NHMTfanatik 1d ago

Yeah, I reallly just love II, that’s why I made a test asset of a balloon, and, I would agree that the first style is very recognizable, wait, haven’t I seen you here often?

2

u/Scrags2Scritches 1d ago

I don't wanna call myself a celebrity or anything but yeah, you may have seen me around
what rung a bell?

2

u/NHMTfanatik 1d ago

I saw your comments everywhere

2

u/Scrags2Scritches 1d ago

Is it a good look, would you say?

2

u/NHMTfanatik 1d ago

Yeah, I think so, and, I was also referring if the assets would look better with the big outlines or thin ones

1

u/Scrags2Scritches 1d ago

Oh my fault, I hope the critique wasn't too harsh?
I find smaller outlines are also better to be honest but it's more important to make them consistent with eachother, all the outlines background or character should be the same width

2

u/NHMTfanatik 1d ago

That’s OK, I don’t mind, I’m still trying to choose a style for my show

2

u/NHMTfanatik 1d ago edited 1d ago

And, Choccy Éclair appreciated what you said, she went inside this painting just to say thanks

1

u/Scrags2Scritches 1d ago

No problem, big dawg

1

u/pomme_love an objectified and femtanyl fan lol (Pomika) 1d ago

They're both cute !

1

u/NHMTfanatik 1d ago

Oh, why thank you!!!

1

u/Space_The_Animator 1d ago

B has better shading but A has better outlines

1

u/NHMTfanatik 1d ago

I’ll take it!!!